Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[ting =)]

Mod edit
Visible Votecount:
Korts (5): Alabaska J, Gremwell, somestrangeflea, Riceballtail, Natirasha
Natirasha (3): ting =), farside22, forbiddanlight
FaerieLord (1): Korts
ashmite84 (1): TheSweatpantsNinja
farside22 (1): iamausername
iamausername (1): populartajo

Not voting (9): skitzer, Surye, killa seven, DarlaBlueEyes, FaerieLord, Lord Gurgi, Cream147, goborage, ashmite84

With 21 alive it takes 11 real votes to lynch.

Fos : Ting
Jumping against a confirmed player?

You must have just skimmed through the last two pages.

Recap:

Farside and nat both had contradicting information about the toad role. They both later backtracked on things they said and went, 'I didnt' read my PM and made a mistake, sorry.' This is a game involving deception, it's pretty obvious I won't take that at face value. I find Nat more suspicious.

--

Farside's was

ashmite wrote:
I am a Toad (Mushroom Kingdom). I am loyal to Princess Peach,

and try to keep her from getting kidnapped.

farside wrote:

I don't buy ashmites claim.

How is a toad

the protector

of the princess? Shouldn't that fall under mario or someone like that?

farside wrote:

Mine just says I'm trying to keep her from getting kidknapped.

ting wrote:
Why didn't you buy the claim then?

Farside's defense just goes:

I don't know what I was thinking then. I got protected in my head which is different then keeping the princess from being kidnapped. I probably should have read my PM when Ash claimed, but I just didnt' think about it.

--

Nat's was:

Actually, I'm a toad too and my PM does state that I am here to protect Peach, also.

Is it that you are trying to keep her from getting kidknapped or that you are protecting her?

Both.

Mine just says I'm trying to keep her from getting kidknapped.

Wait...no,

I lied. I only have kidnapped.

Sorry...

I have a mushroom, and my PM had a little aside

about how I can protect myself with the mushroom.

--

[ting =)]

Farside is confirmed town.

End of discussion. You'll notice around the time of my claim there was a lot of underlying understanding from certain people about just what Farside was talking about.

Accuse Farside, and you accuse me, Ash, and certain others as well.

I'm willing to believe you on the bold because you were the first to claim. The italicized I disagree with though. Both farside and nat have contradicted things that you ash have said. I'm accusing them for the contradictions - not their role; it's just them.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Tell me how I knew what Cream was talking about when no one else brought it up.

This is why farside isn't scum.

What about if instead of feathering people we just fireflower like hell. Since Peach cant die we wont kill her and with so many confirmed Toads I think the chances of hitting scum are high.

My concern would be that scum will have resources to protect themselves and townies won't. Besides, having confirmed protected townies is really nice too. If we can get you and k7 stars, then fireflowers to trusted players would be a good second choice.

Also remember that time day 1 when I said that was a good idea and everyone said "no, no." /bitter

[Alabaska J]

Hey guys lets get Korts up enough votes so he is lynched at deadline kthxbai

[Surye]

Hey guys lets get Korts up enough votes so he is lynched at deadline kthxbai

Agreed.

vote: Korts

[populartajo]

Hey guys lets get Korts up enough votes so he is lynched at deadline kthxbai

Agreed.

vote: Korts

No. Guys, can we please lynch either Gobo or iamusername? I dont feel good with a Korts lynch. And maybe he should consider claiming before it is too late.

I still think that fireflowering may be useful. And although it is obvious that scum may have some inmunity, (its extremely possible Bowser is unkillable) I really like the fact that there are so many confirmed Toads that could hit scum. Also remember scum have no coins right now and possibly not mushrooms.

If we're believing K7 then the odds for losing the game with the Bowser kidnapping Peach scenario are low. So theres no problem with reducing the chances of hiting Peach.

So this is the last question, K7
Would you know who kidnapped Peach? Do you know who is Peach? If you answer this, Ill give you a coin.

[killa seven]

Pop i allready answered thos questions multiple times.
Yes i know who peach is and yes i will be notified who kidnapped peach if or when peach is kidnapped.

[Alabaska J]

Hey guys lets get Korts up enough votes so he is lynched at deadline kthxbai

Agreed.

vote: Korts

No. Guys, can we please lynch either Gobo or iamusername? I dont feel good with a Korts lynch. And maybe he should consider claiming before it is too late.

Why iamausername?

Also, goborage is a last resort IMO as he is getting replaced.

[populartajo]

Pop i allready answered thos questions multiple times.
Yes i know who peach is and yes i will be notified who kidnapped peach if or when peach is kidnapped.

Fair enough.

Give 1 coin to K7

Pick well.

Why iamausername?

Im used to more reasoning from his part. Jumping agaisnt Farside even though we knew she was prob confirmed doesnt fit well with his usual reasoning. Also there were some connections between you, Imausername and Armlx. Rite?

[Alabaska J]

Also there were some connections between you, Imausername and Armlx. Rite?

?

[Korts]

Ok, I'm back, and will be catching up shortly. A quick skim tells me, though, that I owe you guys a claim.

I'm a Shy Guy, and I'm your guide around here. My ability basically is that I can use a feather for tracking instead of investigating.

[Cream147]

Ok, I'm back, and will be catching up shortly. A quick skim tells me, though, that I owe you guys a claim.

I'm a Shy Guy, and I'm your guide around here. My ability basically is that I can use a feather for tracking instead of investigating.

Cool role...I have an issue. Isn't Shy Guy a bad guy?

[forbiddanlight]

Ok, I'm back, and will be catching up shortly. A quick skim tells me, though, that I owe you guys a claim.

I'm a Shy Guy, and I'm your guide around here. My ability basically is that I can use a feather for tracking instead of investigating.

Cool role...I have an issue. Isn't Shy Guy a bad guy?

It is, but then it becomes a game of outguess the mod. Would the mod align it bad guys and good guys? And if so, wouldn't he provide falseclaims for scum? Or is Korts trying to make us guess this way and assume game alignment isn't equal to mafia alignment?

[Korts]

Ok, I'm back, and will be catching up shortly. A quick skim tells me, though, that I owe you guys a claim.

I'm a Shy Guy, and I'm your guide around here. My ability basically is that I can use a feather for tracking instead of investigating.

Cool role...I have an issue. Isn't Shy Guy a bad guy?

Not in all the games, I think. Mario Party springs to mind.

[populartajo]

Ok, I'm back, and will be catching up shortly. A quick skim tells me, though, that I owe you guys a claim.

I'm a Shy Guy, and I'm your guide around here. My ability basically is that I can use a feather for tracking instead of investigating.

Cool role...I have an issue. Isn't Shy Guy a bad guy?

Not in all the games, I think. Mario Party springs to mind.

Mmm. Arent all players neutral in Mario Party?
Korts, I suppose you must have a feather?

[Korts]

Ok, I'm back, and will be catching up shortly. A quick skim tells me, though, that I owe you guys a claim.

I'm a Shy Guy, and I'm your guide around here. My ability basically is that I can use a feather for tracking instead of investigating.

Cool role...I have an issue. Isn't Shy Guy a bad guy?

Not in all the games, I think. Mario Party springs to mind.

Mmm. Arent all players neutral in Mario Party?
Korts, I suppose you must have a feather?

Right, I didn't claim actions. I started with 6 coins, with which I bought a feather N1 and feathered farside; she didn't go anywhere. I gave away my last coin D2 and haven't had any since.

[populartajo]

Ok, I'm back, and will be catching up shortly. A quick skim tells me, though, that I owe you guys a claim.

I'm a Shy Guy, and I'm your guide around here. My ability basically is that I can use a feather for tracking instead of investigating.

Cool role...I have an issue. Isn't Shy Guy a bad guy?

Not in all the games, I think. Mario Party springs to mind.

Mmm. Arent all players neutral in Mario Party?
Korts, I suppose you must have a feather?

Right, I didn't claim actions. I started with 6 coins, with which I bought a feather N1 and feathered farside; she didn't go anywhere. I gave away my last coin D2 and haven't had any since.

Why farside?
And can you try this?

Give a feather to populartajo

[Korts]

I can try, but I don't have the feather anymore, I used it.

Give a feather to populartajo

As to why farside: when I replaced in, she seemed suspicious for reasons I couldn't fathom. I usually use investigative powers on either unreadables or unprovables. She was the latter.

[Lord Gurgi]

Ok, I'm back, and will be catching up shortly. A quick skim tells me, though, that I owe you guys a claim.

I'm a Shy Guy, and I'm your guide around here. My ability basically is that I can use a feather for tracking instead of investigating.

Cool role...I have an issue. Isn't Shy Guy a bad guy?

Not in all the games, I think. Mario Party springs to mind.

Consider that DK was only 'evil' at the beginning of the series. Not towards the end. I don't know what to make of his claim however, I would think that investigate > track.

[Cream147]

Ok, I'm back, and will be catching up shortly. A quick skim tells me, though, that I owe you guys a claim.

I'm a Shy Guy, and I'm your guide around here. My ability basically is that I can use a feather for tracking instead of investigating.

Cool role...I have an issue. Isn't Shy Guy a bad guy?

It is, but then it becomes a game of outguess the mod. Would the mod align it bad guys and good guys? And if so, wouldn't he provide falseclaims for scum? Or is Korts trying to make us guess this way and assume game alignment isn't equal to mafia alignment?

You are right. I don't think it's grounds to not believe the claim really. I'd be surprised if a mafia fakeclaim were a bad guy...oh wait, I'm trying to outguess the mod again!

[populartajo]

I can try, but I don't have the feather anymore, I used it.

Give a feather to populartajo

As to why farside: when I replaced in, she seemed suspicious for reasons I couldn't fathom. I usually use investigative powers on either unreadables or unprovables. She was the latter.

Why did you track him if you could investigate her?

[Korts]

What?

I can only track, not investigate.

[Lord Gurgi]

What?

I can only track, not investigate.

Exactly, it makes it seem like you are nerfed, investigation is pretty worthless to scum, but track and watch let them find power roles.

[forbiddanlight]

I'm a Shy Guy, and I'm your guide around here. My ability basically is that

I

can

use a feather for tracking instead of investigating.

I can only track, not investigate.

Oh?

[Lord Gurgi]

EBWOP: And that is why it sounds odd to nerf townie, but then it would be a boon to scum.