Mafia 85 - Murder at the Bus Stop (game over)

[Xtoxm]

Sorry for abscence. Quite busy atm. I'll try to get back to daily posting now that i've got access, and a standard timetable.

Without much looking through the thread:

Fos Jebus
Fos Armlx
Vote Shanba

Mod: not counted, unvote first

I'll try to read the thread and give some opinions at some point.

Mod edit
Votecount:
Slicey (11): Wall-E, Shanba, armlx, Surye, farside22, Riceballtail, Moratorium, Empking, BlakAdder, Alabaska J, al4xz
Surye (2): Demon Pineapple, Sir Tornado
Empking (2): RestFermata, Slicey
Wall-E (1): Mana_Ku
farside22 (1): martin413
armlx (1): Xtoxm
Xtoxm (1): killa seven

Not voting (6): Azuma, Cream147, Slepz, ace1217, Megatheory, Jebus

With 25 alive it's 13 to lynch.

[Surye]

Sorry for abscence. Quite busy atm. I'll try to get back to daily posting now that i've got access, and a standard timetable.

Without much looking through the thread:

Fos Jebus
Fos Armlx
Vote Shanba

I'll try to read the thread and give some opinions at some point.

I'd love to hear some reasons for the FoS' and vote.

[armlx]

See above.

[Xtoxm]

Jebus - One of her posts where she made an excuse for not posting struck me kinda like scum wanting an excuse.

Armlx - I feel his buddying to me is not genuine, his reaction around my joke was a bit odd.

Shanba - Saw a few of his posts, and I can't really explain but I just found him scummy.

[Shanba]

Which posts?

[Wall-E]

Shanba - Saw a few of his posts, and I can't really explain but I just found him scummy.

Usually when I make a post like this I DO have a reason, but it's a reason others might not agree with or might think is totally unconventional, so I call it "gut" to avoid people jumping my $#!+ over it.

Is that the case here?

[armlx]

Armlx - I feel his buddying to me is not genuine, his reaction around my joke was a bit odd.

I thought you were legitmately trying to carry on a vendetta with respect to the joke. I'm not going to discuss the matter more for obvious reasons.

[Wall-E]

This is why we don't tell jokes until after the game's over.

[Xtoxm]

Uhh...The recent ones. The ones I read, basically.

I thought you were legitmately trying to carry on a vendetta with respect to the joke. I'm not going to discuss the matter more for obvious reasons.

That has nothing to do with my point, as far as I can see.

And I will say this: What you are thinking of has nothing to do with any vendetta. My play in whatever game you are thinking of is/was genuine.

[Xtoxm]

Forgot to respond to WE.

No not really, it is just that i'm finding him scummy, but i'm not entirely sure why.

[Azuma]

I haven't posted anything in 22 pages, well.. because I was confused. I'm sorry. I'll be active now.

[Wall-E]

holy goat saucers

can you give us a top 3?

[Moratorium]

Confused about what? The gameplay itself?

We'd all like to hear your opinion on the Slicey voting.

[Alabaska J]

I'd just as rather give them night to catch up.

[Jebus]

@Xotxm: I partially agree with the Shanba vote, though it'll depend how Slicey turns up as.

[armlx]

No not really, it is just that i'm finding him scummy, but i'm not entirely sure why.

Figure out why?

I'd just as rather give them night to catch up.

Rather have opinions before alignment is revealed.

[killa seven]

I'd just as rather give them night to catch up.

Im sure you would.

[Moratorium]

Day 1 is dying a slow death.

[armlx]

Waiting on replacements its the nut low.

[Lawrencelot]

Gremwell replaces Mana_Ku.

Deadline: Friday October 3rd 9 PM GMT.

[Lawrencelot]

A reminder of the rules at deadline:

At deadline, the person with the most votes will be lynched. In case of a tie, I will “go back in time” until the point before there was a tie, to determine who will be lynched.

[Surye]

Welcome Gremwell!

[Wall-E]

The deadline is two days away. I don't think it would be impossible for us to change targets today, but I do think it would be difficult, and arbitrary, as I personally haven't seen behavior worse than Slicey's, and I doubt anyone's going to do something so bad as to warrant a mass voteshift.

But.

We DO still have two days to discuss Slicey's lynch, so I want everyone to give their opinion on whether or not they think Slicey is scum.

I'll start by saying I feel it's 60% likely Slicey is scum, 40% likely he just made some weird choices as town and got everyone's hackles raised. Basically, I'm a little meh on this lynch, but overall I feel Slicey's likely scum.

[Shanba]

@Xotxm: I partially agree with the Shanba vote, though it'll depend how Slicey turns up as.

Two-for-one?

I was going to unvote here, then we got deadlined. I'm happy enough with a slicey lynch.

Wall-E, you're absolutely right. Slicey is as good a lynch as any, better than most for a day 1 lynch.

[RestFermata]

I feel that Slicey is the best lynch for D1, for the reasons I stated before. He seems to be making cases out of nothing, something that scum is always forced to do in Mafia. But I agree that no one should hammer. We should definitely wait for the deadline to get the most out of this day. If we could get the lurkers to post before then, it'll be even better.