Grand Idea GPick [Game Over]

[Bingle]

Farside, are you conftown now?

Farside is confirmed to not be responsible for any of the individual role discrepencies that we know come from scum (unless Starbuck is also scum).

[Starbuck]

Starbuck: Do me a favor and target Titus tonight (do you get a conformation if it works?)

No confirmation if it works, unfortunately.

[Bingle]

If pork is town I would lynch you without hesitation given this info. Any thoughts of a redirector without lynching another player to prove that would look like BS.

If pork is town and there is no redirector/ninjafier he has an innocent result on me that I'm lying about having contradictory evidence about.

[Starbuck]

And there's room on the Bingle wagon, y'all. I've got the hot tub going and mimosas at the ready.

[Bingle]

Starbuck: Do me a favor and target Titus tonight (do you get a conformation if it works?)

If no confirmation occurs then target bingle

I support this. My role is pretty useless.

[Porkens]

Ok yes I had a yellow card so I think that confirms the RB last night

[Bingle]

Spoiler: @BM MT's take on my posts

[Well, right off the bat, what's more likely-- Titus went all the way back to like page 20 of grand idea, or she chose the one that matches her birthday? The explanation of her getting the "Townie (Reroll role)" right at the top of her birthday page, then got assigned a random ass alien role at the beginning of the thread makes a lot of sense to me. Yes she could be alien but also, there hasn't been an alien nightkill yet.]

[we can also use Titus' power to get double lynches. she can't use it nefariously. she can't be the card dealer since we know she has the power. There are a lot of reasons to pick others over titus]

[Also she is definitely a pheromone seeder since hellbooks was hellbent on finding an alien for some reason. She saw the "Pheromone Seeder" and assumed alien]

[i'm not interested in arguing with Starbuck over the hellbooks lynch much]

Interesting how Bingle and MT don't want interact over this.

NOTE this please, everyone.

[Would you like me to? I really don't want to cause i think it's pointless-- i've already said what i think, you disagree with it, i want to move on cause i have 0 hope of convincing you. but we can talk more if you prefer]

[sorry i worded that unnecessarily rudely for some reason. I get what your point was but yeah im convinced the card dealer is scum]

[Well, let's see. Bingle's lynchpool is:]

{Porkens, TSE, Bingle, Looker, MD, CL}

[Your role seems to contradict Bingle's. However I will admit you did seem to shoot Drew. I wish you werent loverized.]
[TSE can't really prove his role at all]
[Bingle can't prove his own role really and it contradicts with yours]
[Looker can't prove that he's a VT and also his slot kinda sucks. He did claim VT right? yeah]
[Manatee can't claim and he also hasn't really done much to solve-- he had a big post on Chateau early game I recall but i believe that was ultimately wrong]
[out of this entire list i just disagree with Chateau being on there. But yes, chateau seems to be unable to prove his role.]

[TemporalLich]

VC 5.4

Titus (2) - Battle Mage, TrueSoulEnergy
Porkens (2) - Chateau Lobby, Morning Tweet
Chateau Lobby (2) - farside22, Porkens
Bingle (1) - Starbuck
Looker (1) - Bingle
ManateeDude (1) - Looker

Not voting: Titus, Iconeum, ManateeDude

With 12 alive it takes 7 to eliminate.

Day 5 will end in (expired on 2020-07-04 00:40:00) or when an elimination is reached.

Iconeum is V/LA until June 29th.

[Bingle]

Ok yes I had a yellow card so I think that confirms the RB last night

The issue with your claim isn't the roleblock last night. It's that you got an innocent result on me on a night when I know no one visited me.

If roleblocking was the answer you wouldn't have gotten that innocent result at all.

For you to be town there necessarily has to be another scum role in the players who don't have confirmable roles.

[Bingle]

Anyone voting Porkens should be voting Looker, btw. Looker is the better lynch given that Porkens claimed red card, unless you think that Porkens lied about that. I'm more confident in Looker scum than Porkens scum by a longshot.

[Battle Mage]

VOTE: manateedude

Looker is in my townbloc too.

[Battle Mage]

dude I'm convinced Looker is town - I know him better than he knows himself.

[Porkens]

I was just confirming the question about last night, maybe I misunderstood the question.

I get the issue with my visit not showing up to you. Wasn’t addressing that.

[Titus]

VOTE: Looker
Baaah....

[Battle Mage]

VOTE: Looker
Baaah....

Bingle - still stand by your assessment of Titus? voting without explanation for someone who:

A. Is highly likely to be town
B. Has already been run up, and claimed.

Seems a bit desperate - not genuine scumhunting in my book. Defending ManateeDude perhaps?

[Titus]

VOTE: Looker
Baaah....

Bingle - still stand by your assessment of Titus? voting without explanation for someone who:

A. Is highly likely to be town
B. Has already been run up, and claimed.

Seems a bit desperate - not genuine scumhunting in my book. Defending ManateeDude perhaps?

Why is Looker likely to be town? What did Looker claim?

I'm a bit out of it, so I am just sleeping my biggest TR at the moment.

[farside22]

Starbuck: Do me a favor and target Titus tonight (do you get a conformation if it works?)

If no confirmation occurs then target bingle

I support this. My role is pretty useless.

Here you go SB, lets get that confirmed. If he says he didn't see you and you target him and Pork targets him we can lynch this lying scum bucket.
Fair?


With that said, still would do MD or CL. Not seeing a case on Looker from anyone makes me steer clear.

[Porkens]

So I roleblocked bingle?

[Bingle]

So I roleblocked bingle?

I have never been roleblocked, because my role has always had a result. I would get a different result if I were roleblocked than if I were targeted by no one.

[Battle Mage]

Starbuck: Do me a favor and target Titus tonight (do you get a conformation if it works?)

No confirmation if it works, unfortunately.

would your role turn somebody scum into town?

[Porkens]

So I roleblocked bingle?

I have never been roleblocked, because my role has always had a result. I would get a different result if I were roleblocked than if I were targeted by no one.

Sorry autocorrect I was asking if I am to roleblock bingle in farsides plan

[Bingle]

I like Titus, ircher, farside, hoctac, TSE. Probably ico too.

I dislike quick, boring, bingle

The rest I have no idea and am reading more to get a better handle on it rn. But this needs to go. I don’t like being pressured to give up info that only benefits mafia and he seems like he’s really trying to control everyone into voting his way. That just doesn’t seem genuine to me.

VOTE: bingle

It's publicly known that my modus operandi as scum is to accurately setup spec as if I were town to the best of my ability. I don't lie about setup information. I am occasionally wrong and occasionally misread things, but Pigman knows me better than to say that that comes from scum me. You can verify this by looking at literally any of my completed games.

I was unaware of it at the time, but Pigman is someone who has extensive experience with me. Like, more than everyone else in this thread combined levels of experience. Town Pigman never makes this post. (Scum Pigman also wouldn't have made this post if I had known who they were, but the reason I know who they are happened after they were replaced, so they were free to make the shit push without me knowing it came from them.)

[farside22]

So I roleblocked bingle?

I have never been roleblocked, because my role has always had a result. I would get a different result if I were roleblocked than if I were targeted by no one.

Sorry autocorrect I was asking if I am to roleblock bingle in farsides plan

hmmmmmm maybe not, I didn't realize you were rb tonight. Maybe MD or TSE.
Damn I wish there was a watcher or investigative role that gave more info right now.

[Bingle]

So I roleblocked bingle?

I have never been roleblocked, because my role has always had a result. I would get a different result if I were roleblocked than if I were targeted by no one.

Sorry autocorrect I was asking if I am to roleblock bingle in farsides plan

That seems to be what she's suggesting, yes. Although it would confirm absolutely nothing if you were to say you planned to roleblock me.

If you out that you're roleblocking me, I can say that I received no result.

If you say you're not roleblocking me I can say whether I was visited based on whether I get a "You were vanilla-ized" pm.

[Bingle]

If Porkens survives the day, Porkens should not claim who he is roleblocking and I should claim whether my role functioned before he claims whether he targeted me. Even still, this isn't foolproof because I have a yellow card today and thus will be roleblocked anyway if we lynch another yellow card holder.