Kenfucius/Battousai:
I'd yell at Kenfucius for pressure-voting chenhsi if I didn't do the same thing. I can't figure out his reason for voting Wumbo, and his quick unvote is questionable.Battousai replaces in and his second post puts Dark wingstalker at L-1. He states that, at that point, DWS, geraintm and I are his top three suspects—DWS for putting Wumbo at L-1 out of not paying attention, geraintm for misinterpreting posts, and me for telling Wumbo to claim or die (which I defend as my play style). I now think that this post saying that he doesn't want to lynch chenhsi despite a counterclaim is a breadcrumb to his also being a cop. He then goes off saying that neither maxwellhouse nor Dark wingstalker should be lynched Day 2 so maxwellhouse's sanity (if he is the cop) can be confirmed. After FoS'ing Inspector Godot for lining up lynches and then voting him for banking on maxwellhouse being a second cop, he decides to vote Dark wingstalker anyway, and DWS turns out to be the godfather. Battousai then votes Inspector Godot given the Dark wingstalker wagon, and he ends up also being Mafia. Votes me given my claim and his results so far since he hadn't investigated me yet. Mistakes my tracker claim for a reporter claim and by that reasoning questions why I targeted maxwellhouse knowing that he would leave his house—actually, since I am the tracker, exactly why I targeted him in the first place. Decides to leave me alive given that both claimed power roles should stick around and then votes Cass for his reasons for investigating her Day 2, then votes no lynch to prevent today from being lynch or lose. Investigates me and gets an innocent result.
Tom/Cass:
All I can get from Tom before Cass replaced him is that he voted Wumbo for his reactions to his inactivity. When Cass replaced, she unvoted Wumbo but still has a case on him. Tries to prevent chenhsi from claiming and tells him to claim doc if he does, then defends it as her getting annoyed at chenhsi. OK, Cass, what the hell!?This is the first mention of a scum roleblocker that we have—Cass claims Dark wingstalker hinted at it. (I got roleblocked twice, so the only way they can't is if I'm scum and lied about the blocks.)
Questions both my self-vote and Battousai's assuredness that I'm scum. I'm debating if this is fence sitting, but I am aware that neither action makes sense to her. I think she is the first person to guess, however, that Battousai is either naïve or scum (said insane, but corrected herself). We now know that if she is incorrect, then Wumbo is scum.
Votes Wumbo based on logic, which is starting to give me second thoughts.
geraintm:
Shoots down Dark wingstalker's "Mafia never hammer" comment, and if I remember correctly I helped do this too. Presents a good case on me, then develops my case even more. What stands out in the second such post is that he attacks me for reserving the hammer yet being hesitant to vote Inspector Godot, which he interprets as my temptation to bus him, but he has some other good points there too, notably his thoughts on the cop sanity distribution. The only thing I don't like is his questioning why Litral wasn't cleared at that point (I tracked him, he didn't send a night action N3, and he confirmed this; thus he was cleared unless there were two scum left, which is unlikely).StrangerCoug:
Oh come the hell on. Don't be lazy! Review me yourself 
Wumbo:
Not a lot Day 1 besides on Dark wingstalker and chenhsi. I don't like the first paragraph of this post, presenting a case yet acknowledging that he himself would most likely be the lynch. This, along the same lines pessimism-wise, is another thing setting me off. Like me, he's fighting back from wanting to be dead, but he seems to be doing this arbitrarily. I wanted to be dead because I didn't want to suffer the consequences of what I misinterpreted as a counterclaim, but if I want discussion to continue I have to put that behind me. Wumbo doesn't really seem to be doing so.My LoS runs Cass, Wumbo, Battousai, and geraintm in order starting with who I think is the scummiest. I think Cass is the best play today, largely because of her later Day 1 actions, but Wumbo's another possibility depending on what comes up.
Vote: Cass
FoS: Wumbo
FoS: Wumbo
