Mafia 86 - mafia.gif - Game Over!

[armlx]

hasdgfas, I hope you replaced for someone, because if yo did not notice Empking's lynch, there is something very wrong.

I am reading through the game and making observations without looking at the first post summary. I find it's a better way of replacing in than reading the first post and backwards reading the game.

I agree with hascows.

[curiouskarmadog]

going to be out of town until Monday...posting in all threads..

[hasdgfas]

Pages 21-now/u]
Post 514 - Seraphim: Really? That's the only reason you brought up Jester? We've seen the same thing from tajo and he wasn't a jester. Bringing up Jesters is completely anti-town
Post 528 - Empking: THE HAMMER IS NOT THE SCUMMIEST VOTE. I HATE THIS ARGUMENT.
Post 537 - Seraphim: Saying they could be a Jester is the silliest reason ever to not vote for a scummy player.
Post 552 - ShadowGirl: Again, saying it was a good night. Don't like this.
Post 554 - BA: Same thing. We know it was good. Don't post that it was to look like town.
Post 557 - Jebus: Don't pay attention to the bah post. It's possible he was just trying to screw with us.
Post 560 - skitzer: Yes, we know. Do you have any non-inane comments to add to the game?
Post 565 - ShadowGirl: You didn't have any strong suspicions, but did you have suspicions?
Post 568 - Seraphim: That's a terrible excuse for terrible play.
Post 573 - massive: Oh I forgot you were in this game. Any non-inane comments to add?
Post 575 - skitzer: That's a very weak case for this point in the game, skitzer. What a noncommital post.
Post 581 - massive: What a terrible post. You claim we're not scumhunting, but if you think so, why aren't you doing anything yourself?
Post 611 - massive: what?
Post 619 - BA: What sense does it make?
Post 650 - Jebus: Wait, how do you know that there are more japanese mafia? Why are you FoSing the people who wagoned you early? Why are you FoSing me and ckd?
I also want to point this wonder of a quote out:

Note: Curiouskarmadog makes the hammer against a claimed doc. Not worthy of an FoS, but still noteworthy.

You FoS people for random wagons, but don't FoS CKD for the hammer against a claimed doc and instead call it noteworthy? Could you elaborate please?

Post 665 - gorckat: Don't like this post for some reason. Doesn't seem like gorckat
Post 671 - skitzer: What another wonderful inane comment by skitzer.

Final Thoughts

ShadowGirl: Likes to stay out of the spotlight. I don't understand why she was so unwilling to believe tajo and emp were scum. Also, there were a few instances of defending other players that I didn't like.
skitzer: Hasn't posted very much at all. Most of what he's said has been inane comments. What hasn't been inane hasn't felt right to me.
BA: Don't like his play much. Most of it has been said already.
Seraphim/gorckat: Brought up Jester. That almost makes me want to vote him just for that. His other posts have also not been good, IMO.
massive: hasn't said anything.
Sierra has been quiet recently which I find very interesting.
Where's Ku_F and Rush?



Anyway, I am now caught up and will start off with a

Vote: ShadowGirl
HoS: skitzer, gorckat
FoS: BA, massive, Sierra, Ku_F

[farside22]

Curiousity makes me ask this hascow. Do you think BA is scum based on his interaction with the Jap mafia or do you think he is just scummy in general?

[hasdgfas]

Curiousity makes me ask this hascow. Do you think BA is scum based on his interaction with the Jap mafia or do you think he is just scummy in general?

his interactions were interesting, but I don't think that they make him jap mafia or townie. I'm thinking greek mafia is possible, because his actions are scummy without knowing others' alignments.

[Jebus]

I'm pretty sure there's one more Yakuza out there because of sekinj's "bah" post on page 22, just after the night scene. Remember, that was still day three.

Basically, it said "Go Yakuza, win win win!". This tells me

Oh, there's still a chance for Yakuza to win, so most likely there's still more of them

.
You're right though, it's possible he's trying to screw with us, but let's assume the worst. Pascal's Wager, sort of, if we assume (bet) that there's still one more out there, we can only gain, and not have anything to lose, except time, which we've got plenty to spare for finding this info. Besides, we can always just find out after the next night scene :/

And I didn't FoS curiouskarmadog for his hammer because I found populartajo to be superscummy, so aka, it didn't put much of a blip on my scum-o-meter.

[Jebus]

As for FoS's for the early wagons, well, that just falls to coincidence that there was so much scum on them, so it's possible that there's still more. A weak FoS, but an FoS all the same.

[armlx]

Jebus makes a good point that validates BA as scum.

[ShadowGirl]

Post 552 - ShadowGirl: Again, saying it was a good night. Don't like this.

I would agree with this if I hadn't said it the day before as well.

Post 565 - ShadowGirl: You didn't have any strong suspicions, but did you have suspicions?

BlakAdder, as per me voting him early in the day.

ShadowGirl: Likes to stay out of the spotlight. I don't understand why she was so unwilling to believe tajo and emp were scum. Also, there were a few instances of defending other players that I didn't like.

Both were playing so erraticly and in such a way that would naturally gain them attention that I think it would have been odd for them to be scum. I voted Emp in the end because he was being very, very anti-town. And I don't see how I was defending anyone. :/

[Jebus]

Jebus makes a good point that validates BA as scum.

?

Explain please?

[armlx]

As you said, its likely there's another Japanese mafia, which is what the case on BA was built on.

[Erratus Apathos]

Where's Ku_F and Rush?

[Sierra]

Sierra has been quiet recently which I find very interesting.

I'm kinda waiting for the mod to respond to CKD's question.

MOD NOTE:

The flavor in this post is just a humorous summary of the conversations during the game. No alignement and no portion of the setup is revealed there.

MOD, I know that every game I have ever been in that you modded (this would be the third) you have put this disclaimer (or something like it) on your every scene that you post...however, on yesterday's scene you did not.

can you please verify that this is indeed true for this scene? Because I am going on the basis of other games you have modded, but if you cant verify this, it changes things for this game

[Jebus]

Hai Sierra.

Sierra has been quiet recently which I find very interesting.

Anything to say about this (and everything else me and has are poking at you?

[hasdgfas]

Sierra, is there seriously nothing else you think is worth talking about right now?

[curiouskarmadog]

back, not too much has happened while I was gone...will try to update tomorrow

[massive]

If we believe that there is the possibility of a fourth Japanese Mafia member, we should clearly go back to BA, since he was easily the scummiest person over the first three days (that's still alive).

[hasdgfas]

If we believe that there is the possibility of a fourth Japanese Mafia member, we should clearly go back to BA, since he was easily the scummiest person over the first three days (that's still alive).

I disagree with this statement. There are plenty of other people alive that I find scummy. At least as scummy as BA, anyway.

[farside22]

As you said, its likely there's another Japanese mafia, which is what the case on BA was built on.

I stated the same thing but it got ignored.
@hascow: Do you think if there is another Japanese mafia member that BA is more likely a memember or do you believe SG is more likely scum to either group?

[armlx]

I stated the same thing but it got ignored.

If it was the same argument re: Sekinj's bah post, link plz.

[hasdgfas]

I think SG is likely scum somewhere, I just don't know what kind. Could be greek, could be japanese, could be SK.
BA, I'm not really sure. I don't think he's as likely scum as SG though. Japanese or otherwise.

[armlx]

I can get behind a SG lynch.

[ShadowGirl]

What exactly are the points against me that I haven't already talked about?

[hasdgfas]

What exactly are the points against me that I haven't already talked about?

I didn't like your "defenses". If you'd prefer, I could go through all my posts and find everything that I didn't like about you so far this game, but a bit of my suspicion of you is gut, along with the fact that you've been extremely noncommittal all game, decided to defend the two people who ended up getting lynched and flipping town. Have you voted for anyone this game? I can't remember any votes.

[ShadowGirl]

That would be nice - since I can't really defend against gut, can I?

I voted for Emp, who was playing terribly anti-town.

Short post - off for now.