Open 853 - PYP X/Y S_S [game over!]

[Titus]

hi i'm here.

does order matter or should i go

Please go now.

[implosion]

PR.

[Titus]

PR.

Not n3 vig I assume right?

[implosion]

Nope.

[implosion]

I do like where this could be going though.

[Titus]

Alright then. I'm going to suppose HQ didn't take n3 vig to move the game along.

No one supports Mathblade's claim.......but me. I picked n3 vig because I have nerd and impulse issues. The fact it was already gone made me suspicious. Unless HQ claims, there is at least one scum above me.

That means StD Roden Math and Dwlee has at maximum one scum.

[Titus]

Now we need Wallflower StD and Dwlee to reveal their choices and why they made them.

[MathBlade]

Alright then. I'm going to suppose HQ didn't take n3 vig to move the game along.

No one supports Mathblade's claim.......but me. I picked n3 vig because I have nerd and impulse issues. The fact it was already gone made me suspicious. Unless HQ claims, there is at least one scum above me.

That means StD Roden Math and Dwlee has at maximum one scum.

For those of us who are not where you are (likely just me)
Why do you say STD/Roden/Dwlee/Me has a max of 1 scum?

Can you explain that please?

[Aristeia]

because she's saying someone above her is scum and picked n3 vig or vengeful so there can only be 1 scum below her if any exist

[MathBlade]

because she's saying someone above her is scum and picked n3 vig or vengeful so there can only be 1 scum below her if any exist

Ah. So 50/50 split

[Aristeia]

well no it could be 2 scum above her in pick order

max 1 doesn't mean there has to be one.

[MathBlade]

well no it could be 2 scum above her in pick order

max 1 doesn't mean there has to be one.

Right

So we just repeat this with the VTs and we can find where the scum are building nested ifs and maybe a search tree.

[Wallflower]

Now we need Wallflower StD and Dwlee to reveal their choices and why they made them.

I’m still waiting to hear from the mods what Mala chose

[Titus]

Correct.

That changes if HQ picked n3 vig in third slot or vengeful for some reason. HQ would be the only person who I might suspect would take vengeful so high up and be town but I highly doubt she would.

Now the reason we have the VTs go next in a place where we know there's a missing PR is that scum will know what PRs are in the game from any VT failures that happened. However, if a scum is hiding in the VTs then they won't know what PR to claim unless they copy someone else.

A claim of n3 vig/vengeful I would view as suspect.

[Titus]

Now we need Wallflower StD and Dwlee to reveal their choices and why they made them.

I’m still waiting to hear from the mods what Mala chose

You weren't told this immediately?

[Wallflower]

I was not

[Titus]

Math, who is the scum above me?

[Ausuka]

My Dwlee/math team is in SHAMBLES right now

But yeah uh seems fairly likely we have a mafia vengeful? If it gets limmed in 7p or 5p elo mafia win the game so it's an alright pick for them

[Dwlee99]

Aren't we supposed to wait for HQ before we say what we picked

[Save The Dragons]

What's up party people

[Roden]

@Roden

do you see what I'm seeing?

VOTE: mathblade
thinking this is radio buzz v2 (2 scum wagoned D1, weird shit with a doctor CC where presumably both slots involved are town)

Yeah I'm seeing it. Math's play this game has been so fucking weird, I don't understand what he's doing or why if he's town. At this point I feel like he's just scum purposely trying to create town apathy by spamming the thread and posting the same shit over and over. Every time I try to catch up on the game it's just ten more pages of Math arguing with someone about how he's right even though he was dead wrong on HEM. Like I think he should've realized he needs to take a step back and let the game breathe, and that because he was so wrong Day 1 maybe realize he's fallible and should be willing to listen to other perspectives.

Aristeia is so obviously town it hurts

Any "misplaced confidence" claims are also hilarious because Aristeia is one of the only people I see that is consistently right when she thinks she is right

I've been feeling this since the numbers thing at the beginning of the game. Idk why there's been so much backlash to practically everything she says, but it's really annoying. I'm not saying to just let her run the game and blindly follow her or anything like that, but man not everything needs to be a 20 page argument where the same three people repeat themselves over and over and the rest of the player list says "still catching up, I'll check in later". Yes I'm exaggerating a bit but that's what I've mainly been seeing this game. I don't get why this game's been so miserable to read either when town clearly has a massive advantage with PRs and a Day 1 scum elim.

[Bellaphant]

In Titus' block, I'd be really surprised if Roden was the scum.

[implosion]

oh yeah my agreement with the misplaced confidence thing from aristeia was mostly bc of her calling me scum >.>

[implosion]

I don't get why this game's been so miserable to read either when town clearly has a massive advantage with PRs and a Day 1 scum elim.

This bears worth repeating.

[Aristeia]

I think if Implo is town and HQ didn't pick venge then Enchant/Gamma contains the N3 Vig/Venge

Ausuka/HQ/Bella feel really town to me

if we flip enchant and he's scum BP or asc cop then gamma is last scum