can I have more input on this? Scoliosis, you still around?In post 404, Gimli wrote: are we sure that performing NAs the way we're suggesting now (focusing on 2 players) is better than going no NAs? are we sure the nurse is more useful for us hidden than outed on d1?
for instance: we might end up playing a 6er tomorrow with two living mafia and concurring nurse claims, right? isn't it better if we avoid the possibility?
Real chance I'm 0 for 2 on them atm but I'm not sure how you could think a freedom vote is "really bad"
With the grandpa vote, I made sure I wasn't putting him in a position to be hammered and waited until someone unvoted to put the third vote on him.In post 423, Gimli wrote:I agree with the timing of vander's votes being scummy, especially the last one.
Fwiw I'm happy enough taking my chances with a conflicting nurse claim, that seems more pro-town than no CC including the chance of nurse being killed N1.In post 425, Gimli wrote:can I have more input on this? Scoliosis, you still around?In post 404, Gimli wrote: are we sure that performing NAs the way we're suggesting now (focusing on 2 players) is better than going no NAs? are we sure the nurse is more useful for us hidden than outed on d1?
for instance: we might end up playing a 6er tomorrow with two living mafia and concurring nurse claims, right? isn't it better if we avoid the possibility?
no early birds in this game. too bad.
hm interesting i was reading enchant off town after that interaction. why do u think their scum? i geininuly got a wholesome feeling from enchant -- am i biased for that read?In post 418, Scoliosis wrote:I think at least one of Enchant or Grandpa are town (I ruled out their fight as being scum theater) and here's why:
231 is really similar to how Grandpa talked to me when he tried to get me to change my mind out of my FoS in 159. Unless Grandpa somehow predicted I would read back and look for this, I don't think Grandpa as scum would replicate the same approach he took with me that he would take with a scum buddy because the intent is very different. Then, in 259 I think if Grandpa and Enchant were doing scum theater Grandpa would have lashed back harder, because players take things less personally when they can laugh it out in a PT after, and I think that in a theater sense it would be natural to escalate the emotion there because they had started talking about religion.
the only reason i am townreading vander is because of something they said earlier -- they were the one to bring up the sitatuion bout cpr resolving last and that would change things and was the one that opened up a discussion on that resulting in a mod question etc
i still yet to have aether/lumine as in a high townread -- they are still ok but the problem is they keep dodging context talks and keep delaying their rsesponses. i am just giving them the benefit of the doubtIn post 416, Scoliosis wrote:This is the first time I felt a scum ping reading Aether/Lumine postsIn post 371, Tabibitos wrote:Sorry not enough time or energy for this yet (about the mech stuff), I am fine doing what you guys agree on if it comes to that
As for reads, I thought about it and maybe Enchant is town for wanting to try targetting someone on their own early, it can e a prerogative to dismiss mech but it's probably town excited for potentially being a vig? Vigging is exciting after all.
Grandpa feels more likely town than not by saying stuff like "I already know the Nurse" on a setup where the Nurse may end up claiming anyway (otherwise it could be rolefishing). Not too sure about grandpa but I don't feel very good about anyone else so I'm gonna like his slot for now.
Elements mech solving is interesting, don't know what to think of that, did you ever do it before Elements? On what game?
- Aether
the 'if I like this plan I'll bet the game on the hydra being town' line, yeah. IDK. maybe flipping freedom is as good as it's gonna get as far as D1 goes.In post 427, Vanderscamp wrote:it was actually your post about Freedom ('s slot's) post 92(?) that made me think "yeah this post makes no sense and I actively dislike it" and I don't have any other stronger scum reads.
how does everyone think of this? IF we do choose to elim freeedom during the day.In post 434, GrandpaMo wrote:vander looks way better than freedom nd enchat fwiw
i think we should investigate it like this since enchant is also someone in interest.
im gonna group a town core with one common suspect in each group so i will group my bottom scumreads .
group a - scoloisis, elements, grandpa, galron
group b - gimli, vander, tabibitos, enchant
group a target enchant
group b target galron
Why are the groups targeting scum reads when we're more likely to protect than kill?In post 435, GrandpaMo wrote:how does everyone think of this? IF we do choose to elim freeedom during the day.In post 434, GrandpaMo wrote:vander looks way better than freedom nd enchat fwiw
i think we should investigate it like this since enchant is also someone in interest.
im gonna group a town core with one common suspect in each group so i will group my bottom scumreads .
group a - scoloisis, elements, grandpa, galron
group b - gimli, vander, tabibitos, enchant
group a target enchant
group b target galron
I am in group c which targets GrandpaMo.In post 434, GrandpaMo wrote:vander looks way better than freedom nd enchat fwiw
i think we should investigate it like this since enchant is also someone in interest.
im gonna group a town core with one common suspect in each group so i will group my bottom scumreads .
group a - scoloisis, elements, grandpa, galron
group b - gimli, vander, tabibitos, enchant
group a target enchant
group b target galron
how will that work then? groups need to choose their town core? that wouldn't make senseIn post 439, Elements wrote:Why are the groups targeting scum reads when we're more likely to protect than kill?In post 435, GrandpaMo wrote:how does everyone think of this? IF we do choose to elim freeedom during the day.In post 434, GrandpaMo wrote:vander looks way better than freedom nd enchat fwiw
i think we should investigate it like this since enchant is also someone in interest.
im gonna group a town core with one common suspect in each group so i will group my bottom scumreads .
group a - scoloisis, elements, grandpa, galron
group b - gimli, vander, tabibitos, enchant
group a target enchant
group b target galron
I have a small recall of his meta . im on my phone rn ill touch back on this question more once I can get backIn post 437, Gimli wrote:grandpa, have you played with vander before? is this confidence based off meta?
we can do me vs u but I think for the sake of everyone else that would wasting a nightIn post 440, Enchant wrote:I am in group c which targets GrandpaMo.In post 434, GrandpaMo wrote:vander looks way better than freedom nd enchat fwiw
i think we should investigate it like this since enchant is also someone in interest.
im gonna group a town core with one common suspect in each group so i will group my bottom scumreads .
group a - scoloisis, elements, grandpa, galron
group b - gimli, vander, tabibitos, enchant
group a target enchant
group b target galron
group a - scoloisis, elements, enchant, galronIn post 442, GrandpaMo wrote:how will that work then? groups need to choose their town core? that wouldn't make sense
In post 445, Enchant wrote:i declare myself serial killer alignment
I understand why group b targets you but why would group a target me? and not Gimli?In post 446, Elements wrote:group a - scoloisis, elements, enchant, galronIn post 442, GrandpaMo wrote:how will that work then? groups need to choose their town core? that wouldn't make sense
group b - gimli, vander, tabibitos, gandpa
group a targets grandpa
group b targets elements
mhm nvm. do not answer thisIn post 448, GrandpaMo wrote:I understand why group b targets you but why would group a target me? and not Gimli?In post 446, Elements wrote:group a - scoloisis, elements, enchant, galronIn post 442, GrandpaMo wrote:how will that work then? groups need to choose their town core? that wouldn't make sense
group b - gimli, vander, tabibitos, gandpa
group a targets grandpa
group b targets elements