Raw, Unfiltered, UPICK Game Over !

[Marky Mark]

KISS

Non loyal targeting
A counterclaim

Let's conveniently overlook the otherwise unexplained second death and 8v3 info from misty that makes that less likely to be SK.

[Marky Mark]

Got as far as Pg 57 but really ought to head in to the office. More later on. Grey looking VERY town. Cass looking less town than before. Titus looking scummy. Grendel's modifier makes sense in line with his flavour.

[Alisae]

Votecount 2.1

Titus(4)

~ Flea the Magician(51), MathBlade(189), Grendel(123), GreyICE(79)

Grendel(2)

~ PookyTheMagicalBear(30), Titus(41)

PookyTheMagicalBear(1)

~ Dannflor(66)


Not Voting (4): Marky Mark(72), Mistyx(27), Jesse Pierce(2), cassowary(20)

With 11 alive it takes 6 to flip.

Day 2 deadline is frozen

[Flea The Magician]

I will tell you now, scum have a roleblocker - from my setup spec, they need one.

This game does not see MELo.

I'm game for full flavour claiming at this point. Working out worse case in that our vigs hit town:

CompVig + ScumShot + MisElim = 5vs3 ELo
CompVig + ScumShot + Elim = 6vs2
GateVig + CompVig + ScumShot + MisLim = 4vs3 ELo
GateVig + CompVig + ScumShot + Elim + 4vs2 MELo.

[Flea The Magician]

actually, GateVig and CompVig wont be around together looking at it...

ADHD brain sucks.
Feels like I've got like 300 processes running on this for outcomes... 100 of them are "when do I do the do"

[MathBlade]

Ugh

Rapid fire paranoia theory
Grey Marky Jesse, Grendel SK

Grendel feels like an SK.

[MathBlade]

Oh wait no then Misty has to be scum shit.

Like I feel it in my bones Grendel is SK

[MathBlade]

If Titus flips scum do Jesse slot tomorrow
If Titus flips town Grey is scum

That’s my last wish

[Titus]

KISS

Non loyal targeting
A counterclaim

Let's conveniently overlook the otherwise unexplained second death and 8v3 info from misty that makes that less likely to be SK.

Grendel scum vig then

[GreyICE]

14 players
Scum full vigilante
Shoots kop who given his amazing post yesterday and his slot's old posts was great mislynch bait with this unbelievable power
Rather than literally anyone else like "oops I shot misty/NK15/uncrowned/literally anyone I could plausibly find scummy but wasn't obvious mislynch bait"

Oh wait no then Misty has to be scum shit.

Like I feel it in my bones Grendel is SK

It just makes Misty's play so weird. So very weird. Even for scum. Like any of the times I was scum I literally legit have not minded an SK lynch, it's just like "eh, wasn't on my team, bonus"

[GreyICE]

Oh and he literally claimed a modifier that's utterly incompatible with a 1-shot scum vig, which is about the most powerful scum vig I can see making (and it's bizarrely powerful)

Because if he's one shot two days from now we'd be like "Grendel. Grendel we've had one kill a night for the last two nights, why are you alive?"

[GreyICE]

Also that'd mean the scum blew a 1-shot vig on Kop.

Like no offense to Kop but I don't see it.

[MathBlade]

14 players
Scum full vigilante
Shoots kop who given his amazing post yesterday and his slot's old posts was great mislynch bait with this unbelievable power
Rather than literally anyone else like "oops I shot misty/NK15/uncrowned/literally anyone I could plausibly find scummy but wasn't obvious mislynch bait"

Oh wait no then Misty has to be scum shit.

Like I feel it in my bones Grendel is SK

It just makes Misty's play so weird. So very weird. Even for scum. Like any of the times I was scum I literally legit have not minded an SK lynch, it's just like "eh, wasn't on my team, bonus"

I know I am confused.

My gut reads says Grendel SK, not group scum
Mechanically he’s probably group scum
But by play he’s town.

So I am just like fuck it elim the player not trying.

[GreyICE]

I'm all for the elimming the mystery JOAT who couldn't come up with her action and is trying to turn that into a town thing.

[Dannflor]

VOTE: Titus

e-1

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

we have a joat too?

rofl how loaded is this town supposed to be

can I hammer her?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I don't want to get blamed for lol-hammering

[cassowary]

are we still waiting on a replacement for nk15? I think the deadline is still indeterminate atm

I would vote Titus rn too, I just wonder if there's any sense in waiting for the replacement to go through

I do kind of feel like we're just going around in circles and need some actual hard info at this point to progress though

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I am NK15

we are waiting for a replacement for Jesse Pierce

[cassowary]

oh I guess that makes more sense. For some reason I thought you were Jesse. I guess I just got used to thinking of nk15 as "the one who's not here"

[Marky Mark]

Votecount is incorrect, I am voting Pookie. I am down for a Titus elim though and think it is worthwhile her claiming last night's action.

No elims until we have a jesse replacement and partial claim from them pls - that ought to help with setup spec

[Marky Mark]

As previously explained, my role PM is No Power category, but reading between the lines between that and my flavor it *hints* that I may have a certain reasonably negative passive modifier that I am not told about. Just mentioning it in case it helps with thinking through the setup.

[Marky Mark]

I've been thinking about the whole grendel situation more and I'm wondering if I've been too narrow minded in terms of thinking the only way grendel could be mafia faction would be as a scum vig. Something like PGO (anyone targetting him dies) could make sense and might explain something along the lines of Kop targetting him n1.

I still am not sold on him as scum and I think there's a reasonable chance scum would block math (if they have a blocker) after he softed tracker d1, BUT I do think the PGO theory holds more weight than any of the theories we've had so far

[Marky Mark]

I'm a little confused how pooky has 18k posts but was asking basic mech questions eg what a loyal motion detector was

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I'm a little confused how pooky has 18k posts but was asking basic mech questions eg what a loyal motion detector was

cuz that role doesnt exist when i used to play