Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Remind me of your first choice again?

Oh, who was it. . . balaclaska k? Maybe? I dunno, I'm starting to sour on you a little bit anyway.

Visible votecount:
mr. incrediball (4): iamausername, Gremwell, populartajo, Alabaska J
Alabaska J (3): Riceballtail, Thesweatpantsninja, farside22
iamausername (3): somestrangeflea, Cream147, ashmite84
ashmite84 (2): Korts, Lord Gurgi
Cream147 (1): killa seven
somestrangeflea (1): Armlx
killa seven (1): goborage

Not voting (8): Phoebus, sideney, andersonw, DarlaBlueEyes, FaerieLord, Surye, skitzer, mr. incrediball

With 23 alive it takes 12 real votes to lynch.

[Lawrencelot]

I´m having a hard time finding replacements (the number of pages might have something to do with it). If you know people you think would be willing to replace, please pm me.

Even though you deserve some replacements, I´m gonna set a deadline for 1 week, that is about 4 weeks in total for this day, which should be enough.

Deadline: July 27, 9 PM GMT

[Lawrencelot]

Announcement: Gimbo is banned from the site. Therefore, I´m trying to find a replacement for him, as well as for malthusis, sideneye and some others.

[Lawrencelot]

DarlaBlueEyes replaces malthusis.

[DarlaBlueEyes]

Hello All!

Doing a speed read, and should post late this evening

[Riceballtail]

Hello All!

Doing a speed read, and should post late this evening

Speed read + this game = no

GL though! Also welcome.

[Cream147]

Yeah, I recommend you read this game right first time around. You don't want to be having to reread it again. Gimbo banned? Hmm...not sure whether to be happy or sad. Oh well!

[DarlaBlueEyes]

I'm working on it, I keep having to go back because the replacements are getting mixed up in my head.

Also just for my own sanity and continuity, other than gimbo have there been any claims?

[Riceballtail]

Yes. Claims have also come from myself, cream, and Rogue who has been lynched.

[ashmite84]

Okay,

unvote

first of all. Now, let's end the speculation, unless y'all don't want to.

Iam: If you like I can explain what farside saw? If this is what everyone wants I will.

Alternatively we can do a random dice roll of all the people who claimed to get it, and line them up to explain it. Then highest roller has to explain, if they do - semi-confirmed, if they don't they become suspicious. Then second, third etc. until someone gets it right.

[Alabaska J]

Okay,

unvote

first of all. Now, let's end the speculation, unless y'all don't want to.

Iam: If you like I can explain what farside saw? If this is what everyone wants I will.

Alternatively we can do a random dice roll of all the people who claimed to get it, and line them up to explain it. Then highest roller has to explain, if they do - semi-confirmed, if they don't they become suspicious. Then second, third etc. until someone gets it right.

What? This issue is over. We decided not to talk about it, remember? I have a good guess at what it might be, but I'm not sure and according to farside it would be bad for the town for it to be revealed so yeah not gonna happen. You seem to be a couple pages behind every time you post.

FoS: ashmite84

[ashmite84]

Okay,

unvote

first of all. Now, let's end the speculation, unless y'all don't want to.

Iam: If you like I can explain what farside saw? If this is what everyone wants I will.

Alternatively we can do a random dice roll of all the people who claimed to get it, and line them up to explain it. Then highest roller has to explain, if they do - semi-confirmed, if they don't they become suspicious. Then second, third etc. until someone gets it right.

What? This issue is over. We decided not to talk about it, remember? I have a good guess at what it might be, but I'm not sure and according to farside it would be bad for the town for it to be revealed so yeah not gonna happen. You seem to be a couple pages behind every time you post.

FoS: ashmite84

This was in response to Iam's post on the previous page.

[DarlaBlueEyes]

well, I am exhausted. I read the first 6 or so pages, and then skipped to the end of D1, and read all of D2.

A few notes (some of this may be old news to the active players)

My Town Category:

Populartajo (confirmed)
Cream
Farside

Scummys:

Alabaska
Riceball
iamusername

Unkown/undecided

Everyone else

I really dislike Alabaska's play, and his interactions with rice seem a bit distancey. Could be a null tell but I don't get a good feeling from them.

Rice is a bit less on the scumdar, but still several of his posts alerted me to something I didn't like.

Sorry for not quoting and such, had a busy day and a lot of reading to do

I support the Pop-coin-donation-protect/clear-grem/TSN thing, and am willing to donate my one coin if needed.


Will add more once I am better acquainted with this game, also where are we on the vote count? last I checked Iamusername was the main one right?

((OT: Psh. Its all about Jack Harkness!!))

[iamausername]

Iam: If you like I can explain what farside saw?

I think the best idea is to not discuss it any further until someone is at L-2 or so and has to claim. This way, if they're scum, they won't be able to claim Toad without being able to explain it, so they'd either have to make up a different fake claim, or take a guess at what farside saw. If they're really a Toad, they'll be able to explain it pretty easily, and so we'll confirm another townie.

Darla, am I on your scum list for any reason other than that I'm leading in the votecount? (Pretty sure I'm actually not, btw, mr. incrediball is the new wagon in town. And it's way cooler than the last one.)

[Lawrencelot]

Lord Gurgi replaces Gimbo

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

I think the best idea is to not discuss it any further until someone is at L-2 or so and has to claim. This way, if they're scum, they won't be able to claim Toad without being able to explain it, so they'd either have to make up a different fake claim, or take a guess at what farside saw. If they're really a Toad, they'll be able to explain it pretty easily, and so we'll confirm another townie.

Iamausername, regardless of his scumminess, has the right idea about this situation.

[farside22]

Iam: If you like I can explain what farside saw?

I think the best idea is to not discuss it any further until someone is at L-2 or so and has to claim. This way, if they're scum, they won't be able to claim Toad without being able to explain it, so they'd either have to make up a different fake claim, or take a guess at what farside saw. If they're really a Toad, they'll be able to explain it pretty easily, and so we'll confirm another townie.

Darla, am I on your scum list for any reason other than that I'm leading in the votecount? (Pretty sure I'm actually not, btw, mr. incrediball is the new wagon in town. And it's way cooler than the last one.)

I think unless someone is under pressure and claims Toad should it only then be discussed. If someone is claiming anything but Toad this subject should be closed till such time as needed. I would rather keep the scum on their toes thank you.

[Lawrencelot]

Syzygy replaces sideney

[Syzygy]

whopee! y'all, i followed this game for a pretty long time

anyways, kudos to iamusername, nice job!

btw, can't the scums kill one of Grem or TSN tonight? I mean, if they don't want confirmed townies, that's optimal. Therefore, the star tonight really only gets us 1 confirmed townie at best.

In addition, I say that we NOT check Grem/TSN's alignment tonight. If Grem was anything BUT town, why would he ask to be checked? Therefore if he is town, TSN is equally cleared. I'm willing to take Grem's word since he is most likely townie, We could better use the 8 coins to check new targets, no?

alright

Vote: mr.incrediball

[armlx]

btw, can't the scums kill one of Grem or TSN tonight? I mean, if they don't want confirmed townies, that's optimal. Therefore, the star tonight really only gets us 1 confirmed townie at best.

They could, but where does that get them?

If Grem was anything BUT town, why would he ask to be checked?

http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=WIFOM

[Syzygy]

yea I know WIFOM....but that's a reach, isn't it?

[armlx]

yea I know WIFOM....but that's a reach, isn't it?

Not really.

[Riceballtail]

yea I know WIFOM....but that's a reach, isn't it?

No. I also think Grem is town, but it never hurts to make a confirmation.

Also, we really need to lynch before deadline this time, and see about some votes.

[Lord Gurgi]

Hello peeps, I already reread, top of my scumlist is cream. For a lot of reasons that the town in general has already pointed out and because, way back when, he said:

Vote: Gimbo. By the way Gimbo, saying the word 'fuck' so excessively is in no way cool, but it is quite annoying. And remember,

if the town lose, you lose

Why on earth would you vote someone you know is town Cream? Further, how do you know he's town? That and I think that his claim does not exclude him from suspicion.

Second on my list is AlabaskaJ, for a lot of reasons, mostly game behaviour in general.

Third is split between Darla and Syzygy.

Also, no I'm not going to do a PBPA.

PS: Gimbo... -_-

[Cream147]

Hello peeps, I already reread, top of my scumlist is cream. For a lot of reasons that the town in general has already pointed out and because, way back when, he said:

Vote: Gimbo. By the way Gimbo, saying the word 'fuck' so excessively is in no way cool, but it is quite annoying. And remember,

if the town lose, you lose

Why on earth would you vote someone you know is town Cream? Further, how do you know he's town? That and I think that his claim does not exclude him from suspicion.

Slips are over-rated.