Mini 624 - Game Over!

[Wumbo]

yay time. I meant to come back before the hammer was cast

I concur with a no lynch vote. It is not beneficial for us to do anything now. Just make the mafia kill so that we aren't cluttered with attacks on the last day of x player lynched y player incorrectly. It's a deliberate tactic to hide under the shroud of misinformation.

Also, told you SC was scum. Boo freaking yah.

vote: No Lynch

[geraintm]

no lynch then

[Cass]

Not that it matters anymore, but I agree.

Vote: No lynch

[Hypatia]

Fittingly for the vernal equinox, night falls sooner than it used to in our little town. No one dies.

PLAYERS:

1. Cass

Tom

2. Wumbo

3. imaginality - Townie

4. Inspector Godot - Mafia Goon

5. chenhsi - Town Cop

6. Dark wingstalker - Mafia Godfather

7. nhat - Town Forensic Investigator
8. maxwellhouse - Town Cop

9. StrangerCoug - Mafia Goon

10. Battousai

Kenfucius

11. geraintm

12. Litral - Townie

Day will dawn at around 8 pm on WEDNESDAY SEPTEMBER 24. Send in your night actions.

[Hypatia]

As the sun rises, another body appears. Cass, a Townie, is dead.

PLAYERS:

1. Cass

Tom

- Townie

2. Wumbo

3. imaginality - Townie

4. Inspector Godot - Mafia Goon

5. chenhsi - Town Cop

6. Dark wingstalker - Mafia Godfather

7. nhat - Town Forensic Investigator
8. maxwellhouse - Town Cop

9. StrangerCoug - Mafia Goon

10. Battousai

Kenfucius

11. geraintm

12. Litral - Townie

With 3 alive, it is 2 to lynch.

[Battousai]

Oh, I love WIFOM. I stated earlier that I really don't think Wumbo is scum. But the remaining scum left me alive, why I ask myself? Is it because Wumbo is scum and wants me to vote to lynch Geraintm? Or does Geraintm think that I would think that and actually vote Wumbo. Or may Wumbo......

Or Cass is dead just because she was almost a confirmed townie, the way SC was trying to get Cass lynched would have been bad scum play.

To get the day started, lets get a preliminary count of how everybody stands right now, prereread (can a word have two prefixes like that?).

For me its geraintm > wumbo as scum

[geraintm]

Ok, seen the result now
Seen Batt's post

when did you say you thought wumbo wasnt scum?
and you do realise i am sitting there thinking the exact same thing about you two, why would either of you leave me alone and go the end game with me in it. What is it about you two which makes one of you think that i will be persuadable.
um, i have thought one of you was more likely to be scum than the other, but i havent got real strong feelings, it was more of a gut than anything

[Wumbo]

Posting from class, lmao.

I'm 1-1 for scum... could have sworn that Cass was the last scum.

At any rate, I've had doubts about Geraintm, especially in the last few days as I notice he continued to harp on my posting while simultaneously doing the same thing. But Batt coming out that strongly in my favor in the past, while appreciated, could be just a ploy to win my trust...

[Wumbo]

EBWODP: Now that I think about it, actually, pre-re-read, I definitely want to go with geraintm. I don't recall him bringing any light to the SC situation other than himself and Cass (who is town) wanting to kill me instead of SC. Batt consistently fought SC.

I'm going to refrain from casting a vote until everyone else speaks again, though.

[Battousai]

The day I claimed, I said I thought Wumbo was innocent.

[geraintm]

I don't recall him bringing any light to the SC situation other than himself and Cass (who is town) wanting to kill me instead of SC. Batt consistently fought SC.

.

just a quick post before i write more later.
would my week long abesnce about two weeks ago explain at all why you think i wasnt doing anything with Cass?

[geraintm]

Batt, what made you say wumbo was innocent? You havent given any reason as far as i can see.
My whole read of him this whoel game has been so hard cause he has given me hardly anything to do on. Are you going to vote me cause i've posted more

hate to do one of those "but i can't be me cause i..."
but i think i've voted for every scum member, i might even have been the hammer in a
bunch of cases too.

i still don't know which one of you is scum. not making this any easier

[geraintm]

I meant to point out teh voting thing to try and get you batt to tell me why you thinki am scum, i'd have been bussing them all so hard if that was the case.

[Battousai]

It stems back to D1 where I DWS kept trying to get wumbo lynched over himself. I do not believe that was a case of bussing, as it almost got Wumbo lynched (and DWS lynched the next day).

I'm not sold on anyone's guilt yet. I still have to reread most of the thread

[geraintm]

oh, ok
at least i know now why you think that
i am going to be away the weekend now
so won't be able to post any more today
would have posted more today, but work was busy

[Battousai]

I'm going to vote geraintm monday (giving him some time to defend himself if he wishes). After reading the thread, I really don't see Wumbo as scum. Sure he claimed early and lurked a bit, but I don't find lurking too scummy and the early claim doesn't tip the scales towards him being scum.

[Wumbo]

I'm gonna go ahead and do it now.

vote: geraintm

I stake my claim on the fact that Batt's not pulling the wool over my eyes. If he is, then that's a job damn well done. I've looked back and SC and Batt fought just as much as me and SC did. Geraintm continued to bring up my lack of involvement even though it became clear by the end of the game that I was very much involved.

Good luck town XD

[geraintm]

really?
so you boththink i am scum?
batt, i know you have said you thought wumbo wasnt scum day one, but have you ever thought i was???
Can anyone actualyl find anything i;ve done that was scummy? i will stand by my voting record as probably the best of anyone in the game. why on earth would i have voted for cougar a few nights ago, i was pretty hardcore on him through out the day.
i am saying this because i am hoping wumbo is going to unvote in cae batt is the last member, or in case wumbo is the last scum then to not have batt hammer.

[Battousai]

time to hammer mwuahhahah go scum!!!!!

nah jk

Geraintm: I'll go back and look at your posts again, but from memory the scummiest thing you have done that stands out to me is D1 where you make someone's reason for voting DWS seem suspicious by cutting out the paragraph where he states his case against him and leave only the ending sentence.

[geraintm]

and that was it batt?
that is all you have on me? a day one post where i snipped a bit froma quoted post.
will you go through and find all thethings where i haven't been scummy?
and please don't vote for me before i have a chance to reply

You refusal though to vote fo rme means

vote wumbo [\b] because it has to be him.
i'll try and go through and see what he has actually posted.

[geraintm]

I do find it REALLY annoying that imaginality keeps harping me on posting.

I'm not dissappearing or anything. But I have a life outside of MS. :/

wumbo, i asn't the onyl one who thought you were lurking, yet it is what you have battered me over the head with teh last few game days

post july 15th, unvoting dark, and then on teh 18th explaining it for his singing voice. for someone who has voted so few times in this game, seems sucha poor reason to unvote the godfather.

post on the 19t aug, again unvoting cougar, who later turns up as scum.

did you actually vote to lynch anyone wumbo???
batt, please go through my votes and see who i voted for. i am pretty sure i lynched and hammered all 3 scum. i am sick that i let wumbo get away with his no show the first few days, shoul dhve pressured him way more to contribute then to have given us something to go on.

[Battousai]

Geraintm: Your using the fact that you hammered all three scum so far as a towntell, no? Then why did you, on D1, basically say it was a nulltell? Is it no longer a nulltell now that your on the line?

Upon reading my post 469, I was able to reread my earlier interpretation of the first DWS wagon. From it, for the players left alive:
Wumbo- placed second vote for bad reasoning
Geraintm- calls DWS an enthusiastic newb after DWS hastily called out Litral for an L-1 vote earlier on wumbo (which was wrong
Wumbo- unvotes DWS to allevate pressure because of his recent posts

Also, I hammered DWS, you were the 4th vote. Therefore you only hammered 2 scum.

I hate being the deciding vote at lylo, unless I'm scum of course. I'm not that good of a town player. I want an answer to the above question and a response from both of you before I place the deciding vote (if geraintm decides to revote correctly that is), hopefully later today.

[geraintm]

hammering day one i think is a null tell. there is too much noise then to get anything from it. go check other games i have played, i am very consistent in that.

but ot have voted 3 scum and to have killed off 2 scum, and one of them being cougar when i think he if he hadnt have died, then that means that i killed off my partner when if he has survived i think it was game over. there has to be something in that. surely?
and espcially when you compare it to wumbo whose i think voted and unvoted two different mafia members.
you say you hate being the deciding vote in situations like this. i hate being so frustrated that the game could end up as a waste of time after this long.

[Wumbo]

Posting from class so you know I'm alive. XD

[Battousai]

Posting from class as well , could your next post tell me what you think about my last post?