Sunny 2: Rules of Im-peachment - Over!

[Jake The Wolfie]

I can say that every vote is opportunistic for both sides. Town gets rid of a potential LHF earlier rather than later, and scum gets a free town kill.

What is alignment indicative to you

*shrug*

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: jake
surprise motherfakka

[Jake The Wolfie]

I can say that every vote is opportunistic for both sides. Town gets rid of a potential LHF earlier rather than later, and scum gets a free town kill.

What is alignment indicative to you

Like really, what kind of answer are you expecting other than "How the fuck am I supposed to know?"
Scumminess isn't some objective quality, like hardness or height. I know scummy when I see it. Granted, I do have a warped perception of any game because I am a vote magnet, but still.

[midwaybear]

You could say something like that.
Your original answer was mostly a nonanswer. Sure town and scum both have incentive to vote you, but as you said, there sometimes is that intuition that allows you to see the difference. Simply leaving things at "yeah could be town or scum pushing me" didn't seem like much of an answer to me, so I was curious to how you scumhunt.

[Jake The Wolfie]

Maria's entrance is unique from what I've seen before, but her vote is neutral.
It was more of Cakez voting Cheetory that seemed a bit unnatural. Cakez's vote seems like a bandwagon vote, and I don't know if his explanation (fifth fortnight) is genuine. This seems like a stretch theory now that I posted

alright, wanna vote a mafia with me?

VOTE: Jake The Wolfie

Looking back on this vote, it's kinda trashy.
There isn't much followup after this vote, either.

VOTE: staypositivefriend

[staypositivefriend]

Maria's entrance is unique from what I've seen before, but her vote is neutral.
It was more of Cakez voting Cheetory that seemed a bit unnatural. Cakez's vote seems like a bandwagon vote, and I don't know if his explanation (fifth fortnight) is genuine. This seems like a stretch theory now that I posted

alright, wanna vote a mafia with me?

VOTE: Jake The Wolfie

Looking back on this vote, it's kinda trashy.
There isn't much followup after this vote, either.

VOTE: staypositivefriend

if me explaining my vote on you on #103 and then questioning you on #119-onward doesn't qualify as "

followup

", i don't think anything could

[Jake The Wolfie]

I haven't read anything I just legit am not gonna let Cheet roll over me again

Interesting coincidence then...

alright, wanna vote a mafia with me?

VOTE: Jake The Wolfie

I don't really have a read on him because this behavior is mostly NAI for him. What pinged you?

his opening posts felt aimless/uncomfortable to me - posts like #65 felt like jake was more concerned w/positioning himself as someone who fit in with the thread than he was with approaching the game from a solving mindset. i was mostly interested in seeing if i could concentrate a bunch of momentum around him

Actually scratch the followup part, this followup is scummy as fuck.

[staypositivefriend]

tell me more

[Jake The Wolfie]

Maria's entrance is unique from what I've seen before, but her vote is neutral.
It was more of Cakez voting Cheetory that seemed a bit unnatural. Cakez's vote seems like a bandwagon vote, and I don't know if his explanation (fifth fortnight) is genuine. This seems like a stretch theory now that I posted

alright, wanna vote a mafia with me?

VOTE: Jake The Wolfie

Looking back on this vote, it's kinda trashy.
There isn't much followup after this vote, either.

VOTE: staypositivefriend

if me explaining my vote on you on #103 and then questioning you on #119-onward doesn't qualify as "

followup

", i don't think anything could

If you want to have 103 count as followup, then go ahead and throwe it over here.
Seriously, "i was mostly interested in seeing if i could concentrate a bunch of momentum around him" is pretty scummy to me.

[Jake The Wolfie]

Why wouldn't you push someone because you wanted to hear more from them, instead of "Well I wanted to feel special in making a wagon!!!"

[Something_Smart]

Looking back on this vote, it's kinda trashy.
There isn't much followup after this vote, either.

And?

[Jake The Wolfie]

Looking back on this vote, it's kinda trashy.
There isn't much followup after this vote, either.

And?

And you somehow missed the posts following this one? I know I missed their posts, but they were on a

completely

different page.

[Jake The Wolfie]

VOTE: jake
surprise motherfakka

Louise, what inspired you to vote me here?

[staypositivefriend]

Why wouldn't you push someone because you wanted to hear more from them, instead of "Well I wanted to feel special in making a wagon!!!"

if i'm able to concentrate the momentum of the game onto a specific player early on, then it tells me a

lot

about both the dynamics of the game and the alignment of the player i'm pushing on.

putting early pressure on a player like you

forces

you to engage w/the game in a way that wouldn't otherwise happen organically. the fact that we're discussing this right now is confirmation to me that it was a good idea

[Jake The Wolfie]

if i'm able to concentrate the momentum of the game onto a specific player early on, then it tells me a lot about both the dynamics of the game and the alignment of the player i'm pushing on.

Or it tells you how many people baa like a sheep.

[staypositivefriend]

if i'm able to concentrate the momentum of the game onto a specific player early on, then it tells me a lot about both the dynamics of the game and the alignment of the player i'm pushing on.

Or it tells you how many people baa like a sheep.

that seems like pretty valuable information to have, if you ask me.

[Something_Smart]

And you somehow missed the posts following this one? I know I missed their posts, but they were on a completely different page.

I'm just wondering how what you posted was connected to the vote. Why is having a trashy vote and not following up scummy for her?

[Jake The Wolfie]

if i'm able to concentrate the momentum of the game onto a specific player early on, then it tells me a lot about both the dynamics of the game and the alignment of the player i'm pushing on.

Or it tells you how many people baa like a sheep.

that seems like pretty valuable information to have, if you ask me.

Why?

[Jake The Wolfie]

And you somehow missed the posts following this one? I know I missed their posts, but they were on a completely different page.

I'm just wondering how what you posted was connected to the vote. Why is having a trashy vote and not following up scummy for her?

Well, their followup was also scummy

[staypositivefriend]

if i'm able to concentrate the momentum of the game onto a specific player early on, then it tells me a lot about both the dynamics of the game and the alignment of the player i'm pushing on.

Or it tells you how many people baa like a sheep.

that seems like pretty valuable information to have, if you ask me.

Why?

understanding the playstyle of the people i'm playing with in a game where i don't know a single person is pretty valuable to me. if my push on you gives me

no

information other than gaining insight into how people play, i would still consider it a good thing

[Jake The Wolfie]

putting early pressure on a player like you forces you to engage w/the game in a way that wouldn't otherwise happen organically. the fact that we're discussing this right now is confirmation to me that it was a good idea

Question: How does pressuring a LHF help you sort them?

[Jake The Wolfie]

if i'm able to concentrate the momentum of the game onto a specific player early on, then it tells me a lot about both the dynamics of the game and the alignment of the player i'm pushing on.

Or it tells you how many people baa like a sheep.

that seems like pretty valuable information to have, if you ask me.

Why?

understanding the playstyle of the people i'm playing with in a game where i don't know a single person is pretty valuable to me. if my push on you gives me

no

information other than gaining insight into how people play, i would still consider it a good thing

Or you could read up on how people play via looking at their previous games.

[Gypyx]

hello, best town player of the earth here, let's catch some red PMs

[Cheetory6]

a wise man once said
meta is trash

[staypositivefriend]

putting early pressure on a player like you forces you to engage w/the game in a way that wouldn't otherwise happen organically. the fact that we're discussing this right now is confirmation to me that it was a good idea

Question: How does pressuring a LHF help you sort them?

this seems self-explanatory - it helps me sort

you

, and sorting you helps me sort the rest of the game by extension. it's silly to suggest that i should read through the meta of 17 different players to figure their dynamics out when i could accomplish the same thing by playing this game.

i don't see this exchange being constructive past this point, so i'm withdrawing from it for now