Mini Theme 2412: Gacha Mafia

[Isis]

Votecount 2.2

GeorgeBailey

'--- (1) Titus

Hoctac

-----------

Dunnstral

-------- (2) GeorgeBailey, Hoctac

Elements

.--------

shiki

----

Pigman

---------- (1) Elements

Titus

-------------

Not voting (3): Dunnstral, shiki, Pigman

Lynching deadline:(expired on 2020-06-13 21:59:59)

Replacement and aliases reference

PINNED:

Elena Fisher

---

GeorgeBailey
Hoctac
Dunnstral
Elements
shiki
Pigman
Titus

Spoiler: NK Cheat Sheet

- Lone scum picks someone to become an IC OR scummates have to perform shots that put the game into 3p LyLo
- Democratic public cop

- Bet the game on voting on two townies correctly

- Scummates fall in love

- Oops! Reveal the alignment of every player colored similarly to murder victims.

Elements flew around the park, hopping and gliding to find the best person to get stones from. Physical force hadn't worked last time. But Elements was flexible, time to try something different.
He should do something unique to his status as a supreme adventure ending dungeon boss.
"Pigman!" Elements exclaimed. He glided next to what was apparently a fertile goddess holding his companion pig. "Yes?" Pigman asked, holding Juryo a little closer.
"Pigman, you are my favorite. I really like you. So I have a proposition to offer you. I'm a dungeon boss, I'm so strong I have MILLIONs of HP and strong attacks.
I can get you strong too. You may not have wings, or fangs, or a poison stinger, but you have something. You have a pig to ride. So I know if you and him both buff up, you can become just as strong as Zhu Bhaije, my other dungeon boss friend! He and his piggie are so strong that any adventurers he fights he charges them and knocks them down to ONE HP, even if they had thousands! Now, for some reason, he always follows that up by eating a snack, that is not exactly the wisest follow up. But, you're already smarter than that, so if you train with me you can be smart

and

strong and beat everybody! All I'm asking is for three magic stones up front and one magic stone per session."
Pigman seems reluctant. He was very interested up until the part where he needed to spend precious magic stones. "Hm, I can think about it."
"Look at how much your pig wants it! He wants to become

SWOLE

. How can you deny such a cute companion his heart's desire??"
Elements' comment did not seem particularly burdened by reality. Juryo had wriggled out of Pigman's grip during the conversation, and was currently wallowing in mud. He let out a piggish squeal meant to indicate how delightful the mud felt to him.
"As a manticore, I can translate that for you, and I promise to do so honestly..."

[GeorgeBailey]

Elena said Elements is likely scum in the PT.

@Hoctac, What's your current read on him?

Dunn's response so far to being pushed is giving a town block, and townreading me. I think this is probably low-activity rather thank lurker scum.

I think what discerns between the two is that Lurker scum would be feeling pressured to vote right now.

I have a feeling it's Elements currently, but I think voting outside of the Pepper wagon is too risky. By PoE 1 of Shiki/Dunn is scum to me.

[Hoctac]

Not great, he's kind of just done nothing today. Honestly, I feel deep inside my amygdala that it's shiki, both from Misty's play and her play. But several people seem to townread her lol. Also worth mentioning, is that the lack of motivation from both Misty/shiki could also be part due to not having daychat. Honestly, they should just invite me to a hood and we could make a new daychat but

shrug

.

My working townbloc is Hoctic, GeorgeBailey, Pigman. Pigman's appeal to Titus for help seemed genuine, and I've explained why not knowing what the disable daytalk egg did is town-indicative.

Dunny also seems to have no interest in this game. And his best explanation for who he wants to lynch is a "IDK". Not all of these people can be scum.

[Hoctac]

Dunny, shiki, and Pigman, you've some lost, lonely votes there. They're just looking for a place to stay and they're so, so afraid. Find them homes.

[Hoctac]

Pigman, do you think Juryo could leave your care and become a player to occupy a new slot? We'd be adding a townie to our ranks I think. What do ya reckon?

[Hoctac]

VOTE: Elements

Dunny at least gave me a shameless answer which I could see coming from town while Elements has just started lurking and ignoring my questions.

[shiki]

I have a feeling it's Elements currently, but I think voting outside of the Pepper wagon is too risky. By PoE 1 of Shiki/Dunn is scum to me.

i think scum would have been resistant to lynching doctorpepper and those off the wagon (elements, pigman, titus) are most suspicious. i really don't think scum!dunnstral would cut himself off from beneficial options by staying on doctorpepper when he could have moved to pigman at end of day. it only really makes sense to me if you or pigman were his partner, like i said before. you seem quite towny to me. the pigman associative is strengthened by the egg throw so it lingers in my mind. however, he landed on doctorpepper after going over the setup before there was a pigman wagon so it seems more likely he is town to me.

VOTE: elements

[Hoctac]

What makes you believe scum would've been resistant to lynching the good old Doctor?

my reads at this time look something like:

elena fisher, hoctac
dunnstral, elements, georgebailey, pigman
doctorpepper, titus

How have your reads changed from this?

[shiki]

What makes you believe scum would've been resistant to lynching the good old Doctor?

his typing (heart, sword) would give the mafia access to the most beneficial options to nightkill.

How have your reads changed from this?

an updated readslist:

georgebailey, hoctic
dunnstral, pigman
elements, titus

[Hoctac]

That's true, but it depends on the team and their priorities. They can't get an

OOPs

now.

I was thinking if both Elena and I decided to activate night 1, they would have a clean path into getting an

OOPs

by night killing us consecutively. They'd of course need to lynch one of Titus or GeorgeBailey though and the other would also need to be town for that to be good (since solo colours get alignment revealed)... there's a lot of factors involved.

[Hoctac]

Thanks for calling me, Hoctic; I appreciate it <3

What made Ele drop a tier?

[Hoctac]

A needless comma snuck into my post there. Don't allow it to bamboozle you.

[shiki]

That's true, but it depends on the team and their priorities. They can't get an

OOPs

now.

I was thinking if both Elena and I decided to activate night 1, they would have a clean path into getting an

OOPs

by night killing us consecutively. They'd of course need to lynch one of Titus or GeorgeBailey though and the other would also need to be town for that to be good (since solo colours get alignment revealed)... there's a lot of factors involved.

do you disagree that dunnstral would prioritize that?

working out what you meant here is proving difficult. i assume elena should be titus, but even then i don't think i'm following.

What made Ele drop a tier?

his vote on me seemed like it was to get me lynched instead of doctorpepper.

[Hoctac]

Oh yeah, I meant Titus.

Basically, Titus or I activating on night 1 is always bad as long as our opposite counterparts (Elena and DoctorWater) are alive.

Are you saying you value the healer and physical abilities less? I think they're all potentially the best/worst depending on situations. Like, if we have 1 obvtown, it makes the healers a lot better. If we have 1 obvscum, it makes the physicals a lot better.

[shiki]

Are you saying you value the healer and physical abilities less? I think they're all potentially the best/worst depending on situations. Like, if we have 1 obvtown, it makes the healers a lot better. If we have 1 obvscum, it makes the physicals a lot better.

? i am saying that i think mafia, or at least dunnstral as mafia, would have wanted to kill the heart/sword if available to them. it would have given them the option to choose between killing another heart the next night if they were both still alive or killing a sword if one of them were lynched.

[Hoctac]

I seeeeeeeee. Damn, I must've looked stupid when I PMed my night 1 setupspec to Isis. I guess I probably should've activated last night, but clearly I calculated that scum wouldn't take the risk.

Fear e nuff

[Hoctac]

I would like to use [Team Rocket Queen] as a nickname for shiki.

I would like to use [The Periodic Table] as a nickname for Elements

.

shiki, if you're really going to pocket me, could you at least lend me a hand here?

[GeorgeBailey]

I'll lend you a hand catcoh

VOTE: Elements

[GeorgeBailey]

That's L-1 btw.

Shamefully sheeping Elena rn.

I think this is better than Dunn right now.

[Elements]

don't sheep elena she has bad reads.
This is exactly what happened in the mini Hoctic. Scum killed the person who scumread me and then pushed my lynch.
VOTE: georgebailey

[Titus]

Hey, I am going to point out the obvious. Everyone I try to work with is getting fucking wagoned. Maybe it's time to see it's Hoctac and GB.

[Hoctac]

don't sheep elena she has bad reads.
This is exactly what happened in the mini Hoctic. Scum killed the person who scumread me and then pushed my lynch.
VOTE: georgebailey

That doesn't work unless George is scum though, and since when have you been scumreading clidd/George's slot?

[Elements]

don't sheep elena she has bad reads.
This is exactly what happened in the mini Hoctic. Scum killed the person who scumread me and then pushed my lynch.
VOTE: georgebailey

That doesn't work unless George is scum though, and since when have you been scumreading clidd/George's slot?

That's why I've started scumreading GB. He comment about sheeping Elena

[Pigman]

Titus is probably my strongest townread at the moment

followed by elements,

I think.

This is so lazy. You’ve done nothing at all to sort me. How on earth can you have me as your strongest read when you’ve hardly interacted with me nor questioned me about anything? Not to mention the fact that there’s so much more content from other slots that are far more suspicious than the few I’ve managed to get out considering I’ve been lost and struggling to keep up with this game in the first place.

is this what you're townreading?

No. The read was mostly based on day one play. But the way their read on me “developed” seems baseless and fake af. Like how do you interact with everyone else but me and then say “he’s my strongest read”. Lol? So no not anymore.

[Pigman]

Pigman, do you think Juryo could leave your care and become a player to occupy a new slot? We'd be adding a townie to our ranks I think. What do ya reckon?

I dunno what this means. I’m probably gonna vote elements but I want to read into some other slots more first.