Really Bad Idea Mafia - Game Over

[forbiddanlight]

Well, i'd really rather not consider killing a cop unless everyone has cop-inno's on them, in that case.

I didn't realise there were only sane cops in the last one...I think it would probably follow that again...

Glad you see my point. We had to decide to kill someone eventually. Because if 48 hours pass, I'm taking my shot. And I hope I hit a Godfather again assuming we have multiples.

[M4yhem]

I'd prefer it if query did the killing.

Let's wait till the remaining players have spoken up and then he can shoot Natirasha or whoever else the majority says is scummy.

[Natirasha]

Why me?

I can assure you, considering the fact I was gone for 2 weeks(or, days 4-14) I would have been absolutely useless to me scumteam.

[M4yhem]

There was a missed kill at some point so that arguement reeally doesn't help you.

[forbiddanlight]

There was a missed kill at some point so that arguement reeally doesn't help you.

This is a good point. Feeling real good about a Nati kill.

[M4yhem]

It was day 13 that had no kill, which fits in nicely.

Also 'I wouldn't have been useful' is a bad arguement anyway because it doesn't mean you are not scum, it just means you're useless.

Shoot him, Query.

[somestrangeflea]

I was gone for 2 weeks(or, days 4-14)

Your Day 12 kill says otherwise.

It was day 13 that had no kill, which fits in nicely

It was Night 12 that had no kill. Natirasha killed immediately before scum didn't.

[Query]

If the majority wants me to kill Nat, I will. What's the verdict?

[Xtoxm]

Yes. 24 hours have passed, if you wanna do it hurry up...

[Query]

Fine. Enough people seem to agree.

Kill: Natirasha

[forbiddanlight]

Hope we win.

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

Natirasha, a townie, killed by Query during Day 15

Night 15

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

Iamausername, a cop, shot to hell during Night 15

Day 16

People who have to wait 24 hours to kill:
Xtoxm
somestrangeflea
Grimmy
M4yhem
chenhsi
goborage
Erratus Apathos
Query

People who have to wait 48 hours to kill:
forbiddanlight

[M4yhem]

Kaleidoscope, Natirasha's dead. He'll never kill again.

Sorry to be picky but I thought you'd want to know.

Okay, so I lost my patience yesterday. This day, we really should wait for everyone to post before killing. Especially Grimmy.

I'm glad the cop is dead, because I was going to suggest killing him today, in case he was saving a kill for the endgame.

I suspect: Grimmy, for being quiet and because Fonz said he was town, Xtoxm because of the case made against him yesterday and chensi for not always making sense.

I'd like everybody to answer the following questions:
Who do you think should be killed today?
Who should do the killing? (It's best to get whoever is the second most suspected to kill, so that they are behind the 'townie' players ion terms of time till shooting in the endgame.
Who should not be shot?

My answers at the moment:
Grimmy to kill Xtoxm
No shooting Forbiddenlight or Flea.

[forbiddanlight]

Who do you think should be killed today? chen or Xtoxm
Who should do the killing? Aww, I wanted to kill...but fine, Xtox kills chen
Who should not be shot? No one should be immune.

[chenhsi]

Who do you think should be killed today? not sure
Who should do the killing? forbidden
Who should not be shot? forbidden or me

[Erratus Apathos]

Goborage must die if he doesn't post soon, otherwise I still prefer a more swiss-cheese-resembling Xtoxm. If it's Xtoxm getting shot, I'd rather Chenhsi shot him; else Xtoxm should shoot.

As far as who shouldn't be killed, I have town reads on M4yhem and somestrangeflea. Forbiddanlight needn't be shot today, since her longer delay gives us more freedom to kill her closer to endgame than we have with anyone else.

[forbiddanlight]

Forbiddanlight needn't be shot today, since her longer delay gives us more freedom to kill her closer to endgame than we have with anyone else.

Yep, though I still am trigger happy. If I EVER reach 48 hours, I'm shooting again.

[Xtoxm]

Not cop cleared:

Forbinanlight
Somestrangeflea
Goborage
Mayhem

If this follows the same pattern as the last game, (ie, 1 GF and all sane cops), then the last scum are in these.

I really don't understand why so many people want me dead.

I will shoot one of them if 24 hours is reached.

[forbiddanlight]

If this follows the same pattern as the last game, (ie, 1 GF and all sane cops), then the last scum are in these.

One problem, by that same logic EVERYONE is cleared. If it follows the same pattern as last game, goons can't shoot. Meaning there has to be at least one shooting scum (which would be new), or multiple godfathers.

[Xtoxm]

Yeh that is a good point actually.

[M4yhem]

Since we've all shot at least once, there has to be a godfather so cop results mean nothing now. Unless there's a modified goon role but there's no way of knowing that.

KaleiÐoscøpe

: Please can we have prods on Grimmy and Goborage? Thank you.

[Query]

Who do you think should be killed today? not sure
Who should do the killing? forbidden
Who should not be shot? forbidden or me

Why forbiddanlight? Since her scuminess depends on there being 2 godfathers rather than one, she is the most likely to be townie. Everyone else could be townie if there were 2 GFs or a replacement GF.

[chenhsi]

No, since I think that the possibility of a goon replacing a gf is most likely, a goon couldnt have shot the gf, so forbidden couldn't be the gf.

I think that the chances of having 2 gfs is really small.

[Query]

Nevermind, I misread your post. I thought you were advocating the killing of forbiddanlight.