Really Bad Idea Mafia - Game Over

[forbiddanlight]

And obviously, noone but Query or Iam should shoot today. I'd also really like everyone to make at least one post saying who they want shot before we go to night.

You want I am shot then, right?

[chenhsi]

Curious, but why are you so certain that Erratus and query aren't scum?

[forbiddanlight]

Curious, but why are you so certain that Erratus and query aren't scum?

Me? Well, Query could be scum. I want to see him shoot first. I also said that Erratus could be suspect for being the Godfather, since killing mafia is a good long term strategy.

[chenhsi]

Well, I mostly meant M4yhem, but you too.

[Query]

And obviously,

noone but Query or Iam should shoot today

. I'd also really like everyone to make at least one post saying who they want shot before we go to night.

Won't the first of us to be online shoot the other? I'm being courteous right now, but who's to say my companion will be?

[chenhsi]

I think that since the chance of having 2 godfathers is most likely, nothing we do can clear anyone, the only thing we can do is kill everyone

[Query]

That most certainly isn't the most likely setup.

[chenhsi]

I meant a goon replacing the godfather.

[Query]

Really? I think you just want everyone to go crazy and start shooting.

[chenhsi]

In which case I'll probably die first.

[Query]

Not if everyone abide's M4yhem's rule.

[Query]

EBWOP: abides

[M4yhem]

I'm hoping if I ask nicely, you'll both wait. So please, please, Iamusername, don't shoot query till everyone checks in. Same for you, Query.

This supports the idea that scum got promoted and they want to avoid confirmeds.

Or they want us to think they got promoted. I know, I know, WIFOM. But it's possible.

I'm cop confirmed, dude.

Sorry, I missed that. But Godfathers show as innocent anyway so till you shoot somebody, you're suspect. And afterwards too, actually. Everyone's a suspect now.

You want I am shot then, right?

Yes, unless he shoots query. We need the two non-shooters eliminated before we look at the shooters again.

Curious, but why are you so certain that Erratus and query aren't scum?

Erratus shot someone. Traditionally in this game, the godfather can't shoot. Since query is eager to kill, I don't think he's godfather. Obviously, if he doesn't kill for a few days, my view will change.

[chenhsi]

What about his rule? He said that only you or erratus should shoot today. He also said we should say who we think is scum. Not that we should shoot whoever gets the most votes.

[forbiddanlight]

Agree with Query. Right now, while this game is one of the most random you will ever play, the time has come to use a bit of logic. Even 1 day worth of it might be enough.

[chenhsi]

Traditionally in this game, the godfather can't shoot.

Where does it say that?

[forbiddanlight]

Erratus shot someone. Traditionally in this game, the godfather can't shoot. Since query is eager to kill, I don't think he's godfather. Obviously, if he doesn't kill for a few days, my view will change.

Wrong. Godfather's CAN shoot in bad idea. They are the only scum that can, which is what makes them so powerful.

[chenhsi]

Exactly my point. Even you said it yourself:

Sorry, I missed that. But Godfathers show as innocent anyway so till you shoot somebody, you're suspect.

And afterwards too, actually.

Everyone's a suspect now.

[chenhsi]

I am finding M4yhem VERY suspicious right now unless he can explain his obvious contradiction.

[forbiddanlight]

I am finding M4yhem VERY suspicious right now unless he can explain his obvious contradiction.

Never thought I'd say this, but I agree with chenhsi.

[M4yhem]

I thought goons could shoot and godfathers show as innocent because that seems an obvious way to balance things.

Otherwise, it seems like it sucks to be a goon.

So I guess that means there's no way there are any goons left, only a godfather?

[forbiddanlight]

I thought goons could shoot and godfathers show as innocent because that seems an obvious way to balance things.

Otherwise, it seems like it sucks to be a goon.

So I guess that means there's no way there are any goons left, only a godfather?

Goons are meat shields for Godfathers basically. The assumption is by this point in the game, you've gone through all the goons. They served their purpose because now the Godfather is hidden amongst a confirmed group. In theory, my killing the GF D4 SHOULD have locked the game. Clearly the mod wasn't too keen on that. I'm assuming one godfather left and no goons.

[M4yhem]

Okay, so shooting won't work anymore.

Query and Iam can't be goons, because they are cop cleared, so I guess it doesn't matter who does the shooting.

In that case, I suggest Natirasha to die, because TDC made a joke about him shooting himself, which might be a form of distancing. And he weirds me out

Chensi also kind of rings my bell but he might just be an overeager townie.

Forbidden- who do you want shot? (Same question to everyone else, really.)

[forbiddanlight]

Forbidden- who do you want shot? (Same question to everyone else, really.)

Chen or iam can be shot in my opinion.

In that case, I suggest Natirasha to die, because TDC made a joke about him shooting himself, which might be a form of distancing. And he weirds me out

I doubt this. Natirasha is known for self voting, so self shooting is not much of a stretch.

[forbiddanlight]

Query and Iam can't be goons, because they are cop cleared, so I guess it doesn't matter who does the shooting.

This.