Explosiva Mafia - GAME OVER

[Battle Mage]

Not necessarily, but it is certainly indicated. No doubts on Coron himself, so i'm more than happy to see him die now.

BM

[killa seven]

You mean, like k7?


[/quote]

Dude i got my role pm this thread was closed next time i checked there was 10 pages.. guess thats what happens when BM is playing in a game.

[DrippingGoofball]

[quote="Tarhalindur"]For those of you who don't recognize the term, Information Instead of Analysis is a Tarhalindur Standard TellWIFOM of intergalactic proportions.

[DrippingGoofball]

EBWOP

For those of you who don't recognize the term, Information Instead of Analysis is a Tarhalindur Standard Tell

WIFOM of intergalactic proportions.

[killa seven]

Ok i guess i fail on quote tags

[DrippingGoofball]

You do realise, people like you and I are NEVER gonna get given a bomb. Because the scum are gonna have a list of players who will be good bomb magnets, and players who will be tough to get killed. Me and you fall in the former category atm.

BM

I'm a mega bomb magnet, BM. How do you explain that?

[DrippingGoofball]

Say that instead of the actual statement I made, I just said "armlx is town". If one of armlx or me dies, it makes the other look scummy.

Unvote, Vote: Coron

Did you REALLY just claim scum?

BM

Wait a minute. Is he also saying that armlx is his buddy?

[Max]

Coron, any reason why? And, how will that help us (scum are made up of people who have been here less than 2 years, and more than 2 years)

I interpreted that as he thinks 2 mafia are newbies and the third has been around a while.

For those of you wailing on me for one post per day: School just started, I'm low on sleep, I'm a fairly slow poster, and it takes far more thought for me to play than mod. Not all of us reliably post multiple well-reasoned posts per day, you know. If you're town and attacking me for lurking, quit being an idiot.

For those of you who don't recognize the term, Information Instead of Analysis is a Tarhalindur Standard Tell

Players I would support being nuked today: Forbiddanlight, Mayhem, alvin, roughly in that order. Alvin gets on the list for the horrible opening post, the other two will need to be elaborated on (read: PBPA) in separate posts.

I'm going to withhold condemnation for Batt for now: he's been in a number of the games I've modded, so I have a decent meta on him, and I want to see more of his posting. More importantly, I want to see if he picks up the posting (lurking is NOT normal for Batt-town, and if he keeps it up for more than three or four real-life days I will be screaming for his head).

I want to see more out of Battle Mage before I try to draw any firm conclusions - he's hard for me to read even in the best of circumstances.

Coron reads town to me: I don't want to see him nuked.

:Good Posting:

I don't get why so many people are trying to bring this game back to how the bomb works/ why the scum would give it to a certain person. It doesn't make any sense to me and I feel like it is hindering the hunting of scum.

unvote vote Max

If we know what the scum use to decide the dead people we know what to look for, in this game it is

Unlinkely

the opponents will give the bomb to v. good townies as they will hunt scum successfully. But they can use the Wifom against us.

I think Max is a good choice because he has said absolutely nothing, and disappeared as soon as people started calling him on it (now in all fairness to him that was only a few hours ago as well, and he can't be around all the time)

I have no intentions of staying on MS past 6ishPM (which I often do, but usually at that time I don't actually respond properly as I'm either A, getting ready to go out, B eating or C surfing something else on the internet.), because I do have some sort of a social life you know, last night, for example, I was going to a BBQ, and next week I'm going back to school, so you see I do do things other than MS.

insert funny stuff about my meta

Nice to know people think so highly of me.

[Max]

3 Posts

Care to elaborate, 10 pages and you manage 3 posts all one sentence long?

Anyway I've gtg now, might be back later

[M4yhem]

You mean, like k7?

And Twomz.

I don't think Coron claimed scum. You guys are kidding, right?

[Battle Mage]

You do realise, people like you and I are NEVER gonna get given a bomb. Because the scum are gonna have a list of players who will be good bomb magnets, and players who will be tough to get killed. Me and you fall in the former category atm.

BM

I'm a mega bomb magnet, BM. How do you explain that?

I don't know. Maybe the scum thought you'd be too unpredictable, and difficult to lynch? Personally, i dont think i'd have given you the bomb though.

BM

[Battle Mage]

Say that instead of the actual statement I made, I just said "armlx is town". If one of armlx or me dies, it makes the other look scummy.

Unvote, Vote: Coron

Did you REALLY just claim scum?

BM

Wait a minute. Is he also saying that armlx is his buddy?

Possibly, but not necessarily. It could be a bluff anyway. We'll cross that bridge when we come to it.

BM

[Battle Mage]

You mean, like k7?

And Twomz.

I don't think Coron claimed scum. You guys are kidding, right?

Read it again. He claimed scum.

BM

[Battle Mage]

You mean, like k7?

Dude i got my role pm this thread was closed next time i checked there was 10 pages.. guess thats what happens when BM is playing in a game.[/quote]

And in the time it took you to make this post, we went to 11.

BM

[Twomz]

Drown Twomz in chocolate cherry ice cream. I don't believe he's always so apathetic early on. I'm sure I read a game where he was helpful. Besides, it's not really hard to make content, unless you're scum. Just pour your thoughts and feelings on to the page.

Yeah, when I do that I get lynched. Reading one game I've played in isn't going to give you a meta on me. My playstyle changes depending on the situation. I will put down my thoughts, and they won't be edited either... when I have them. Right now I'm just trying to figure out what's goin on.

[armlx]

I don't believe he's always so apathetic early on. I'm sure I read a game where he was helpful. Besides, it's not really hard to make content, unless you're scum. Just pour your thoughts and feelings on to the page.

He actually is, though his own awareness of his meta makes it into a null tell.

BM's last vote = face + palm. Clearly no understanding of hypothetical scenarios like Coron is talking about.

BM, lets say you think Player Y is town. Would you do something that made that player and yourself look scummy?

[Coron]

Say that instead of the actual statement I made, I just said "armlx is town". If one of armlx or me dies, it makes the other look scummy.

Unvote, Vote: Coron

Did you REALLY just claim scum?

BM

No, I don't see it. Sorry, but as far as I can tell I did not.

[Coron]

Say that instead of the actual statement I made, I just said "armlx is town". If one of armlx or me dies, it makes the other look scummy.

Unvote, Vote: Coron

Did you REALLY just claim scum?

BM

no... I don't see it.

And I don't disagree. It is unreasonable to think most people post more as scum than as town, though (unless you can provide some numbers that are not solely based on your playstyle from a couple years ago). Lurking is not a town-tell.

I don't disagree. I just think it's not the be-all and end-all

And yet you specifically pointed out the "I post less as town"-you, thereby generalizing without "using both".
The other you only came about after I pointed out that you're posting a lot.

Misquotes are bad. "On lurker lynching, on analysing around 2/3rds of my own games, which admittedly were mostly minis, I found that I have fewer posts per game day as TOWN, and more as scum. " Which doesn't even mean the same thing as what you said I said. Unless you're quoting something other than the orginal post.

You mean, like k7?

sure, but it breaks down early in the game. This game has only been open for like 3 days. SRSLY, give some more time.


---------

Did you REALLY just claim scum?

That, and that armlx is his partner :p

still not seeing it.

Not necessarily, but it is certainly indicated. No doubts on Coron himself, so i'm more than happy to see him die now.

BM

The only one who shouldn't have doubts are the scum. Just sayin'.

Say that instead of the actual statement I made, I just said "armlx is town". If one of armlx or me dies, it makes the other look scummy.

Unvote, Vote: Coron

Did you REALLY just claim scum?

BM

Wait a minute. Is he also saying that armlx is his buddy?

... I'm still not seeing it. Unles you guys are having problems with hypotheticals again. I'm willing to entertain the the thought from your point of view I might be scum. I am not scum.

You mean, like k7?

And Twomz.

I don't think Coron claimed scum. You guys are kidding, right?

Good work.

[Max]

Just popping in, nothing much has happened, Coron, any reason why you aren't attacking me in this game, that's how your Meta in games with me works *eyes suspiciously*

[TDC]

And yet you specifically pointed out the "I post less as town"-you, thereby generalizing without "using both".
The other you only came about after I pointed out that you're posting a lot.

Misquotes are bad. "On lurker lynching, on analysing around 2/3rds of my own games, which admittedly were mostly minis, I found that I have fewer posts per game day as TOWN, and more as scum. " Which doesn't even mean the same thing as what you said I said. Unless you're quoting something other than the orginal post.

Where have I misquoted you.
The topic was lurker lynching, right? You then gave the anecdotal note that you post more as scum than as town (something which we've established is not even true nowadays).
Where is my misquote?

[M4yhem]

Good work.

Thank you, Coron. Do I get a gold star?

[Battle Mage]

Say that instead of the actual statement I made, I just said "armlx is town". If one of armlx or me dies, it makes the other look scummy.

Unvote, Vote: Coron

Did you REALLY just claim scum?

BM

No, I don't see it. Sorry, but as far as I can tell I did not.

Please explain your comment then. Or better yet, let's have Armlx do it.

BM

[Battle Mage]

Not necessarily, but it is certainly indicated. No doubts on Coron himself, so i'm more than happy to see him die now.

BM

The only one who shouldn't have doubts are the scum. Just sayin'.

When you just admitted you were scum, what the hell do you expect? 0.o

Say that instead of the actual statement I made, I just said "armlx is town". If one of armlx or me dies, it makes the other look scummy.

Unvote, Vote: Coron

Did you REALLY just claim scum?

BM

Wait a minute. Is he also saying that armlx is his buddy?

... I'm still not seeing it. Unles you guys are having problems with hypotheticals again.

The fact that you don't see it makes it worse. I can just about believe you're not very good at wording things, and got in a complete tangle. Or even that you were just making a joke. But, you seem to genuinely not understand what you have just said.

You can lecture about hypotheticals until the cows come home. I'm not having any of it. Do you realise how little sense you are making?

The only way you're gonna accept this is by trying to explain what you said. No 'its a hypothetical' bs. Just explain your comment.

BM

[Coron]

And yet you specifically pointed out the "I post less as town"-you, thereby generalizing without "using both".
The other you only came about after I pointed out that you're posting a lot.

Misquotes are bad. "On lurker lynching, on analysing around 2/3rds of my own games, which admittedly were mostly minis, I found that I have fewer posts per game day as TOWN, and more as scum. " Which doesn't even mean the same thing as what you said I said. Unless you're quoting something other than the orginal post.

Where have I misquoted you.
The topic was lurker lynching, right? You then gave the anecdotal note that you post more as scum than as town (something which we've established is not even true nowadays).
Where is my misquote?

"I post less as town" What I actually said is roughly "on average I have posted less as town" if you had posted this I would not be making a fuss over whether they were actually my words. Tense is really important.

Good work.

Thank you, Coron. Do I get a gold star?

You can reach for the stars, but you'll never make it. Sorry.

Say that instead of the actual statement I made, I just said "armlx is town". If one of armlx or me dies, it makes the other look scummy.

Unvote, Vote: Coron

Did you REALLY just claim scum?

BM

No, I don't see it. Sorry, but as far as I can tell I did not.

Please explain your comment then. Or better yet, let's have Armlx do it.

BM

Okay, whatever you want.

[Coron]

Not necessarily, but it is certainly indicated. No doubts on Coron himself, so i'm more than happy to see him die now.

BM

The only one who shouldn't have doubts are the scum. Just sayin'.

When you just admitted you were scum, what the hell do you expect? 0.o

except I didn't.

Say that instead of the actual statement I made, I just said "armlx is town". If one of armlx or me dies, it makes the other look scummy.

Unvote, Vote: Coron

Did you REALLY just claim scum?

BM

Wait a minute. Is he also saying that armlx is his buddy?

... I'm still not seeing it. Unles you guys are having problems with hypotheticals again.

The fact that you don't see it makes it worse. I can just about believe you're not very good at wording things, and got in a complete tangle. Or even that you were just making a joke. But, you seem to genuinely not understand what you have just said.

No, now that I look at it, you're definately having problems with hypotheticals. I didn't get it for a while, but I now see what you're saying, even if you're completely and totally wrong.

You can lecture about hypotheticals until the cows come home. I'm not having any of it. Do you realise how little sense you are making?

You do realize that these hypotheticals are hypothetical on which I make hypotheses. Or something.

The only way you're gonna accept this is by trying to explain what you said. No 'its a hypothetical' bs. Just explain your comment.

I was saying hypothetically if I were scum, I wouldn't always be wrong for reasons given in the post that I won't bother going through in this post.

Anyway, yeah, I gotta get ready for class, I'll do a more in depth response after class.