Mafia 85 - Murder at the Bus Stop (game over)

[armlx]

Slicey is a very good lynch at this point. Unfortunately replacements won't get here in time to comment.

Mod edit
Votecount:
Slicey (11): Wall-E, Shanba, armlx, Surye, farside22, Riceballtail, Moratorium, Empking, BlakAdder, Alabaska J, al4xz
Surye (2): Demon Pineapple, Sir Tornado
Empking (2): RestFermata, Slicey
Wall-E (1): Mana_Ku
farside22 (1): martin413
armlx (1): Xtoxm
Xtoxm (1): killa seven

Not voting (6): Azuma, Cream147, Slepz, ace1217, Megatheory, Jebus

With 25 alive it's 13 to lynch.

[Xtoxm]

We DO still have two days to discuss Slicey's lynch, so I want everyone to give their opinion on whether or not they think Slicey is scum.

I have no opinion on Slicey at this point. If i've read anything of his, it has not stood out to me in either direction. Given the nature of this wagon, and the fact he has apparantly claimed to be a townie, I would say he is most likely to be town, at this point.

[armlx]

Mind elaborating on that last bit xtoxm?

[Xtoxm]

When a quick wagon springs up like this on Day One, and they claim townie, the suspect is more often than not telling the truth.

[Xtoxm]

I should be working.

Instead, I decided to take a look at Slicey's posts.

I have not seen the cases made, but I saw nothing I found scummy, and I get pretty much a standard town read from him.

Why is he so popular, out of interest?

[RestFermata]

People think his case on Empking is fabricated and not consistent with Empking's actual posts.

[Xtoxm]

I checked this "case".

I fail to see how anyone could draw that conclusion.

I am now officially against this wagon.

[RestFermata]

Who do you find most scummy, xtoxm?

[Wall-E]

Xtoxm: I made a case that Slicey might be right in attacking Empking earlier in the thread. Did you read it, Xtoxm? What did you think?

[Shanba]

Yet you attack me rather than those following me?

[RestFermata]

Wait, yeah. You said Shanba, that's right, xtoxm. But have you figured out why yet?

[Wall-E]

I'm not following Shanba. I think I was actually first to vote Slicey, for reasons other than his case on Empking. Shanba, claiming that others are following you is a bit of a strange claim.

[Xtoxm]

The three I named are my best attempts thus far.

Please try to understand I have read only about, 10% of the thread at this moment, and I don't have full knowledge of what's going on.

WE - I have not read said case. I viewed their posts by isolation. I'll take a look for it.

[Xtoxm]

Wait, yeah. You said Shanba, that's right, xtoxm. But have you figured out why yet?

I have not. Something just didn't feal right when I read some of his posts.

[Xtoxm]

Well that was a headache. WE, I could not find the case you mention. Please link. I don't necessarily think Slicey's case is good, but I certainly don't find it scummy, is my current thought.

WE, if you're vote on Slicey was not a joke vote, then it is terribly poor reasoning.

[Xtoxm]

Your isolation posts 30-34 were the ones I didn't like.

[armlx]

Xtoxm, what do you not understand about how Shanba's conclusion was made?

[Alabaska J]

Xtoxm, if it helps, I agree with you that Shanba is scum.

Seriously though, I think you should read the whole thread and then comment and Slicey.

[Surye]

I checked this "case".

I fail to see how anyone could draw that conclusion.

I am now officially against this wagon.

This is the best D1 wagon I have ever seen. I hope you plan to read the game.

[armlx]

It's good, not the best ever. But the later part applies. Read plz.

[Wall-E]

Well that was a headache. WE, I could not find the case you mention. Please link. I don't necessarily think Slicey's case is good, but I certainly don't find it scummy, is my current thought.

WE, if you're vote on Slicey was not a joke vote, then it is terribly poor reasoning.

I was actually

defending

Slicey (as best I could, given my natural biases/policies).

I'll go dig up some quotes, if you'd like, but you're entitled to your opinion. I wish you'd do more than simply say "No." with no real statements of why.

Do you feel that Slicey was right when he claimed Empking was pushing for a lynch, and didn't care who died?

Do you feel that Empking is scummy?

[Surye]

It's good, not the best ever. But the later part applies. Read plz.

I haven't played as many games as you maybe, it's the best day one I've seen

[Sir Tornado]

I have no opinion on Slicey at this point. If i've read anything of his, it has not stood out to me in either direction. Given the nature of this wagon, and the fact he has apparantly claimed to be a townie, I would say he is most likely to be town, at this point.

When a quick wagon springs up like this on Day One, and they claim townie, the suspect is more often than not telling the truth.

I agree with this.

[armlx]

When a quick wagon springs up like this on Day One, and they claim townie, the suspect is more often than not telling the truth.

Does more often then not = more then proportionate to the townie:scum ratio?

[Gremwell]

hey all, /replacing Mana_Ku I have a bit of reading to do