Mini Normal 2289 - Postgame

[Eiralox]

Don't turn off the muzak

[Alchemist21]

Like I get having personal beef with someone but basing half your posts around it isn’t something I expect from Town.

[Alchemist21]

Don't turn off the muzak

I can get you more muzak. Lol

[PenguinPower]

i'm the snarky spam poster. get your own gimmick

[Eiralox]

Don't turn off the muzak

I can get you more muzak. Lol

sorta already have established supply lines so not sure I wanna rock the boat?

[Alchemist21]

Suit yourself.

[Cephrir]

VOTE: Cephrir

I’m not really thrilled with Cephrir’s entrance either.

Cephrir’s first post implies they read the thread before deciding to replace in (which is probably true) but there’s less early takes than I would expect and more shooting down frogster’s push on the slot. What’s pinging me is that Cephrir seems to be assuming frogster is just wrong Town but I don’t know what reason he has to be Townreading him at this point. Maybe it’s based on their meta but at the same time Cephrir openly encouraging other players to just ignore frogster is also scummy. I think maybe Cephrir thought he was replacing into a Town slot and had to readjust on the fly when he got in and realized it was a scum slot.

I skimmed the most recent couple pages before entry. If I were scum who had read the game and had a lot of takes I would just post them anyway.

Go look at the completed large theme KTaNE. If anything my response to frog has been remarkably tame by comparison. How would you expect a town player to respond to some of the silly attacks against me here?

[Cephrir]

As to my assuming he's town. Not 100 percent sure but unfortunately this lines up with his town meta

[Eiralox]

Suit yourself.

Spoiler:

[Cephrir]

2 town games KTaNE and lost - tons of ridiculously dumb posts with outlandish theories
Mini normal where I played as tenebrousluminary - he was a lot more muted posted less and was scum

STD I'll respond to you when I have more time but I still want to know where your Dionysus vote came from

[Cephrir]

Frogs in KTaNE is literally the worst performance I have ever seen from town in 17 years on this website. Seriously, go look

[Cephrir]

I'm not just posting this to be mean it's necessary context for how I'm going about this

Maybe I shouldn't have taken this slot I just read those 2 pages and got annoyed by the bad logic so I decided to do something about it

[Alchemist21]

VOTE: Cephrir

I’m not really thrilled with Cephrir’s entrance either.

Cephrir’s first post implies they read the thread before deciding to replace in (which is probably true) but there’s less early takes than I would expect and more shooting down frogster’s push on the slot. What’s pinging me is that Cephrir seems to be assuming frogster is just wrong Town but I don’t know what reason he has to be Townreading him at this point. Maybe it’s based on their meta but at the same time Cephrir openly encouraging other players to just ignore frogster is also scummy. I think maybe Cephrir thought he was replacing into a Town slot and had to readjust on the fly when he got in and realized it was a scum slot.

I skimmed the most recent couple pages before entry. If I were scum who had read the game and had a lot of takes I would just post them anyway.

Go look at the completed large theme KTaNE. If anything my response to frog has been remarkably tame by comparison. How would you expect a town player to respond to some of the silly attacks against me here?

I don’t have the time or energy to read a large theme for 2nd hand meta so I’ll just take your word for it.

As Town I don’t expect you to make as many posts about it as you did if you thought they were silly, and again if you wanted to ignore them based on personal beef that would be fine but telling others to ignore them is not Town.

[Cephrir]

i understand your position but disagree, it's the most protown thing i've done

[Save The Dragons]

Maybe cephrir is town lol

I voted dionysus for funzies I dunno who the scum are yet at all I'm like the anti-frogster

[Alchemist21]

I'm not just posting this to be mean it's necessary context for how I'm going about this

Maybe I shouldn't have taken this slot I just read those 2 pages and got annoyed by the bad logic so I decided to do something about it

Honestly your personal choices do confuse me, I would just not join a game if someone I didn’t like was in it. And your decision to replace in is inherently NAI and I KNOW that, but I think my confusion on understanding you as a person is playing a part in my read on you.

[Alchemist21]

If you’re Town I really need you to step up and show it.

Anyway I have to go to work now.

[Cephrir]

many people find me confusing, you're far from the first. that said i don't disagree that maybe replacing in here was a poor decision, but i made my bed and now i have to lie in it

i am feeling more centered now and perhaps i can find a more relaxed approach later.

[Frogsterking]

Let me quote another scum player making this exact same argument using the exact same game to discredit me while I run them (and their team) up on D1:

Subject: hi, i'm large normal 242. and i'm over with.

because as far as I can see, the only reason you call me a troll is because I am pushing your slot and that feels like a way to discredit my push on you by trying to attribute my play to something its clearly not.

its also intensely ironic considering your play in games such as KTANE where you blew up the IC, you should be the last person to call others trolls.

For reference I'm reposting the quote of the other scum players using the exact same argument:


Subject: Open 860 | Elected Decisions | Postgame

My experience with reading Frogsterking is that he's very unpredictable and erratic (KTaNE). My impression is that he's surprisingly making some sense in this game and making an effort, which makes me paranoid and unwilling to trust him at all. Doesn't mean he's necessarily scum though. I wouldn't mind getting him Divulged though.

To me he's absolutely Not making sense, so I have no idea what you're seeing here. Though you aren't the first to say he's normally erratic/unpredictable, I still can't imagine this as Town right now. It seems like he does have clear goals, and that those goals are Mafia-oriented

Both Greeting and Radical Rat in the above example are scum, chainsawing me as I had solved the game within the first few pages.

I'll quote the same scum above pissing themselves in their scumPT after getting caught D1:

Subject: Open 860 | Elected Decisions | Mafia Hideout

Frog is annoying, he's legit just lying

Gotta do my best not to give out "caught for the wrong reason" vibes

Subject: Open 860 | Elected Decisions | Mafia Hideout

I know this'll just pass because Frog literally makes no sense and no one's just gonna agree to quick hammering 24 hours into the game for no reason

But wow

Subject: Open 860 | Elected Decisions | Mafia Hideout

Don't worry about

Frogsterking

, no one takes him seriously.

Both of you are doing a good job so far, if I were town, I wouldn't be suspecting either of you.

Subject: Open 860 | Elected Decisions | Mafia Hideout

VOTE: Roden
VOTE: Divulgence (sigh)

HEAL: Fun Times
VOTE: Divulge
VOTE: Greeting

I want to see how many players support this wagon config for D1.

VOTE: radical rat

Uh...

Subject: i'm large normal 242 mafia thread (this is over)

gamma/frogster very obviously a mason pair and we need to get them to vote a townie together as we systematically kill them at night

No Masons, just good D1 reads

Subject: i'm large normal 242 mafia thread (this is over)

really think that stacking votes on a townie right now is way more of a good play than what is happening right now (:

Subject: i'm large normal 242 mafia thread (this is over)

who do u want to push again lol

Subject: i'm large normal 242 mafia thread (this is over)

btw theres almost certainly a rolecop or maybe 2 in this setup considering this is a schadd setup and the roles i see here.

make sure to look as investigatable as possible.

i mean we can force frog to claim to force the gambit and see if there really is a masonry and not just a hood where they townread eachother

No Masons, just scum getting caught D1

Subject: i'm large normal 242 mafia thread (this is over)

frogster is really polarized on meta tho rofl

Subject: i'm large normal 242 mafia thread (this is over)

the mason play in this game is so lol theyre just trying to hide their masonry while being upset and making it more obvious that it exists instead of dropping the act

also frogster basically hard OGIing himself town is w i l d

prob should bury that post, im gonna try to get him to post more to bury it in his ISO too.

No OGI, just butt hurt scum

Subject: i'm large normal 242 mafia thread (this is over)

kitty/frog/gamma is the masonry

No masons, just kicking scum ass D1 the old fashioned way etc.

In summary, there's a pattern of: Frog push real hard D1 > Frog hits correctly D1 (sometimes) > Scum aren't used to getting caught so early so they flail and reference KTANE

Real creative, much gameplay

[Frogsterking]

Maybe cephrir is town lol

I voted dionysus for funzies I dunno who the scum are yet at all I'm like the anti-frogster

Townlean revoked

[Save The Dragons]

Frogster I expect a readslist by page 4 if that's the case

[Frogsterking]

2 town games KTaNE and lost - tons of ridiculously dumb posts with outlandish theories
Mini normal where I played as tenebrousluminary - he was a lot more muted posted less and was scum

STD I'll respond to you when I have more time but I still want to know where your Dionysus vote came from

Cephrir I'm not sure whether you got caught with your pants down or this is the best you can muster, but from my point of view it's really disappointing to put all this work into solving games just to face opponents whose main defense is to wail
"ReMeMbEr KTANEEEEEE!! PlEaSe DoN't VoTe Me!!"

Like off the top of my head you are the fourth scum player to make this exact same argument after getting caught D1.

I guess for you I can only criticize your choice to attack my meta, because unlike the other scum, you had to replace into a slot I was already scum reading. So kudos to you I guess.

Frogster I expect a readslist by page 4 if that's the case

@all

Do you think there's a cost to posting even though there's no post limit? Should we be trying to keep our post counts low?

To clarify my first post, 8 I thought was AI for scum until I read 9, FWIW.

__

@Brickwall

I want to know if you can defend 10 and 11 as being NAI and I also want you to post a full reads list by page 4.

__

@furtiveglance

6 any reason you started so differently here than you did in Masque? This sort of low key start reminds me more of your traitor game in Community 2.

7 what are you talking about here?

__

@CSF

Anything you want to add to that?

Hello Frog

I started differently to previous games because it's not the same game and I don't repeat stuff

I'm sure you can work out what my score means

Full readslist by page 4 please.

Town

CSF
Eiralox

Town lean

Furtiveglance

Null

T3,
Dionysus
and 0 posters

Scum lean

Brickwalll,
Dragons

Scum

0

Wow if Dragons is the Anti-Frogster then I will sleep easy tonight!!

[Save The Dragons]

I need you to do another one

[Save The Dragons]

By page 4 please

[Cephrir]

hey eiralox why haven't you offered a single read or opinion since post 264