Mini Theme 2259: Superfight Mafia!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I don't need a walkie when I'm psychic

[Enchant]

Game staling, when we start murdering?

[Galron]

K. We're good then.

[Radical Rat]

how is NK15 still alive

We still have a slot that hasn't posted at all yet, and should PROBABLY be waiting on that to either show up or get replaced before we start killing people for real

[Jingle]

speaking of:

@mod: what are your activity rules?

48 hour prod timers.

Speaking of which…

Replacing Cyrus62 for failing to pick up their role pm.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

how is NK15 still alive

We still have a slot that hasn't posted at all yet, and should PROBABLY be waiting on that to either show up or get replaced before we start killing people for real

I don't see how this is related in any way to dropkicking NK15 into a new timezone

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Game staling, when we start murdering?

towniest post on this page

[Radical Rat]

how is NK15 still alive

We still have a slot that hasn't posted at all yet, and should PROBABLY be waiting on that to either show up or get replaced before we start killing people for real

I don't see how this is related in any way to dropkicking NK15 into a new timezone

They could potentially show up and be even scummier. Or they could catch the townslip NK15 made but we all missed. Also they could wind up getting murdered (or in this case nominated to fight) without getting to post even once, which isn't fun for anyone.

[Enchant]

Game staling, when we start murdering?

towniest post on this page

More townier than yours?

[Firebringer]

Game staling, when we start murdering?

im committed to peace

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Game staling, when we start murdering?

towniest post on this page

More townier than yours?

I'm confscum

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Game staling, when we start murdering?

im committed to peace

you're so sexy when you say "peace"

[Not Known 15]

Game staling, when we start murdering?

The game is stalling because there are some complacent people who haven't expressed a single read, or the absence of reads other than null. Scum are probably waiting for someone to vote me to E-1 so that Not Mafia can lolhammer and produce a cheap mislim.
Well, this situation again...
So... can someone tell me why they are not voting jjh? Or why jjh is supposed to be town?

[Not Known 15]

Now, to something else, yes, people should reveal whom they send in as a contestant. I'll probably select an old man in a wheelchair because I am probably a better nightkill then the alternative.

[TemporalLich]

Galron seems like a towny thoughtstreamer

Enchant is null but is promising

also, please don't reveal your fight choices as that ruins the spirit of the game

[jjh927]

I could explain why I'm not voting jjh if you like

[jjh927]

For what it's worth, NK15, I think you have no idea how to effectively scumhunt, and this is the exact situation you had going for you with your tunnel on the fire/pooky hydra in RC's latest upick. That is to say, I think you are town here

I am looking forward to you tunneling on me all game and everyone ignoring you

[jjh927]

Revealing your fight choices removes the fight mechanic and turns it into a "vote on who you want NKed" mechanic and I am not up for that as it's not what I signed up for

It may be mechanically optimal but it's not fun or in the spirit of things

[jjh927]

Although actually I'll shut this one down with logic

There is counterplay to declaring your fighters. The rules do not indicate that the winner of a fight is revealed, only that the loser dies. Therefore scum could put themselves in the fight against a town member and submit the fighter declared by someone who is more widely townread etc

[jjh927]

Wait that's dumb they would just put the town person in nvm

[jjh927]

Yeah there's just no counterplay I guess

I thought there was something there with regard to people being confirmed and shit but there just isn't

However it would totally suck


What the game really needs is a Fight Adjudication and Referee Team that solves the disputes as an independent third party

[TemporalLich]

if this is indeed mountainous the EV of this setup is scumsided

[Enchant]

Remind me, why should't i steal fighter of different player to survive if i even find myself in position where i can lose fight?

Because it's something i will do if happens.

[TemporalLich]

Remind me, why should't i steal fighter of different player to survive if i even find myself in position where i can lose fight?

Because it's something i will do if happens.

and this is why we should not pre-announce fighters

[TemporalLich]

well, that's the mechanical reason why, the true reason why is that it would ruin the Superfight aspect of the game