Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[Surye]

How is a toad the protector of the princess? Shouldn't that fall under mario or someone like that?

Anyone else see anything wrong with this?

Yea, it completely ignores the sited information about the character. And Mario never protects her... ever. He's always reactionary.

Mod edit
Visible Votecount:
FaerieLord (1): Korts
ashmite84 (1): TheSweatpantsNinja
DarlaBlueEyes (1): populartajo
goborage (1): Riceballtail

Not voting (17): iamausername, skitzer, Wintermute, forbiddanlight, somestrangeflea, Surye, killa seven, Gremwell, Alabaska J, farside22, ting =), DarlaBlueEyes, FaerieLord, Lord Gurgi, Cream147, goborage, ashmite84

With 21 alive it takes 11 real votes to lynch.

[ashmite84]

How is a toad the protector of the princess? Shouldn't that fall under mario or someone like that?

Anyone else see anything wrong with this?

Yea, it completely ignores the sited information about the character. And Mario never protects her... ever. He's always reactionary.

No, I mean: IIRC Farside as good as claimed Toad, if so, she should recognize things from my claim, as should any toad.

[Korts]

How is a toad the protector of the princess? Shouldn't that fall under mario or someone like that?

Anyone else see anything wrong with this?

Yea, it completely ignores the sited information about the character. And Mario never protects her... ever. He's always reactionary.

No, I mean: IIRC Farside as good as claimed Toad, if so, she should recognize things from my claim, as should any toad.

I see your point, although I'm not a toad myself. Farside, care to reply?

[DarlaBlueEyes]

Any reason you think I'm scum Pop?

[farside22]

How is a toad the protector of the princess? Shouldn't that fall under mario or someone like that?

Anyone else see anything wrong with this?

Yea, it completely ignores the sited information about the character. And Mario never protects her... ever. He's always reactionary.

No, I mean: IIRC Farside as good as claimed Toad, if so, she should recognize things from my claim, as should any toad.

My character Toad doesn't protect the princess so that makes no sense. I'm saying in the video games I've played (which isn't many) the toads were not the protectors. Usually she is just in the castle and gets kidnapped.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

And its not in the role pm *cough*. Just saying.

[somestrangeflea]

Apologies for the recent inactivity. Internet was down since Tuesday.

And it's obvious that ashmite wasn't trying to PM-quote, fake or otherwise, because it's written in the

first person

.

[iamausername]

For now, I'm been thinking about it, and I can't understand why a pro-town would have a poisoned mushroom...

VOTE:Goborage

I'd forgotten about this, and I think you may be right. See also this post (it's an awesome post), and I'm sure you will understand my

Vote: goborage

right here.

[forbiddanlight]

For now, I'm been thinking about it, and I can't understand why a pro-town would have a poisoned mushroom...

VOTE:Goborage

I'd forgotten about this, and I think you may be right. See also this post (it's an awesome post), and I'm sure you will understand my

Vote: goborage

right here.

Can someone show me the poisoned mushroom post so that I may at least bandwagon with good reason should I decide Goborage is full of garbage?

[iamausername]

Here is where goborage explains his poisonous mushroom.

[Alabaska J]

I would like the explanation from pop ASAP

[forbiddanlight]

Actually, I can see him being a one shot vig with that. He ruined it with his claim though. Then again, the trickery portion is somewhat scummy. I'll...have to read goborage tomorrow to see if his actions match the projected alignment. Also, I think it'd be wise to not try to outguess the mod given people's items. If a theme game is properly done, flavor doesn't give you good hints. (If I'm wrong, I'm not insulting you Lawrence, because I could see you having trouble making the flavor be meaningless given the set up). Now, to completely be a hypocrite, if the item is an indicator, he's likely with Wario or Bowser (Yeah, I know, 2 out of the 3 scum factions we know of...I lean Wario...it fits the trickery motif)

[Lord Gurgi]

Hmm I'm just thinking here, what would happen if he were to give it to Alabaska to be made into a pill?

[Riceballtail]

Wario is dead, but I was suspicious of Waluigi being in the game as well.

The mushroom does not exist anymore, as I cannot hold onto items. So it cannot be given to anyone else.

[goborage]

^ The world would explode. Wasn't I town a few days ago RBT? What changed since then?

[Riceballtail]

Do you ever read what I post? Or do you just think "he voted me, therefore I must OMGUS."? I asked myself why a protown player would have a poison mushroom, and couldn't come up with a good reason. So now, you get to be my lynch target.

[ting =)]

I'm at about page 50 on my read through. Tempted to vote farside, but I want to read the rest before voting.

[Riceballtail]

You should vote Pengy. He didn't help you at all!

[skitzer]

Actually, I can see him being a one shot vig with that. He ruined it with his claim though. Then again, the trickery portion is somewhat scummy. I'll...have to read goborage tomorrow to see if his actions match the projected alignment. Also, I think it'd be wise to not try to outguess the mod given people's items. If a theme game is properly done, flavor doesn't give you good hints. (If I'm wrong, I'm not insulting you Lawrence, because I could see you having trouble making the flavor be meaningless given the set up). Now, to completely be a hypocrite, if the item is an indicator, he's likely with Wario or Bowser (Yeah, I know, 2 out of the 3 scum factions we know of...I lean Wario...it fits the trickery motif)

I agree with this. It seems like Riceballtail wasn't thinking very hard...

[iamausername]

I don't think that having the poisonous mushroom in itself makes goborage scum, but he's been highly scummy outside of that, and it does make more sense for scum to have that item than town.

[populartajo]

Ok. Tonight Im preparing a list of semiconfirmed townies to distribute the coins for feathering and such. Please the players that havent still given all their coins please do it.
Im asking all of you to answer this.
1) Should K7 have a star?
2) Who of the following do you think SHOULDNT get a feather?
- TSPN
- Gremwell
- Farside
- Cream
- Rice
- Alabaska

[forbiddanlight]

Hi, pop taj...were you ever planning to explain the whole "Hi, DarlaBlueEyes is scum" thing? As for K7 having a star...I'd rather have you, our only confirmed town, to target him with one. As for the second question, do you mean give them a feather so they can view someone or be viewed by a feather? And what motivated that list?

[Riceballtail]

1) Yes.
2) I shouldn't get a feather because I can't hold one.

[Korts]

1) k7 should have a star, but a star should also be used on him
2) other than RBT, I'd say Alabaska, cos he'll have his hands full with pills, no?

Also, fl got here first, but why are you suddenly convinced DBE's scum?

[forbiddanlight]

1) k7 should have a star, but a star should also be used on him

If a star hits someone guarded by a star, do they die?