Open 97 - Lovers Mafia (Over in 3 days!) before 703

[Guardian]

Scumlist, from most suspicious to least:

Adel
SF
Jdodge
LG
Batt

I'm pretty much right about this. Any questions?

PS lynch Adel she's scum. Adel would not call for a page two lynch, she is all about information and this generates none. Don't let her slime her way out of it.

[Guardian]

Unless SF can explain his hammer on me when he previously had no reason to hammer me, I permit you to lynch him instead of Adel.

Still, Adel is a much better choice.

[Guardian]

Ok, I'll lynch guardian on page 1 :)

You wanna know the reason for the double wagon vote? To see how people would react. I didn't think it was scummy, though so I wasn't trying to see who would jump on me for being scummy.

Also, I haven't played with guardian, but I would think that L-2 on page 1 where both votes were random = pressure. That's just me though.

Concerning the scum pairs: I think it is pretty early to be calling them now. From the people that are active, the person I think is most likely scum is Adel (info after random vote).

Adel: What's your position on guardian-

batt

scum pair, adel-batt scum pair, or the one where I'm not scum? Instead of sitting back and watch two people have a "scum fight."

this post is why batt is town fyi.

jdodge is playing normal for jdodge, even though his reasons are really dumb. lg has nothing one way or the other.

adel does not call for quick days as town, SF had no reason to hammer me.

that is the game as I see it.

[Lord Gurgi]

7. When you die, you may make a "bah!" post, but nothing game-related.

I expected better, Guardian.

[JDodge]

JDodge

is

may be (~65%) town. This is based on meta. It will additionally be based upon his response to this statement. Let's see where it goes.

I am almost completely apathetic about this statement. A little curious as to why you think I'm town, yet apathetic.

Revised.

Batt, that was a very good post to say absolutely nothing.

In other news, why is Guardian still breathing?

What I meant was that you basically said, "I think Jdodge is town because of his meta, unless he reacts scummy when I post this." I guess for my post to actually say something like your meaningful "why is Guardian still breathing? post," I should add in: I think you posted the meta/plus disclaimer post so as to appear to side with JDodge, but if he does something scummy you can fall back on and still say you had doubts because of his ambigous response to that post.

No. I have a reliable meta on him. He didn't quite obey it, hence the drop to may be.

Also, weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee hammer on page two.

# of times you've played forum mafia with me: 0
# of times you've played IRC mafia with me: countless

IRC mafia =/= Forum mafia

Hence your meta is invalid.

Yawn.

[Guardian]

6. If any player gains the majority of votes, that person will be lynched, and the game will go into twilight until I post the lynch scene (

you may still post during this time

).

I checked the rules LG..............

[JDodge]

7. When you die, you may make a "bah!" post, but nothing game-related.

I expected better, Guardian.

Is he dead yet? No. Why do you want someone who will apparently come up town to shut up?

[Lord Gurgi]

7. When you die, you may make a "bah!" post, but nothing game-related.

I expected better, Guardian.

Is he dead yet? No. Why do you want someone who will apparently come up town to shut up?

Sorry, I assumed that the rules prohibited that. I didn't want to violate the rules, if you feel like lynching me for that, there's no hope left for the game.

[JDodge]

7. When you die, you may make a "bah!" post, but nothing game-related.

I expected better, Guardian.

Is he dead yet? No. Why do you want someone who will apparently come up town to shut up?

Sorry, I assumed that the rules prohibited that. I didn't want to violate the rules, if you feel like lynching me for that, there's no hope left for the game.

Why so defensive, Flimsy?

[Lord Gurgi]

7. When you die, you may make a "bah!" post, but nothing game-related.

I expected better, Guardian.

Is he dead yet? No. Why do you want someone who will apparently come up town to shut up?

Sorry, I assumed that the rules prohibited that. I didn't want to violate the rules, if you feel like lynching me for that, there's no hope left for the game.

Why so defensive, Flimsy?

Because you lodged a serious accusation at me, why so flippant?

[Guardian]

if you have any questions for me or comments on my analysis of the game please present it now. I feel about 85% confident in it.

[SensFan]

Why do you think I'm Scum?

[Lord Gurgi]

if you have any questions for me or comments on my analysis of the game please present it now. I feel about 85% confident in it.

Why is JDodge above me?

[Guardian]

Why do you think I'm Scum?

wait -- also -- SF, what reason did you have to vote me, if any?

you didn't express any suspicion of me until hammering.

Why is JDodge above me?

He probably shouldn't be.

[JDodge]

7. When you die, you may make a "bah!" post, but nothing game-related.

I expected better, Guardian.

Is he dead yet? No. Why do you want someone who will apparently come up town to shut up?

Sorry, I assumed that the rules prohibited that. I didn't want to violate the rules, if you feel like lynching me for that, there's no hope left for the game.

Why so defensive, Flimsy?

Because you lodged a serious accusation at me, why so flippant?

When did I ever accuse you?

I asked you why you wanted someone who will come up town to shut up. I never said anything accusatory.

[Lord Gurgi]

Can you give us all some questions to answer, that should shed some light on alignment?

[SensFan]

wait -- also -- SF, what reason did you have to vote me, if any?

2 people were calling for a hammer so I went back and looked at your play thus far. I didn't like you trying to make someone unlynchable, but I thought maybe it was Adel/JDodge scumpair. When Gurgi also called for a hammer, I knew that at least one of them was Town, so I hammered.

[JDodge]

if you have any questions for me or comments on my analysis of the game please present it now. I feel about 85% confident in it.

I think lynching Sens is better than lynching Adel thanks to Adel's tendency towards gambitting, meaning that any tells on her are less solid.

[Lord Gurgi]

When did I ever accuse you?

I asked you why you wanted someone who will come up town to shut up. I never said anything accusatory.

Welcome to mafia, it is a serious accusation to say I wanted to cut off discussion. I wanted to follow the rules, because I thought he had to stop talking.

[Lord Gurgi]

if you have any questions for me or comments on my analysis of the game please present it now. I feel about 85% confident in it.

I think lynching Sens is better than lynching Adel thanks to Adel's tendency towards gambitting, meaning that any tells on her are less solid.

That sounds like a good excuse to waive off suspicion of Adel.

[Guardian]

wait -- also -- SF, what reason did you have to vote me, if any?

2 people were calling for a hammer so I went back and looked at your play thus far. I didn't like you trying to make someone unlynchable, but I thought maybe it was Adel/JDodge scumpair. When Gurgi also called for a hammer, I knew that at least one of them was Town, so I hammered

so one or two townies and one or two scum wanted me hammered... ergo you hammered?

you say you looked at my play -- what if anything was suspicious about it?



I believe LG about keeping the rules rather than trying to halt discussion.

[SensFan]

if you have any questions for me or comments on my analysis of the game please present it now. I feel about 85% confident in it.

I think lynching Sens is better than lynching Adel thanks to Adel's tendency towards gambitting, meaning that any tells on her are less solid.

I have a very large tendency to gambit.

[JDodge]

When did I ever accuse you?

I asked you why you wanted someone who will come up town to shut up. I never said anything accusatory.

Welcome to mafia, it is a serious accusation to say I wanted to cut off discussion. I wanted to follow the rules, because I thought he had to stop talking.

No. It is not. It is curiosity. You define it as an accusation because:

A. You were expecting something accusatory from me

B. It nicely takes all discussion involving you off of the "why is JD town to you" thing which you decided to waffle on.

[Lord Gurgi]

wait -- also -- SF, what reason did you have to vote me, if any?

2 people were calling for a hammer so I went back and looked at your play thus far. I didn't like you trying to make someone unlynchable, but I thought maybe it was Adel/JDodge scumpair. When Gurgi also called for a hammer, I knew that at least one of them was Town, so I hammered.

Huh?

[Lord Gurgi]

When did I ever accuse you?

I asked you why you wanted someone who will come up town to shut up. I never said anything accusatory.

Welcome to mafia, it is a serious accusation to say I wanted to cut off discussion. I wanted to follow the rules, because I thought he had to stop talking.

No. It is not. It is curiosity. You define it as an accusation because:

A. You were expecting something accusatory from me

B. It nicely takes all discussion involving you off of the "why is JD town to you" thing which you decided to waffle on.

I followed that through, I ignored your 'curiosity' because I think it's a load of garbage. Also, JDodge, you're an accusatory person, I read your posts with your aggressive personality in mind.