Mini Theme 2264: Fusion Upick | Post Game

[Enchant]

Just in a case, i started making assumptions after there's no Gunsmith claims, but Vigilante and Vengeful pair was viable.

Does Vengeful+Vigilante even result in Vengesmith?
Via ability, not.
But with other sense, it could be possibility.

Also mod is sadist.

[Noraa]

a50-? is the team

[Enchant]

Do you think A50 faked visit from Flea?

[Noraa]

its almost never a50-radical because that doesn't feel right at all.

[Noraa]

Do you think A50 faked visit from Flea?

theres fishy stuff in those two claims and if a50 is not scum and you are not either, then the team is csf and radical and that makes even less sense than a50 faking a visit

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Who is mafia team for ya?
CSF, Noree?

Is there more to this beyond PoE?

[Enchant]

Who is mafia team for ya?
CSF, Noree?

Is there more to this beyond PoE?

I didn't understand.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

I'm mostly curious why you think I'm scum

[MegAzumarill]

Vote Count 5.0.1


Not Voting: (5) Almost50, Radical Rat, Enchant, Noraa, Cat Scratch Fever

With 5 votes it takes 3 to eliminate.

Deadline: (expired on 2022-03-25 06:43:09)

[Radical Rat]

Flea visiting A50 is actually a very good point I hadn't considered yet.

If A50 faked it, Flea corroborated it, which makes fine sense if they're buddies... EXCEPT that Flea ALSO claimed it in the post where fae outed themselves with the Toog visit. If fae were going to be faking visits, you'd expect faer to also fake the guilty one. So I'm inclined to believe fae's claimed visits were true. And it does indeed make No Sense for Flea to target A50 with that particular ability if they're buddies.

So, A50 can be safely assumed to be Town, which means.... Noraa/Enchant/CSF are the only remaining possibilities. Enchant I still quite firmly townread, so.... Yeah, I'm ready to vote I think, pending input from others.

[Noraa]

except that is wrong and at the very most, has 1 scum in csf. i somewhat think enchant is town, or at least is pretending to be towny unlike some people

[Noraa]

If fae were going to be faking visits, you'd expect faer to also fake the guilty one.

a normal mafia player wouldn't think guiltying two scum in one post is somethign that makes sense. but here you are.

[Radical Rat]

If fae were going to be faking visits, you'd expect faer to also fake the guilty one.

a normal mafia player wouldn't think guiltying two scum in one post is somethign that makes sense. but here you are.

And yet, it happened. It doesn't do any good to go on about how scum wouldn't do x, when scum has objectively already done x

[Noraa]

are you trying to say that you've seen scum guilty two scum in one post more than you've seen a single scum slip?

[Noraa]

like your argument does not make sense. you're like "oh because flea guiltied faerself, fae would've guiltied a50 if a50 were a scum buddy"

[Noraa]

ok lets put this a different way
do you think it's more likely that i remember that soemone who died on day 2 claimed something that might guilty me if i claim a certain night action or that my partner (who probably put this in the scum pt big and in bold) claimed an action with me

[Noraa]

if a scum buddy is claiming an action that needs your confirming, they ALWAYS communicate it with you in the scum pt at some point.
the scum slip was bad, but you are saying that a scum team that successfully got to a three scum elo decided to not even talk through something as big as confirming an action. That is one action and 2 guilties if gone wrong.

a50 is scum here and i cant see a world where they arent.

[Noraa]

[radical, a50] has scum and radical being bad town makes a lot more sense here

[Radical Rat]

My point is more that a hypothetical scumteam of A50/Flea thought enough about their actions to claim visiting with an interaction to clear one of them, but somehow DIDN'T think to cover their bases with the claimed investigative result.

[Noraa]

which one seems more likely to get discussed in the scum pt? something that could guilty 2 scum or something that could guilty 1?

[Noraa]

like you seem to think that a50 is cleared through this interaction and you're literally the only one.
a50 is not cleared and i've spelled out why very clearly.

[Radical Rat]

Y'know, this whole trying to engage with my scumreads in good faith is a habit of mine that usually bites me in the ass, and I genuinely just don't find your arguments convincing here anyway, so I think it's time to stop going in circles here.

I will be voting Noraa in 24 hours unless someone that isn't Noraa gives me a good reason not to

[Noraa]

when your arguments are literally terrible, yeah it will bite you in the ass lmao

[Noraa]

let's list your arguments rq
1) flea didn't guilty faerself and a50, therefore a50 is town
2) noraa is scum because ze misunderstood dwlee's role and thought flea claiming to target toog was tstbs

[Noraa]

vote me out. lose the game