HMS Mutiny [Game Over]

[furtiveglance]

3.06

Votecount 3.06

Gamma Emerald (3):

Killing Joke, Radical Rat, Gamma Emerald.

Elements (2):

Eiralox, BlueBloodedToffee.

Enchant (2):

Gimli, ActionDan.

Eiralox (1):

Elements.

Not Voting (4):

Enchant, Malakittens, Flea The Magician, Bellaphant.

With 12 players alive, it takes 7 to eliminate someone.

Day 3 ends in (expired on 2023-02-06 22:00:00).

Co-Mod Notes

• Combined Mod ISO
  
• Squawk

Flavour

[Gimli]

Gimli very likely fourth scum.

Killing Joke, Elements is lying about role. So. Please just stop with this and focus on what is at hand.

I can see you as crew.But you might be fifth scum, traitor. Either way.

If you're town you're needed here.

full bananas

[Killing Joke]

Yeah, I get that to an extent if you've been active all game. Action Dan hasn't exactly been active all game so him getting active as scum now doesn't really make sense

That’s a very good point. I think it’s the posters being active here are far more likely to be town than the ones not doing much. Scum are probably mostly chilling and not doing anything to try to solve this game.

[Gimli]

elements isn't lying about the cop checks, she'd never misplay scum this badly. how can eiralox still think that? it's funny.

it's like elements can be scum and there's nothing in her claim that makes her not scum and her role is a scummy role BUT, the cop checks are valid as far as some basic mafia playing goes.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Nancy, would you replicate your town meta of lambasting players for scum reading you if you were scum?

[Gimli]

that's also why elly and KJ are never scum together and one flipping scum clears the other

[Gimli]

they can both be town

TRIPLE SOFT INNO

jk don't use that

[Killing Joke]

@Harley

I think it might be better to approach it from another angle. Why WOULDN'T Titus have been targeted? She's a well-known player with a reputation for being strong Town.

Probably most people here would put her on a priority D1 kill list, I know I would. But who wouldn't have killed her? And is that strong enough to remove them from a PoE?


These aren't leading questions, I have no idea about any of the interpersonal dynamics of other people on this site, but for someone who does have an idea on those things, pursuing that angle may prove more fruitful

But I ISO’d her to try to hopefully figure out why but I couldn’t find any evidence that she pr softed, so if anyone did, tell me. Gimli and Eira can sr me for this all they like but I’m never going to stop saying that we we’re double soft inno’d and therefore couldn’t have killed Titus and I don’t see how anyone who thinks logically wouldn’t think that if we were a goon, we wouldn’t have been the one to do it, so fucking yes. the fact that we are confirmed vanilla who didn’t visit Titus very strongly points to us being vt, which is what I truthfully claimed. We had an immediate wagon on us d2 after STD flip and I told Joker I was expecting that to happen. And if it weren’t probably literally for Titus checking us, I have no doubt we would have been the d2 miselim, guaranteed.

SvS filler.

Are you maybe scum here because that take seemed extremely disingenuous?

[Bellaphant]

I do think kj is town.

Also, bbt, sussed it.

[Enchant]

VOTE: Elements

[Bellaphant]

Gimlis latest reads gave me the ick

[Eiralox]

Eiralox, do you have any actual reason to suspect Elements is lying instead of just that it theoretically could have been faked?

Im so tired rat.

I promised answers, I promised to case.

I'm gonna. I've been saying it from start but once Not_Eira sorts some shit ill logic this. Show the patterns.

I mean.


Gimlinstart D3 sorta points to AD scum to me rn at least.

I believe my path is just.

[Gimli]

that's also why elly and KJ are never scum together and one flipping scum clears the other

to be clear, elements is either a town parity cop or a scum parity cop. she did visit KJ to know their role and paired KJ with AD. she got a 'same'. KJ claimed VT very early. elements said 'yeah i think they goon mebbe but the other is vt'. the other is AD, who we now know is in fact a vt.

so since she is a parity cop, she wouldn't parity her scumbuddy with someone else, but two townies. that means her action spews KJ town if she is scum. and the other way around.

[Bellaphant]

...but that is true I believe. God gimli confuses me

[Radical Rat]

Okay, but a real quick thing to consider while you analyze these patterns...

If Elements/KJ are aligned, and Elements claim is completely made up, why did Elements visit them?

[Gimli]

...but that is true I believe. God gimli confuses me

it's only fun that way

[Killing Joke]

elements isn't lying about the cop checks, she'd never misplay scum this badly. how can eiralox still think that? it's funny.

it's like elements can be scum and there's nothing in her claim that makes her not scum and her role is a scummy role BUT, the cop checks are valid as far as some basic mafia playing goes.

Yes and once again - because I almost want to put this in all caps because you continue to ignore it - if you believe we’re vanilla, why would you not think we’d be the most logical choice if goon to kill Titus? I just can’t shake the feeling that you maybe really want us to be scum and don’t care about all of the reasons pointing against it.

[Radical Rat]

that's also why elly and KJ are never scum together and one flipping scum clears the other

to be clear, elements is either a town parity cop or a scum parity cop. she did visit KJ to know their role and paired KJ with AD. she got a 'same'. KJ claimed VT very early. elements said 'yeah i think they goon mebbe but the other is vt'. the other is AD, who we now know is in fact a vt.

so since she is a parity cop, she wouldn't parity her scumbuddy with someone else, but two townies. that means her action spews KJ town if she is scum. and the other way around.

I actually disagree here. At least for a first check, if I'm scum parity cop and not just a normal rolecop, I'm checking one partner and one Town N1, so that I have a known reference point to work from.

[Gimli]

Okay, but a real quick thing to consider while you analyze these patterns...

If Elements/KJ are aligned, and Elements claim is completely made up, why did Elements visit them?

see I just said the opposite. they are never SvS. and this is your response cause I guess you don't read with any attention.

I'll repeat my question that I made about elements: who are the demons townreading RR? there's scum in them.

[Eiralox]

Okay, but a real quick thing to consider while you analyze these patterns...

If Elements/KJ are aligned, and Elements claim is completely made up, why did Elements visit them?

Kj not in my solve rn. But u called for them be vigged.

So if traitor/scum kj might be protective elements. R rolecop elements seeing if kj traitor or whatever. I think I told u this earlier but not my main concent atm.

[Gimli]

elements isn't lying about the cop checks, she'd never misplay scum this badly. how can eiralox still think that? it's funny.

it's like elements can be scum and there's nothing in her claim that makes her not scum and her role is a scummy role BUT, the cop checks are valid as far as some basic mafia playing goes.

Yes and once again - because I almost want to put this in all caps because you continue to ignore it - if you believe we’re vanilla, why would you not think we’d be the most logical choice if goon to kill Titus? I just can’t shake the feeling that you maybe really want us to be scum and don’t care about all of the reasons pointing against it.

the only problem is I don't care about this at all, you know? I don't want to clear you. but there's 4 mafia and we're finding them finally, I think. and instead of scumhunting you're like 'blablabla im town' and like okay, work the game then?

[Gimli]

Okay, but a real quick thing to consider while you analyze these patterns...

If Elements/KJ are aligned, and Elements claim is completely made up, why did Elements visit them?

see I just said the opposite. they are never SvS. and this is your response cause I guess you don't read with any attention.

I'll repeat my question that I made about elements: who are the demons townreading RR? there's scum in them.

*about enchant, sorry.

[Eiralox]

that's also why elly and KJ are never scum together and one flipping scum clears the other

to be clear, elements is either a town parity cop or a scum parity cop. she did visit KJ to know their role and paired KJ with AD. she got a 'same'. KJ claimed VT very early. elements said 'yeah i think they goon mebbe but the other is vt'. the other is AD, who we now know is in fact a vt.

so since she is a parity cop, she wouldn't parity her scumbuddy with someone else, but two townies. that means her action spews KJ town if she is scum. and the other way around.

No. Everything is fake, and you are scum.

Enchant is crew.

Such a horrible wagon yall chose instead of the eira elim

[Bellaphant]

Enchant hasn't towned it up. Enchant normally towns it up

[Bellaphant]

VOTE: gamna