Open 88 - Polygamist Mafia (Game Over) before 650

[armlx]

You stated you just joined one, but kloud just said to look at votes. Seems like an out of the blue comment to make.

I assume he quickly skimmed the other games.

[kloud1516]

You stated you just joined one, but kloud just said to look at votes. Seems like an out of the blue comment to make.

I assume he quickly skimmed the other games.

This. Refer to post 629.

[Jahudo]

Sorry your right I was given 24 hours because I replaced. Sorry I have another game where someone replaced. The 24 hours to talk is accurate.

Then is it still true that in you and Caboose's pre-game chat you were the one who said hi twice to him because he was a no-show?

If you only had 24 hours after being replaced in, I find it harder to believe that you were waiting for him. I also wonder why Caboose didn't mention anything about the other pre-game lover.

Rest of room: Do you agree or disagree that this is an inconsistency?

[Empking]

It's definitely an inconsistency.

Personally, I don't understand the claims of not being chatty. What is their to be chatty about.

[farside22]

Sorry your right I was given 24 hours because I replaced. Sorry I have another game where someone replaced. The 24 hours to talk is accurate.

Then is it still true that in you and Caboose's pre-game chat you were the one who said hi twice to him because he was a no-show?

If you only had 24 hours after being replaced in, I find it harder to believe that you were waiting for him. I also wonder why Caboose didn't mention anything about the other pre-game lover.

Rest of room: Do you agree or disagree that this is an inconsistency?

I don't know why caboose didn't say anything. I don't recall why I said hi twice.
The was nothing said by caboose before I came into the chat room. I was the first post. So how is this inconsistent?

[farside22]

It's definitely an inconsistency.

Personally, I don't understand the claims of not being chatty. What is their to be chatty about.

You should talk about what the game is about. Things to look for. Should people claim lovers. What is the best things to look for when looking for scum. Something like that would be ideal especially from some people in this game.

[Empking]

The problem is, is that the pairs (other than yours and Armix's) were at the same skill level. They couldn't help each other.

[Jahudo]

>Me: I say that I haven't had any experience with the set-up, but noticed that voting patterns were a key part in hitting scum in previous games.

Are you talking about previous games with identical or similar setups to this? Did you specifically mention it in pre-game because of the setup or would you have said this for a newbie game, etc.?

Also I don't think armix's pre-game was out of character from what he's done in this game.

[farside22]

The problem is, is that the pairs (other than yours and Armix's) were at the same skill level. They couldn't help each other.

Llama is very good in my book as town and scum. Short talks from him don't make sense.

[Empking]

The problem is, is that the pairs (other than yours and Armix's) were at the same skill level. They couldn't help each other.

Llama is very good in my book as town and scum. Short talks from him don't make sense.

I never said llama wasn't good. What would he talk about when Goat is also good?

[farside22]

The problem is, is that the pairs (other than yours and Armix's) were at the same skill level. They couldn't help each other.

Llama is very good in my book as town and scum. Short talks from him don't make sense.

I never said llama wasn't good. What would he talk about when Goat is also good?

You should talk about what the game is about. Things to look for. Should people claim lovers. What is the best things to look for when looking for scum. Something like that would be ideal especially from some people in this game.

[kloud1516]

>Me: I say that I haven't had any experience with the set-up, but noticed that voting patterns were a key part in hitting scum in previous games.

Are you talking about previous games with identical or similar setups to this? Did you specifically mention it in pre-game because of the setup or would you have said this for a newbie game, etc.?

Yes, I was referring to Open 76, which was the same set up as this game. I mentioned it in pre-game conversation specifically for this game, for since the town won in Open 76 I thought it would be a good foundation to start from.

[armlx]

Farside, I don't think you understand. As town, what is there to talk about pre-game in this set up?

[farside22]

Farside, I don't think you understand. As town, what is there to talk about pre-game in this set up?

How many times do I need to quote this:

You should talk about what the game is about. Things to look for. Should people claim lovers. What is the best things to look for when looking for scum. Something like that would be ideal especially from some people in this game.

[armlx]

Why does matter if you discuss those pre-game rather then just point them out in thread when relevant?

[Xtoxm]

Hey guys! Got internet here a week earlier than I was expecting, VC coming up!

[Xtoxm]

Adel has requested replacment, i'll start looking.

Remember - Contact with mod in bold please, only got time to skim atm, check for things in bold.

Vote Count

Farside22 (2) Adel, Empking
Empking (0)
Goatrevolt (1) armlx
Jahudo (0)
Jenethron (0)
armlx (1) Goat
Caboose (0)
Mana_Ku (0)
kloud1516 (0)
Adel (0)

Not Voting (6) Mana_Ku, Jenethron, Jahudo, Farside22, Caboose, Kloud

With 10 alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch.

[Empking]

Mana_ku: Care to post?

[armlx]

Farside, I don't think you understand. As town, what is there to talk about pre-game in this set up?

How many times do I need to quote this:

You should talk about what the game is about. Things to look for. Should people claim lovers. What is the best things to look for when looking for scum. Something like that would be ideal especially from some people in this game.

Again, why?

[Jahudo]

Vote: Farside22

I'd like to get back to real scumhunting, unless there's some point in telling us what we should have done pre-game. The chats were a little interesting; the only minor slip-up was actually in Farside and that only adds to suspicions I've had and listed previously, and can restate if asked.

[farside22]

Who is my scum partner and why Jah?

Well I'm torn between Empkin/ Goat and Armlx/ Kloud.
The question is why wouldn't you talk about the game. The question should be why didn't you talk about the game. To me those being vague on there discussion is more suspect.

Vote: Armlx

Something Goat said makes me think it isn't them. Can't explain gut feelings.
So who do I think is armlx/ kloud partner. I don't know. Something just doesn't make sense and I'm not letting it go.

[Mana_Ku]

Empking, I've posted in our other game that I have some internet problems.

I don't like Farside's last post. First of all, she didn't like Empking's posts about his idea that pairs should claim together. She thought him claiming that she's strawmanning as terrible post 622.
Second, Goat and Empking descriptions don't match. At the end, Empking said that Llama and Goat were talking about Football. Goat said that Llama and he were talking about a different game.

I'm going to

Vote Empking

. I'll give Farside one chance to explain. Otherwise, I can see a Emp/Goat-Farside/Caboose pair. As for now, I can see Empking as scum. The way he played day 1 and his attack of the fake strawman of Farside.

[farside22]

Empking, I've posted in our other game that I have some internet problems.

I don't like Farside's last post. First of all, she didn't like Empking's posts about his idea that pairs should claim together. She thought him claiming that she's strawmanning as terrible post 622.
Second, Goat and Empking descriptions don't match. At the end, Empking said that Llama and Goat were talking about Football. Goat said that Llama and he were talking about a different game.

I'm going to

Vote Empking

. I'll give Farside one chance to explain. Otherwise, I can see a Emp/Goat-Farside/Caboose pair. As for now, I can see Empking as scum. The way he played day 1 and his attack of the fake strawman of Farside.

I wish I could explain my gut feeling on this. But lets look at what empking and Goat said:

Goat said:

Llama: Yo Goat, what's up, this should be a good team.
Goat: Definitely. We were good last time as town together.
Llama: Never played this game, not sure what to talk about.
Goat: Nor have I. I'm guessing the key is to look at lover pairs not individuals.
Llama: Agreed. I don't recognize many of the players.
Goat: I've played with a decent number of them.
Llama: [Random comments about a different game we played in.]

Empking Said:

Post 1 - Saying they're a good lover pair
Post 3 - Saying they isn't much to discuss
Post 5 - Saying they're are quite a few new players

Worded differently, but the same thing. Surprised that Llama didn't ask Goat about the players he knew to see if anyone would be easier to read then others.

[Mana_Ku]

Let's see what Empking said afterwards as well.

That's not all that was said. It was just that Llama and Goats we're talking about things unrelated to the game after that.

They said Football but I think they meant American football.

What do you have to say about 'your strawman' which Empking mentioned?

[farside22]

Let's see what Empking said afterwards as well.

That's not all that was said. It was just that Llama and Goats we're talking about things unrelated to the game after that.

They said Football but I think they meant American football.

What do you have to say about 'your strawman' which Empking mentioned?

I didn't get Empking's argument. It was pointelss.
Hmm reading the comments they made I thought Goat was talking about the open game, but empking says they were talking about football. That makes no sense.