Silent Star 1: Lunacy

[Clover Ebi]

I'm going to make 1 last big post and then retire for the day, may come back later in the afternoon but it'll depend how much I wanna handle

[Raven Branwen]

I don't really believe in the extra scumteam theory too much and could reasonably see a scum!Dru try to get raven/skitts or beeboy/dunn exiles by no-killing and pushing that theory.

Found it

I seriously think that if scum hadn’t no killed, Dru would have never made that bizarre tin foil and might have not been mislynched. And scum!Dunn really has no incentive to make Dru look bad, quite the opposite in fact. It’s in his interest to hard defend her but he took a completely neutral approach.

[Raven Branwen]

I don't really want to deal with Raven trying to power a lynch on me again so I don't mind dying if it means I don't have to deal with that anymore.

You were in TF, you know I’m pretty good at scum, because I know how scum think. You should have killed me instead of MT or MWB even bee. Leaving me alive was your downfall.

[Dunnstral]

mwb and bee are still alive though

[Raven Branwen]

VOTE: Clover

I think the no kill makes the most sense if it’s you. I don’t see why scum!Dunn no kills. I also don’t think scum!Dunn kills MT.

[Raven Branwen]

mwb and bee are still alive though

I’m saying that Clover seriously underestimated me. Do you know how I won so many of my scumgames? I made all the right NAs. Remember Clover, when I won my first scumgame on MU? I chose all the NKs. I excel at judging optics.

[Clover Ebi]

Raven if I was scum you'd be dead because of how uncomfortable you make me. No if and or buts about it. Please do not interact with me for the remainder of the game if you can help it. If you want to push me as scum so be it, but this is a game of mafia meant for fun and you do not make this fun. I am not blaming you for this, it's probably more me then you. But I hope you'll respect my wishes.

Moving on.

Dunnstral being scum we've already debated on and it should be obvious as to why. The only scumteam that makes sense to no kill and I think we can make a good assumption to this. Is a scum team that knows a detective is in the game. Who knew this at the time? Dunnstral and Beeboy. Nothing else makes sense here on why scum would no kill. Dunnstral showing no paranoia or finding it odd that he's seemingly left alive and just getting results is also quite strange. He doesn't even consider that his results might be wrong.

The question you need to ask if you think Dunnstral isn't mafia is why does the last scum put themselves in a spot that would be nearly auto loss? It just doesn't make a lot of sense without some manner of avoiding the detective.

As for why I'm not scum I feel like the last scum would have to be pretty daring and I think I've shown that isn't me? Combine with the fact I would have to fake my day 1 and scum me would never be able to do that is surreal. Along with the matter that I would've openly let my partner die to dru knowing dru became whoever we lynched, a watcher in this case.

[Raven Branwen]

mwb and bee are still alive though

I’m saying that Clover seriously underestimated me. Do you know how I won so many of my scumgames? I made all the right NAs. Remember Clover, when I won my first scumgame on MU? I chose all the NKs. I excel at judging optics.

I still 100% never kill Skitter regardless because I’m not an idiot.

[Clover Ebi]

I'm on break for about ten more minutes and then I'll be getting back to work, but I hope you can see why Dunnstral is the only one that makes sense here.

[Dunnstral]

The question you need to ask if you think Dunnstral isn't mafia is why does the last scum put themselves in a spot that would be nearly auto loss?

So what's the answer to this? Because this question doesn't exclude you

[Dunnstral]

Sorry not that question, the detective one

[Dunnstral]

Is a scum team that knows a detective is in the game. Who knew this at the time? Dunnstral and Beeboy.

Are you saying we're both scum?

[Raven Branwen]

Raven if I was scum you'd be dead because of how uncomfortable you make me. No if and or buts about it. Please do not interact with me for the remainder of the game if you can help it. If you want to push me as scum so be it, but this is a game of mafia meant for fun and you do not make this fun. I am not blaming you for this, it's probably more me then you. But I hope you'll respect my wishes.

Moving on.
UNVOTE:
Dunnstral being scum we've already debated on and it should be obvious as to why. The only scumteam that makes sense to no kill and I think we can make a good assumption to this. Is a scum team that knows a detective is in the game. Who knew this at the time? Dunnstral and Beeboy. Nothing else makes sense here on why scum would no kill. Dunnstral showing no paranoia or finding it odd that he's seemingly left alive and just getting results is also quite strange. He doesn't even consider that his results might be wrong.

The question you need to ask if you think Dunnstral isn't mafia is why does the last scum put themselves in a spot that would be nearly auto loss? It just doesn't make a lot of sense without some manner of avoiding the detective.

As for why I'm not scum I feel like the last scum would have to be pretty daring and I think I've shown that isn't me? Combine with the fact I would have to fake my day 1 and scum me would never be able to do that is surreal. Along with the matter that I would've openly let my partner die to dru knowing dru became whoever we lynched, a watcher in this case.

UNVOTE:

Alright fine, Dunn clearing me was whack.

[Dunnstral]

Not really? It still results in Clover being killed, even if that happens after me

Wheras if I don't check you, and you're mafia, you probably run away with the game, beating beeboy

[Clover Ebi]

The question you need to ask if you think Dunnstral isn't mafia is why does the last scum put themselves in a spot that would be nearly auto loss?

So what's the answer to this? Because this question doesn't exclude you

You tell me. You don't find this odd or strange? No questions about it at all? The fact you're being so narrowed minded about this makes me want to believe you less and less.

Is a scum team that knows a detective is in the game. Who knew this at the time? Dunnstral and Beeboy.

Are you saying we're both scum?

No? How'd you get that?

[Dunnstral]

So even if you eliminate me today, I need you and midway to be on the same page with clover

[Dunnstral]

You don't find this odd or strange?

I do, but what am I supposed to do about it?

[Dunnstral]

The question you need to ask if you think Dunnstral isn't mafia is why does the last scum put themselves in a spot that would be nearly auto loss?

So what's the answer to this? Because this question doesn't exclude you

You tell me. You don't find this odd or strange? No questions about it at all? The fact you're being so narrowed minded about this makes me want to believe you less and less.

Is a scum team that knows a detective is in the game. Who knew this at the time? Dunnstral and Beeboy.

Are you saying we're both scum?

No? How'd you get that?

So are you pushing beeboy right now or what

If I flip wolf detective what does that mean

[Raven Branwen]

Is a scum team that knows a detective is in the game. Who knew this at the time? Dunnstral and Beeboy.

Are you saying we're both scum?

Extremely unlikely, Hectic would put two scum in a PT. Midway’s role clearly means that Lillith and Star were paired with both scum.

[Clover Ebi]

You don't find this odd or strange?

I do, but what am I supposed to do about it?

Think of why scum would put themselves in auto loss over killing you? Like maybe they have a way around it. But if you're so confident it isn't that way than we're back to square one, but the fact you're not thinking about it is strange.

[Raven Branwen]

Not really? It still results in Clover being killed, even if that happens after me

Wheras if I don't check you, and you're mafia, you probably run away with the game, beating beeboy

In what world do you think I ever kill Skitter, seriously? You know she was 100% never ever voting me, right?

[Clover Ebi]

The question you need to ask if you think Dunnstral isn't mafia is why does the last scum put themselves in a spot that would be nearly auto loss?

So what's the answer to this? Because this question doesn't exclude you

You tell me. You don't find this odd or strange? No questions about it at all? The fact you're being so narrowed minded about this makes me want to believe you less and less.

Is a scum team that knows a detective is in the game. Who knew this at the time? Dunnstral and Beeboy.

Are you saying we're both scum?

No? How'd you get that?

So are you pushing beeboy right now or what

If I flip wolf detective what does that mean

I haven't pushed beeboy once so I have no idea what narrative you're trying to make up right now. Did you misunderstand my words or something? If you flipped werewolf I would vote Midway

[Dunnstral]

I can't see into your pt so I wouldn't know though
Obv you aren't scum but if you were and Skitter changed her opinion in the pt maybe then you'd kill her

What do you think I should have done? If I checked Clover and by chance he was town this would have been a much worse situation deciding between you and beeboy

[Dunnstral]

If you flipped werewolf I would vote Midway

But he's clear

[Dunnstral]

I haven't pushed beeboy once so I have no idea what narrative you're trying to make up right now.

Because you said scum would have some way to avoid my check, t hen mentioned the only people who knew who I was checking would be me or beeboy, i thought you were implying something there