Open 855: Not Mafia's Republic | Game Over

[Arete Lastname]

I guess the obvious answer is 'his partner is also on that list of three and he doesn't want to out under those conditions'

which is unfortunate, 'two mafia 1 werewolf in that group of 3/1 wolf in my probably town club' is a worse position than '2 werewolves 1 mafia in that group of 3/1 mafia in my probably town club'

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

oh right my thoughts were that

maybe

ydrasse asking pooky about PP was a partner-tell

I think there's exactly one tryhardy wolf because I don't think spf and arete are aligned

rereading a&r and still don't think they are scum

if a/r and you are town then wolf team is just SabiHydra + SPF and Mafia team is 2 of STD/Peng/NM

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

also its p clear atp mafia are not interested in claiming and would rather get limmed and lose so it's w/e i'm fine with losing

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

also ydra being annoyed at NM felt kinda partnery

[Arete Lastname]

also its p clear atp mafia are not interested in claiming and would rather get limmed and lose so it's w/e i'm fine with losing

ok but what if instead of getting limmed and losing they instead did not do that

[catboi]

oh right my thoughts were that

maybe

ydrasse asking pooky about PP was a partner-tell

I think there's exactly one tryhardy wolf because I don't think spf and arete are aligned

rereading a&r and still don't think they are scum

if a/r and you are town then wolf team is just SabiHydra + SPF and Mafia team is 2 of STD/Peng/NM

a&r is the sabihydra

i need to reread spf/arete and decide which i think is scum

[catboi]

also ydra being annoyed at NM felt kinda partnery

i couldn't find this in her iso

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I don't think we can rely on the mafia playing optimally

maybe they just don't care

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

also ydra being annoyed at NM felt kinda partnery

i couldn't find this in her iso

when he hammered her she was like "oh lame"

[Arete Lastname]

@SaveTheDragons

if it will help you feel better about claiming you could say something like 'hypothetically speaking if I were mafia so-and-so isn't my partner and is probably a werewolf' and we'll pretend we don't think it's a mafiaclaim

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

oh right my thoughts were that

maybe

ydrasse asking pooky about PP was a partner-tell

I think there's exactly one tryhardy wolf because I don't think spf and arete are aligned

rereading a&r and still don't think they are scum

if a/r and you are town then wolf team is just SabiHydra + SPF and Mafia team is 2 of STD/Peng/NM

a&r is the sabihydra

i need to reread spf/arete and decide which i think is scum

in my mind a&r = arete lol

[Arete Lastname]

I don't think we can rely on the mafia playing optimally

maybe they just don't care

well instead of having those emotions, which I think are dumb, they should have different less-dumb emotions

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I mean they've already shown us that they would literally rather die than claim scum so I'm not sure how we can convince them otherwise that their fanatical devotion is wrong.

[Arete Lastname]

Mafia team is 2 of STD/Peng/NM

also fwiw you seem to be parsing this as 2 maf/1 town and I think it's more likely 2 maf/1 wolf

mostly because them having 1 town means one of them is town but also because I don't want to believe that I'm misreading two people in my townpool

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

like maybe they just think playing multiball without a nightkill is lame and stupid

which tbh if I had a mafia role pm I could see myself thinking this is total bullshit too

but it is what it is.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Mafia team is 2 of STD/Peng/NM

also fwiw you seem to be parsing this as 2 maf/1 town and I think it's more likely 2 maf/1 wolf

mostly because them having 1 town means one of them is town but also because I don't want to believe that I'm misreading two people in my townpool

I think wolves are very incentivized to hunt down mafia so it makes sense to me that both wolf votes were on ydrasse and wolves did not do some split up thing where one of them goes deep and the other one tries to blend in with the mafia

[Not_Mafia]

also ydra being annoyed at NM felt kinda partnery

Everyone is annoyed at me all the time

Vote the SabiHydra with me

Well that was an unfortunate night death. Why was there only one night kill if there's two groups?

Also why was night so long???

- sk

This is a wolf post

[Arete Lastname]

like maybe they just think playing multiball without a nightkill is lame and stupid

which tbh if I had a mafia role pm I could see myself thinking this is total bullshit too

but it is what it is.

idk why you would sign up for a game if you're not even going to try to win

like I am literally only playing this game because I lost a bet and it was running concurrently with my champs game [which is over, so I can say this, don't yell at me] and I am still trying to win

[Not_Mafia]

Mafia is the strongest faction in this set-up

[Arete Lastname]

oh right speaking of that Catboi had a post on like day 1 where he was obviously reading me based on the fact that that was happening that I thought was kinda townie but I couldn't say that at the time without talking about ongoing games

[Arete Lastname]

Mafia team is 2 of STD/Peng/NM

also fwiw you seem to be parsing this as 2 maf/1 town and I think it's more likely 2 maf/1 wolf

mostly because them having 1 town means one of them is town but also because I don't want to believe that I'm misreading two people in my townpool

I think wolves are very incentivized to hunt down mafia so it makes sense to me that both wolf votes were on ydrasse and wolves did not do some split up thing where one of them goes deep and the other one tries to blend in with the mafia

that requires them to have had good reads though and the two-thirds of them that I don't think are obviously-specifically-mafia are not really ..... doing very much ...... or paying attention

/if wolves disagreed with me about how obvious Ydrasse was/weren't sure of Ydrasse's alignment it makes sense that they'd split so that regardless of flip only one of them would "look bad" from it

(if Catbae's a wolf this is less likely to apply since they were the main cw)

[Arete Lastname]

uh I phrased that last sentence badly, it's more of an argument for Catbae being town than it is worldbuilding worlds where he's a wolf

[Not_Mafia]

uh I phrased that last sentence badly, it's more of an argument for Catbae being town than it is worldbuilding worlds where he's a wolf

Mr Turkey. Would you vote Buzzcap?

[Arete Lastname]

uh I phrased that last sentence badly, it's more of an argument for Catbae being town than it is worldbuilding worlds where he's a wolf

Mr Turkey. Would you vote Buzzcap?

who even is Buzzcap

also why is my nickname Mr. Turkey

[Not_Mafia]

Abby and Rani obviously