Really Bad Idea Mafia - Game Over

[chenhsi]

Oh. Never mind, didn't notice that.

[forbiddanlight]

Decided that with the GF dead and so few unconfirmed

I'm a cop:

the following are innocent:

12. Sir Tornado
32. The Jester
28. Query
23. Erratus Apathos

felt like at this point losing 1 cop was good for confiming four innocents

You are cleared for the username kill

[Query]

Anybody else you'd like me to dispose of?

[forbiddanlight]

Wait, let me check again something.

[chenhsi]

One at a time, kill username first.

[chenhsi]

Oh, did username replace torando? never mind again

[Query]

To clarify: Tornado = username

[chenhsi]

Yeah, so I'm not sure. Thheortically everyone is cleared, but...

[Query]

Can we post a list of people that have killed or have been cleared by confirmed cops?

[forbiddanlight]

2. somestrangeflea - shot a bullet
7. forbiddanlight - shot a bullet
8. goborage - shot a bullet
12. iamausername - cop confirm
17. chenhsi - shot a bullet
18. Natirasha - shot a bullet
23. Erratus Apathos - shot a bullet and cop confirmed
26. M4yhem - shot a bullet
28. Query - cop confirm
31. Xtoxm - shot a bullet
38. Grimmy - shot a bullet

Shoot anyone on this list. We know Niv was a cop, and we have no one non confirmed. Shoot anyone.

[Query]

...or is that everybody?

[forbiddanlight]

Shoot anyone. We have another shooting scum, likely GF.

[chenhsi]

I would personally kill forbiddenlight or one of the other people who killed a scum, especially if he is a scum with a shooting power.

Or maybe we have 1 (or 2) SK left, in which case we should kill everyone cleared by the cop first (since cop inspects for scum, not sk?)

[Query]

Two godfathers?

[forbiddanlight]

I would personally kill forbiddenlight or one of the other people who killed a scum, especially if he is a scum with a shooting power.

Honestly, I'm probably both the most innocent and the least confirmed. Considering this is the obvious result of my kill if I knew another Godfather would step up, it'd screw us in the long run. I personally could see Xtoxm being shot.

[chenhsi]

No, I meant if they were a scum with a shooting power, but not a godfather, they could kill 1 of the other scum to pretend they were town.

[forbiddanlight]

Two godfathers?

Our mod is a bastard.

[Query]

Have there been SKs in previous "Bad Ideas"?

[chenhsi]

So which do you think is more likiely forbidden: SK or shooting scum? OR some other investigate-immune?

[forbiddanlight]

No, I meant if they were a scum with a shooting power, but not a godfather, they could kill 1 of the other scum to pretend they were town.

Possible, but odd. Honestly, I could see either solution. Either way, killing me will be worthless. I don't know how much attrition we have left.

[forbiddanlight]

So which do you think is more likiely forbidden: SK or shooting scum? OR some other investigate-immune?

I personally like the theory we had a goon that was promoted to Godfather when the godfather died. This makes a lot of sense since the GF died first. I'm more willing to believe people who shot after I killed the GF are scum.

[M4yhem]

Don't shoot anyone until everyone has checked in please, Query. Let's have a proper talk first.

My notes:
2. somestrangeflea –killed mafia goon
7. forbiddanlight –shot godfather
8. goborage –killed town
12. Sir Tornado iamausername-cleared by cop (could be godfather?)
17. chenhsi –killed town
18. Natirasha –killed town, TDC (maf) ‘vote natirasha to kill natirasha’
23. Erratus Apathos –killed Mafia cleared by cop
26. M4yhem –killed town
28. Query ?
31. Xtoxm –killed town
38. Grimmy-killed town, Fonz (mafia) calls him town

I think Iamusername could be godfather.

[chenhsi]

In both of the other bad idea games, the godfather survived the entire game and won, so we don't know about promotions.

Yeah, forbidden makes sense too. It's really up to you, Query.

[Query]

Not truly confirmed people (killed townies):

8. goborage - shot a bullet
17. chenhsi - shot a bullet
18. Natirasha - shot a bullet
26. M4yhem - shot a bullet
31. Xtoxm - shot a bullet
38. Grimmy - shot a bullet

[M4yhem]

I personally like the theory we had a goon that was promoted to Godfather when the godfather died. This makes a lot of sense since the GF died first. I'm more willing to believe people who shot after I killed the GF are scum.

That's everybody still living, who shot someone. I checked.