Mini 639 - Sci-Fi/Fantasy Movie Mafia(Over!)

[farside22]

Farside how is voting me scumhunting?

My top 2 scum suspects are you and xtoxm if you read my write up.

[DarlaBlueEyes]

agh! Prod picked up. Apologies. Havehad limited Access should get it back full swing tonight. (posting from my phone)

[Knight of Cydonia]

Pressure voting on someone who is away = stalling.
You only retracted that vote after people pointed it out, which makes me think scum trying to create a quick wagon and lynch without anyway for the accuse to defend.

[fuzzylightning]

Yes they had to point it out because I had forgotten, I am sorry that I had a lapse where I forgot something. I don't necessarily see that as scummy.

[fuzzylightning]

And if you wanna look at stalling, how about everyone waiting for Gorrad to post why he wanted the movie claim before they posted what they thought of everyone.

[Knight of Cydonia]

The difference being, everyone else didn't deliberately vote a V/LA player, and no-one was putting pressure on Gorrad. Also - not everyone can be scum.
I'm sorry, I don't buy this "Oh, I didn't see it" crap. You're also, rather than giving a decent defence, trying to call the entire town scum for stalling - which you've just done.

Vote fuzzylightning

[fuzzylightning]

No I was not calling everyone scum for stalling. I was merely pointing out the fact that I have stated that I forgot he was V/LA and I also don't believe I ever said that he would be lynched. I believe somewhere in my posts I said that if he hadn't defended himself and he had gotten close to a lynch I would retract my vote. But, seeing as you have replaced into this game, could we see how you feel about the rest of the players in this game.

[Knight of Cydonia]

farside22 - scum-hunting away, fits in with what I've seen of her town meta. Perhaps a little too aggressive, but could just be zeal.
Gorrad - Claim makes me more comfortable with him being town, although the fact he investigated zoraster doesn't make a huge amount of sense. Yeah you suspected him most, but I can't see a huge amount that looks like anything worse than a null tell, IMHO.
zoraster - null-tells ahoy! But seriously, I'm undecided here, maybe leaning slightly scum because of the sheer volume of nullness - it almsot looks like he's trying to be as *meh* as possible.
Grimmy - Hmmm. Jumped on fuzzylightning pretty quickly about the Xtoxm thing... I could see a triple-distance here: xtoxm goes V/LA, fuzzy jumps on him, then off as soon as Grimmy mentions teh fact Xtoxm can't defend himself. Hmmm. One to watch.
Panzerjager - "how is voting me scumhunting?" Overtly defensive, I haven't seen a huge amount of reasoning other than additions to existing cases. Worrisome.
Xtoxm - third place in my suspect list right now, V/LA at the moment but hasn't done anything to convince me of him being town.
DarlaBlueEyes(rp.Muerrto) - looking forward to a return tonight, would like to hear more - one of the less vocal players in the game. Bit of a null-tell at the moment.
Knight of Cydonia(rp.ashmite84) - All-round nice guy and furry-footed ninja.
fuzzylightning - "Tell us what you think of other people" - a scum-tell, IMHO - instead of defending yourself adequately with anything but "I didn't see him say he was V/LA!" you're trying to distract with other opinions. Are you hoping a family member will OMGUS me for this, or something?
Korts - Is he still here? Away until Sunday? Alright then. Another null, leaning town. Expect a decent post on return.

[DarlaBlueEyes]

Back! was in a small car accident *meeps* I'm ok tho.

Reading over some of this I Still have an unshakable feeling about Panz, but xtom's blatant lurking/refusal to add content is frustrating. Also, did I mis Ash's/replacment Claim?

for now

vote: Xtom

Moar Content Plz

[Knight of Cydonia]

...He's very recently said that he's V/LA for a while. So therefore asking for content is pointless for now.
And for those who missed it, I claim Samwise Gamgee (Movie - Lord of the Rings), pro-town NK resistant Vig.

[fuzzylightning]

I didn't see him say he was V/LA when I posted. Had I seen it I wouldn't have voted for him. What else do you want me to say? And how is asking you to share your opinions of others a scum tell. I believe that I am not the only one who has asked someone that and as a replacement you should post your thoughts on the game thus far and I was just asking you to do so. If you could show me something from before Xtoxm going away that was a "scum tell" I would love to hear it, but without anything else your case is rather weak.

[hasdgfas]

Third Vote Count of Day 2

Panzerjager(1): farside22
fuzzylightning(1): Knight of Cydonia
Xtoxm(1): DarlaBlueEyes

Not Voting: Xtoxm, Gorrad, Grimmy, fuzzylightning, Panzerjager, Korts, zoraster

10 alive, 6 to lynch

Deadline begins on 8/27

[Knight of Cydonia]

Other people were doing it early on, or to question possible scum. You're doing it in order to get people looking at my thoughts rather than you.

[fuzzylightning]

No I was doing it because I wanted to see what you thought on the game. You are a replacement and as a replacement should be giving your thoughts on everyone, and you didn't answer the second part of my post. Now that I have your thoughts I would like to see Xtoxm come back, because he only said a few days and its Saturday, so any time now. All I am saying is that you are misreading my intentions. And why didn't you jump on Darla for voting Xtoxm like you did me?

[Xtoxm]

Sorry, not had much time for MS today. I'll take a look soon.

[Knight of Cydonia]

Damn. I thought he was back and we could get some proper questioning done.

[Korts]

Ok, I'm back, and glad to see there's stuff to read. Will get on it pretty soon. Also, welcome Knight of Cydonia!

[Xtoxm]

NK immume vig?

Sounds like an SK to me.

Xtoxm - reading xtoxm is the equivalant to reading nothing. He hasn't posted any supicion. He says there is nothing to talk about when there has been many a conversation going on. I rank him as #1 scummy out of everyone.

That's not true. I find this analysis of me quite crap.

Xtoxm - third place in my suspect list right now, V/LA at the moment but hasn't done anything to convince me of him being town.

Isn't it that you need convincing of someone being scum rather convincing of them being town?

Xtoxm: his playstyle is generally a bit lurkish, so I'd dismiss that as a scumtell, and otherwise, he's answered questions and posed questions D1, though considerably less so D2. I'm Middle of the Road, maybe slightly scum.

Think this is a better summary of me.

Still think Korts is looking good (Pretty sure I mentioned it earlier).

Believe Gorrad atm. Generally unecessary early claims are town, I think.

DEB - You voted voted me over not enough conent, but looking at your isolation, I can't see anything directed at me...Did you want something?

In regards to Xtoxm's lurking: In every game I've played with him, and there has been like 4, he has lurked in ALL of them. So to me, the guy is just a lurker, he has fun playing mafia when there is nothing else, but there is other shit so he neglects it and lurks in most his games.

I should vote you on the basis of Lynch all Liars...

im witholding a judgement on him until his return to defend himself.

What is it I am expected to defend myself against?

Posts consolidated. Please try to keep it to 1 post if possible and no more than 3.
-Cow

[Gorrad]

NK immume vig?

Sounds like an SK to me.

*Cough*Meta-breaking mafia*cough*

[farside22]

@xtoxm: Show me where you have actually done any scum hunting this game. Show me more then one post that didn't have just one line. Your only comment on ZS is that he needed to claim, but never once did you state any suspicion on him. So tell me how the analysis I typed is crap.

[Knight of Cydonia]

NK immume vig?

Sounds like an SK to me.

Okay, WHAT?
On the basis of nothing but a role claim, you're trying to get me lynched as an SK, with no proof whatsoever? Christ, boyo. You'd better have a damn good explanation for that.

Rule 4
-Cow

[Gorrad]

Hey KoC, can you give the flavor behind your role being what it is? I'm having a lot of trouble seeing Sam as a pro-town NK-resistant Vig. I can see the first two parts, but who in LotR did Sam really kill? Almost no one.

[Knight of Cydonia]

Sorry cow. Got a bit excited there.

Gorrad - watch the Cirith Ungol section in Return of the King - he takes out three Orcs on his own, four if you count the one he backstabs on the ladder into Frodo's cell at the top of the Tower.
That enough killing for you?

[Korts]

Ok, I've read up. I was just about to ask the same thing as Gorrad; from the LotR, Sam is the least likely to be vig. Did you shoot N1?

[Grimmy]

I have a copy of that movie somewhere...

I think it is along the lines of him having a hissy fit and going after Golem out of sheer jealousy.