Dichotomafia- Games Over

[lulu muumuu]

that's true, your results could be really helpful-- unless you're paranoid.... but even then it's probably worth the shot...

[MMCL]

I would look to the cross-section between those that voted me and those that voted for Talitha...

Tally = (MMCL, Fishbulb, Save The Dragons, Wacky, Flying Dutchman, NanookTheWolf)
MMCL = (Mgm, Save The Dragons, NanookTheWolf, Wacky, willows_weep, lulu muumuu, Fuldu, Flying Dutchman)

So my suspicions would be at the door of STD, Nanook, FD, Wacky and Willows Weep (because I think she is scum in particular).

[Save The Dragons]

Forgive me. Day 1 I thought either of you were a good lynch because it would give information, and Day 2 it appeared you were trying something. There wasn't any way we could let you go for killing the innocent, regardless of your own innocence.

Yes, I made a mistake. We all did. But I don't regret it. I did what I had to do.

[NanookTheWolf]

So just because that I voted for two people that I found suspicious in the other thread, I'm being considered as a scum candidate? Why are we contradicting ourselves from yesterday anyways, I thought that we made it a point not to bring the town into the village.

[ralphmerridew]

Well, the fact that you helped to lynch a doctor, a cop, and the fact that there was no kill on the night you were blocked does make you look a bit suspicious.

[NanookTheWolf]

Oh I see ....

[NanookTheWolf]

Oh I see ....

But how does that make me a discussion topic here in the village, I mean wouldn't you think that that would be discussed in oh I don't know, Town, so that the battleground would be more fair?

[the silent speaker]

Fair? I'll give you fair. This is the only place I

can

talk about it, and in fact the whole point of the game is that we can talk about either in both. That way just because you're dead doesn't mean you can't comment on the game.

[NanookTheWolf]

Yes, but in relevance to me? I don't think that you all are quite catching what I am saying, but none the less, I'll wait till we get there before I even try to negotiate anything.

[Flying Dutchman]

If you look through my games you'll find that I'm almost always voting for the day 1 lynchee, I don't like long day 1's. That doesn't mean anything.

[Fishbulb]

I see your point Nanook. Even if we are to bring in any Town suspicions, that doesn't have anything to do with lynching you today. But likewise, I understand the others. They can't talk during the Town's day, so it still needs to be discussed in the Village for them to participate. I don't think they were intending on lynching you right now.

[Talitha]

Yeah - what TSS said. We just want to have our say about the town. Even though we are dead there we're still trying to win. (I'm also one who would like Nanook to be given a severe bandwagoning in the town tomorrow.)

Now for the village:

vote: Peacebringer

Not because willows obviously got a guilty result on him night 1, but because she's now dead.

[Wacky]

I think we might also have to take a close look at PeaceBringer in the other thread as well. MMCL was blocked, and Nanook was blocked. That makes two (that is, unless PB is lying), and probably a mafia blocker in there regardless of whether PB is telling the truth.

But I don't know, he didn't seem very suspicious in the other game.

Reading back I don't feel he's all that suspicious in this game either. But that could change.

Right now, I like the wolfy wagon this game better, I think.

Vote: Nanook

.

[Mgm]

Nanook is a valid lynch candidate in the town, but I don't see any merit in lynching him here. No vote yet..

[NanookTheWolf]

Vote: Wacky

Fishbulb knew what I meant ...

Wacky you are voting me for reasons happening in the town, not here. And what wolfy wagon are you joining considering that you are the only one voting for me.

[Wacky]

As Ralphmerridew said, you're voting for the people who were suspicious in the town. That seems like as good a reason as any.

[Flying Dutchman]

Vote: Nanook

No good reasons, simply shameless bandwagoning.....

[the silent speaker]

vote: Flying Dutchman

. He said he's "shamelessly bandwagoning" Nanook when there wasn't a bandwagon on Nanook yet.

[Talitha]

unvote: Peacebringer

- please let's keep an eye on him - I think he's scum.

vote: Flying Dutchman

- My suspicion from yesterday, and we need to get things moving.

[Flying Dutchman]

I thought Nanook had 2 or 3 votes, turns out he only had 1 before mine, is that such a good reason to vote me? There was no-one with more votes, and a bandwagon has to start SOMEWHERE.....

[Save The Dragons]

How about you?

Vote Flying Dutchman

[Fishbulb]

I'm still interested in this Wacky vs. Nanook exchange. Especially Wacky's reasoning:

As Ralphmerridew said, you're voting for the people who were suspicious in the town. That seems like as good a reason as any.

I don't understand what you mean by that. He's voting you because you were voting him in the town, not the other way around, correct?

vote: Flying Dutchman

. He said he's "shamelessly bandwagoning" Nanook when there wasn't a bandwagon on Nanook yet.

Wacky just did that exact thing to Nanook just a couple posts up. Did you intentionally ignore that?

[Wacky]

Fishbulb: I totally don't get what you are asking.

[NanookTheWolf]

As Ralphmerridew said, you're voting for the people who were suspicious in the town. That seems like as good a reason as any.

Yeah, that may be the case, but that is the case in the town, not the village. We are currently in the village. You do know by voting me here that that is totally unfair, right?

We are playing two different games here, The way I act in one game should not be judge in the other. If you have some evidence of scumminess from the way that I've been acting in the village then I could except your vote, but you don't, all you have is what I've done in the town, which I am not going to defend against until it is day over there again.

Thankfully I am already voting for you.

[NanookTheWolf]

Forgot something ...

Do you really believe that I am scum in the town as well as the village? If your answer is yes, then I want you to show me something from the village that makes you think that.

I would go after Flying Dutchman for his "shameless bandwagoning", but I think Wacky is a much better choice. He is using my actions from the other game to make me look guilty over hear as well. I think that he is scum trying to take a cheap shot.