BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[Auro]

Chronos, why did you appoint yourself Flip's laywer?

You can wait until after getting an answer to this, but how is this a useful question?

[Chronos]

Who knows

[Titus]

Who knows

So you're randomly advising people on how to defend themselves and don't know why you're doing it?

[Titus]

I gtg to work.

[Auro]

H...H-...Hello!

Oh I am so sorry for how I lashed out at jjh earlier, I’m such a naughty person~

I don’t want the others to feel like I’m so aggressive, I’m just here to make friends...

But Vecna talking about spreading Corona is scaring me

I...don’t know if my reaction there was justified...But I guess I don’t require some hefty punishment unless I’m wrong about my assumptions on jjh...

I kind of feel bad for going so aggressive, can’t help it OwO

As your appointed lawyer, I suggest you plead the fifth on that one Mr Flip.

@Titus: Does reading the earlier two posts from Chronos change how you interpret her lawyer one?

[davesaz]

@Kakeguri: it is strongly my belief that alignment is not randomised prior to role creation, and that someone who wanted to be scum could influence role allocation by picking scum only roles for the Booneytoonz list, or quotes from players from games where they were scum, etc.

Your strong belief is wrong. Undivulged non-randomness is bastard. Alignment is assumed to be randomised.

Upicks are inherently non random.

UPick ROLES are inherently non-random, but this does not include alignment

What happens if someone picks Traitor, Framer, SK as their picks? How can they possibly end up town?

I agree with this.

[davesaz]

What's interesting it that nobody has ever given a shit about me explaining things in detail before. Because it's kinda dumb to think town!me isn't gonna give a full explanation for something when there os one and there's someone asking for an explanation, and there's no downside to me explaining it. I'd like those who think that post I made was weird to read it with context and explain why they think it's weird outside of this idea that I can explain my thought process.

Dave has played with me before. He doesn't get a free pass.
VOTE: davesaz

Interesting you vote me for something I noticed during catchup, but didn't refer to anyone else who made the same observation about it being a lot of explanation. It's also interesting to note that I specifically said that I didn't remember the context (and still don't). So you'd like to have it looked at in context -- fine, that's part of the plan anyway.

[davesaz]

If he was scum who could "cancerously millerize" town and neuter cops, why even claim it?

Although this is not a great argument, my spreading virus does in fact not tell the infected people what it does. Just that they have to spread it.

Sounds a lot like a survivor role. Does your wincon say a you win when a majority has it?

[davesaz]

This seems like an awful lot of explanation for such an early point in the game.

I'm impressed, there actually was a reason that 100 needed that much detail that early.

[Krazy Katz]

Town traitor -- u are informed that x is aligned with the town. You cannot join any pts

Town serial killer -- you can kill a player at night. You must both survive to the end of the game and see town win the game

Compulsive town framer -- each night you must tsrget a player. That player will appear as mafia aligned to any cops

any role can be town by putting the word 'town' in the role pm

-K

[davesaz]

This is different than a normal upick, because you usually get your flavor as your role. Here, I will use your picks to influence the design of your role, allowing for some extra depth.

I believe that Boon said right up front that he is influencing the design. In particular it's not a

normal

upick. I wouldn't put it past him to flaunt the definition of mod influence all the way to allowing the design to influence alignment. Yes it could be considered bastard by some, but he did kinda announce what he was doing.

[Krazy Katz]

Sure but if he wasn't using any discretion or randomization then I'd have the dayvig from LNT right now

-K

[Krazy Katz]

Unless someone else also top picked the dayvig I guess?

-K

[Vecna]

If he was scum who could "cancerously millerize" town and neuter cops, why even claim it?

Although this is not a great argument, my spreading virus does in fact not tell the infected people what it does. Just that they have to spread it.

Sounds a lot like a survivor role. Does your wincon say a you win when a majority has it?

You think id propose a plan to have two people continue to spread it in a circle between them if that was my mission?

[Krazy Katz]

But since it wasn't even on a proper rolecard I was thinking that was unlikely, and he either decided dayvig was too strong for town or he didn't want a dayvig at all

-K

[Krazy Katz]

The people you infect only have to target one person with it, not two?

-K

[Chronos]

I'll be observing until this mech talk goes away, not my thing.

[Krazy Katz]

Chronos you should vote fonz to make up for your earlier naughtiness

-K

[Vecna]

plenty of other things to talk about chronos

[Chronos]

Why should I vote Fonzie?

[Krazy Katz]

His townplay isn't usually this underwhelming

Is there a better vote?

-K

[Auro]

VOTE: The Fonz
Baa, baa

[Vecna]

The people you infect only have to target one person with it, not two?

-K

Yes just one

[Chronos]

I haven't seen anything to make me change my mind on jjh and I think it's worthy of a push.

I don't have a metric for Fonz's townplay so I'll need a lot more than that. He seems fine thus far.

[Krazy Katz]

Shiro is aware the game began right? Like even if nancy is taking a break the slot should not be silent?

-K