Her. And it wasn't my fault the thread wasn't locked and I had to deal with some really rather clever WIFOM. If you are willing to wait for 48 hours, I'm willing to see if this girl can get lucky twice. (actually, it's not really luck at this point, though that is a factor. It's basically trained guessing now)But stupid forbidden made it so that he can't shoot for $* HOURS!!!
Otherwise, I would have asked him to shoot.
This is what I don't like (not just because it's INTENTS AND PURPOSES, DAMMIT). I assume he's saying this because:Natirasha wrote:And, for the record, I have practically shot for all intensive purposes in the first three pages.
(Posted on a Monday, fyi).Natirasha wrote:I agree with everything Grimmy said. Except I have dibs. And I will be killing Thursday. Think of it as a deadline for dayonetwo.
Too Townieforbiddanlight wrote:This is possible. Also, Erratus too. Cleared by cop and killed scum. Might be an attempt to look confirmed.
I think Iamusername could be godfather.
chenhsi wrote:I would personally kill forbiddenlight or one of the other people who killed a scum, especially if he is a scum with a shooting power.
Too Towniechenhsi wrote:No, I meant if they were a scum with a shooting power, but not a godfather, they could kill 1 of the other scum to pretend they were town.
forbiddanlight wrote:I personally like the theory we had a goon that was promoted to Godfather when the godfather died.
chenhsi wrote:*sigh*
I would say forbidden isn't scum, since most likely there isn't any day-kill powers other than town + gf, and forbidden killed the gf, and so forbidden couldnt be the gf, unless there are 2+ gfs, which is unlikely.
Query wrote:He's most likely to be town. 2 GFs at the beginning is quite unlikely.
Rather than citing mini-normal balance guidelines in a forty-player Bad Idea, Tarhalindur brings up actual evidence pointing to a backup GF, that being that Xtoxm acted like one. Not only do I agree with Tar here, but I don't care for the way Xtoxm tried to play both sides of the "lurking = scummy" argument at various points this game. He's definitely my top suspect, followed by chenhsi, Query, and forbiddan in that order.Tarhalindur wrote:I don't think it's inconceivable that we have another Godfather lying around somewhere. I'm going to make an intuitive leap here and say that, if said Godfather exists, his name is probably Xtoxm (brought up the BOGUS "Godfather is dead, so Mafia can't have a daykill" argument and killed Day 5 - read "immediately after the first Godfather died).
Not on MS (but I only have one complete game anyway). Actually, I tend to be lynched rather early but usually conclude who the scum are (or already have) after I've died. It's useless but tends to be the case. Also the fact most games I play are cardflip off (i.e, roles not revealed on death), makes things rather interesting for trained guessing, lol. But, let's see...I've probably won as town (if you count town winning even though I'm NK'd/lynched) in about half the games I've played (as town), which is around 20ish games. So, just depends on how you want to take that.
Forbiddenlight- forgive me for asking but have you ever won as town? I'm just wondering how good your 'trained guessing' really is. You did get the godfather, which is (much) better than I've done so far but I'm still curious.
Um...probably not. The reason we have a lot of cops is because they drop like flies in this game. I suppose it's possible, but a read of the last Bad Idea Mafia shows sane cops.
With so many cops, we should probably be considering sanity...
Fair enough, I was unfamiliar with the too townie argument. I was also saying it was possible. I prefer chen for being hung on an SK. It might be safest to shoot I am anyway. He might be the GF trying to pass as a cop, though this is completely WIFOMable. Town's decision really, I'm ambivalent.
What other options did I have anyways? Niv clearing me wasn't exactly my choice, and killing anyone other than The Fonz yesterday would be utterly retarded.
Haha, baseless guesswork killed the first GF if we have more than one
FoS: all of the above for baseless guesswork.
.I'd like to think so. As far as I'm concerned, we have one, maybe 2 scum left at most. If killing me assauges anyone's fears, so be it. I'd prefer that we kill scum though. How many hours has it been since Day start?
I suppose that the 2GF setup is possible, but since forbidden is only even possibly scum if that's the case, I'd say she has a higher chance of being townie. However, I agree with Erratus concerning Xtoxm.
If I remember correctly one. Ok, point taken. I still don't think with Godfathers that the mod would have insane cops. Only way to really check though is by making sure everyone has shot or been shot eventually.How many GFs did this read show?
It's possible that either (or indeed, both) of Query and iamausername is a Goon, if Niv is Naive. Given the nature of Niv's results, Niv cannot be an insane cop, but he can be naive. We need to determine if it's likely.forbiddanlight wrote:If I remember correctly one. Ok, point taken. I still don't think with Godfathers that the mod would have insane cops.How many GFs did this read show?
Have query kill iam. I'm fine with that.It's possible that either (or indeed, both) of Query and iamausername is a Goon, if Niv is Naive. Given the nature of Niv's results, Niv cannot be an insane cop, but he can be naive. We need to determine if it's likely.
Um, what?!forbiddanlight wrote:Have query kill iam. I'm fine with that.It's possible that either (or indeed, both) of Query and iamausername is a Goon, if Niv is Naive. Given the nature of Niv's results, Niv cannot be an insane cop, but he can be naive. We need to determine if it's likely.