Mafia 85 - Murder at the Bus Stop (game over)

[farside22]

There are too many people absent from this game, and I don't feel like attacking anyone who's active right now.

Vote K7

Is this serious?

Why the habitual lurker over the person who wanted lurker lynches then started lurking, while making no real stances in the game.

I didn't even know K-7 was playing this game. Why him out of the 4 other lurkers in the game?

Mod edit
Votecount:
Surye (4): springlullaby, Riceballtail, Muerrto, Wall-E
Cream147 (3): Empking, BlakAdder, armlx
Jebus (2): farside22, Shanba
killa seven (1): Xtoxm

Not voting (12): Megatheory, Azuma, RestFermata, Gremwell, Alabaska J, Cream147, Jebus, Slepz, killa seven, Zazier, al4xz, Surye

With 22 alive it's 12 to lynch.

[Xtoxm]

Because he always lurks to endgame and everyone refuses to lynch him, because "lynching lurkers is bad", and it's ridiculous.

[Empking]

Xtoxm: Does that make him more likely to be scum?

[Xtoxm]

You think it makes him more likely to be town?

[Empking]

No.

[farside22]

Because he always lurks to endgame and everyone refuses to lynch him, because "lynching lurkers is bad", and it's ridiculous.

meh he lurks as town. He lurks as scum. Depending on what he says I sometimes can sense when he is scum or town.

[armlx]

You think it makes him more likely to be town?

That's not an excuse. What makes any of the other lurkers any different.

OH wait, I made a case on Cream. Hmm....

[Xtoxm]

I don't think anyone active is scummy enough to warrant being lynched right now.

So even if it's a guess, I think this is a good way to go.

Plus, it'll mkae the game more active if non-participaters die.

[Lawrencelot]

Killa Seven, Slepz, Azuma and Megatheory have been prodded.

Deadline: October 22, Noon GMT

[Xtoxm]

You think it makes him more likely to be town?

That's not an excuse. What makes any of the other lurkers any different.

OH wait, I made a case on Cream. Hmm....

Cream is legitimately V/LA, and some of the stuff he said prior to that struck me as town.

[Xtoxm]

Yay a deadline.

[Xtoxm]

And people are doing it again.

I don't get why everyone refuses to consider someone who practically refuses to participate for a lynch.

[Empking]

5 days, oh god.

We don't want to lynch someone who isn't scummy.

[farside22]

Killa Seven, Slepz, Azuma and Megatheory have been prodded.

Deadline: October 22, Noon GMT

A deadline and on my b-day. I get a present early.

[armlx]

Cream is legitimately V/LA, and some of the stuff he said prior to that struck me as town.

What stuff specifically?

[Xtoxm]

Well I don't remember what exactly, I just remember thinking it.

[Surye]

I feel that a lynch of a lurker is better odds to hit scum then anyone I see playing actively right now, but, I really hate trying to find the best lurker to vote as there is, by nature, little to analyze.

Cream's anti-lurk stance followed by his lurking is very odd. K7 hardly plays in any game. Megatheory WAS active, and now is not when the conversation flaired up. Slepz and Azuma, I've got no idea.

Given that, Cream or MT seem like the best course of action at this point. Will consider which gets my vote.

[farside22]

I feel that a lynch of a lurker is better odds to hit scum then anyone I see playing actively right now, but, I really hate trying to find the best lurker to vote as there is, by nature, little to analyze.

Cream's anti-lurk stance followed by his lurking is very odd. K7 hardly plays in any game. Megatheory WAS active, and now is not when the conversation flaired up. Slepz and Azuma, I've got no idea.

Given that, Cream or MT seem like the best course of action at this point. Will consider which gets my vote.

Actually that is true about MT. I wonder if he is playing else where or just disappeared.
(goes to check)

[Surye]

He's been off the site since Sept 28! Guess that means

Vote: Cream

He's the worst kind of lurker really. He pokes his head in every few days to try to stay off the lurker list.

[Xtoxm]

No, he was active and then had RL problems. And he said he'll get back to normal soon.

[Cream147]

He's been off the site since Sept 28! Guess that means

Vote: Cream

He's the worst kind of lurker really. He pokes his head in every few days to try to stay off the lurker list.

Whatever, did I not self-admit I was lurking...actually, I think I said something like 'I'm not up with this game or something'. I've already said I agree with pressurising lurkers but don't try to misrepresent me. I haven't tried to avoid the lurker list. I'm just not up with the cases in this game because I've got behind in reading and so I feel very much out of it. I need to get very much back into it...

[Cream147]

(Oh, and the reason I got this behind with reading is because of my unexpected V/LA...I do feel like a real hypocrite though)

[Xtoxm]

Cream, what do you think of my case on K7?

[springlullaby]

I'm retracting my town read on Xtoxm, now I think he could go either way.

I still think Surye is red-handed scum:
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 42#1300342
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 25#1300525

1. His 'this is going to come up tomorrow' comment is scummy in itself because it possibly indicates that he assumed he was going to survives the night.

2. More importantly, his priding himself in being consistent in his suspicions is a dead giveaway imo because
a)consistency is the least of town's worry while casting suspicions
b)it indicates that he wasn't planning to - and indeed didn't - take into account the event of the night and the resulting death in his view of the game: town doesn't think like that, after a night, town see the cardflips and realign their thinking.

3. His suspicions on RestFermata, which were tentative and flaccid to begin with, seem to have deflated on the spot and altogether when they were met with less than enthusiasm and a little criticism.

So yeah, I like my vote where it is.

[springlullaby]

EBWOP

Note here that I'm not against policy lynching lurkers in this game.