HMS Mutiny [Game Over]

[Eiralox]

Scum has a Cabin Servant (PR Cop) and a Role Blocker.

With me never saying this, I thank you for saying this.

[Flea The Magician]

Is anyone else seeing the big catch here?
PR Cop flipped, BBT claimed a role blocker gate and has said that from the start there's blockers...

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Umm, we limming Gimli yet?

[Bellaphant]

? His shog didn't go through, ofc he thinks there are blockers

[Flea The Magician]

? His shog didn't go through, ofc he thinks there are blockers

I managed to bait the kill, I have the black spot.

I was only a 1-shot vig, but it was a recharge shot so if I got blocked then my shot would be refunded.

This is mechanical knowledge. Not suspected knowledge.

[Aisa]

4.08

Votecount 4.08

Eiralox (4):

Flea The Magician, Elements, Gimli, Radical Rat.

Gimli (3):

BlueBloodedToffee, Malakittens, Eiralox.

Elements (1):

Killing Joke.

Not Voting (1):

Bellaphant.

With 9 players alive, it takes 5 to eliminate someone.

Day 4 ends in (expired on 2023-02-12 15:30:00).

Co-Mod Notes

• Combined Mod ISO
  
• Flea The Magician is V/LA.
  
• Gimli has reached his post limit for today and has 0/10 posts left in his reserve. He can only post naked votes every 12 hours.

[Aisa]

Prodding Killing Joke.

[Gimli]

VOTE: eiralox

[Aisa]

Sorry - the thread was locked for a few minutes accidentally. You can resume playing as normal

The source of the error was me

- the Ship's parrot

[Bellaphant]

VOTE: gimli

[Bellaphant]

E-1

[Killing Joke]

Bella I still hate, once again seeing nothing but flapping here, honestly. When all I can remember of a slot is behavioural comparisions, kinda gets my back up.

It's blatantly clear that you don't like me here, at all.

Still, in the interest of communication, would you be able to expand on this? On Bellaphant?

I've been heavily reading you as a mutineer for large portions of this voyage. There was a period where you did feel wholesome.

This sort of is me extending a final olive wreath.

If you reject it, whatever.

I'm sorta tired of trying at this point.

You've given me no reason to like you and given nothing but convoluted flow and narrative which had little to no substance as I read it. I am happy to try and talk.

Bella made some krakens damned awful posts and pushes. Opening on Passenger, then being weird around me in response, then being weird around the ActionDan/Deflection issue. There has been repeated and near constant deliberate misinterpretations of posts to the point I am facepalming. Going into mechanical speculation, A deflector/kill redirector/whatever with 2 gated vigs seems obnoxiously strong for a town setup. 3 gated vigs is also disgustingly strong given pretty much every kill is accounted for meaning there is no additional scum kill power.

Even if we entertain the thought that Mala is a traitor/vig - that still stacks even more against mafia in balance imo.

The power balance of this game, the awful cases, the misinterpretation.
I need to go back over the claim if I ever remember to, and re-read that whole sequence.

Talk to me about being weird on ad? Again, as I said to gimli, why does scum!Bella claim....anything yesterday and bring the limelight on them?

And 'deliberate' misinterpretation? Coz...this literally only seems to happen with Fae. Everyone else can talk to me normally: I only get into these weird back and forths with Fae.

Eira, bbt: I'd rather vote flea over gimli, but I'm worried it's because gimli occasionally looks 'reasonable'. Come talk to me?

(Also, kj, the quoted should give you very much flashbacks to 'come talk to me, not about ne')

I’m sorry Bella but don’t understand the reference?

KILLING JOKE

Harley, Joker, where ya'll at?

What ya'll thinking about what Radical Rat is doing, that is, engaging with Flea the Magician while talking past Bellaphant?

We have exactly 10 posts left for this game day. I disagree with their vote but it’s still better than the one on Mala.

Bellaphant, I don't know where Killing Joke is.

But.... I'm not seeing Flea as crew here, therefore feel my solve of Elements/Gimli/Flea and Rad Rat as traitor has just been validated.

I'll be honest I had some doubts on you and Killing Joke, even today, merely because things have been slow. But the mutineers are being so very, very obvious and unsubtle.

I'm leaving things in your hands then, and Killing Joke's, and hope to hear from Toffee and Mala about this latest development.

That is all.

I’m kind of very frustrated with this game because it’s extremely unusual for me as town to have to be spending pretty much the entire game fighting off bad srs. I also think that scum and scumsiding town is probably driving this game.

I think I'm coming back round to KJ being town again

No, I don't think I am

Wow, for absolutely no reason whatsoever you changed your opinion on us without any input from us, so why even bother to make this post?

Prodding Killing Joke.

Why are we getting a prod when we only have 10 posts left for this gameday?

I am more confident on Elements!scum than Gimli but I think Eira’s town so I’d prefer to vote Gimli > Eira.

Of course I think if Elements isn’t black spotted tomorrow something’s possibly up.

~Harley

[Killing Joke]

First of all we have like less than 10 posts, that's why we've been so quiet.

Second of all:

Town voting Eiralox right now is a really bad choice. I explained this game to my girlfriend who has never played mafia in her life and even she could understand why Elements and Gimli were scum and would vote correctly in this situation.

If it takes 5 players to hammer and Elements and Gimli wagons have been crossed all day at roughly ~2 votes (from the Town core) each, scum can fake a read progression on them whenever they wish to push that wagon through eventually.

If Elements and Gimli

AREN'T/b] scum together, then why did they go to all this trouble to wagon Eiralox rather than vote each other while they were competing wagons all day? It's called the

icono tell

, scum refuse to vote each other in a situation where they would do so if it were TvS.

So yes, a person who has never played mafia before can correctly deduce that, based on D4 alone, Elements and Gimli must be scum together. Flea is Town (IMO) with an objectively bad read on Eiralox. Whoever is in the Town core (Bella, BBT, KJ, Eiralox, Mala) stop voting the Town core. I don't care what rabbit hole you fell down, Elements and Gimli can be deduced as scum and you shouldn't be voting Town core out anyway.

[Eiralox]

I’m sorry Bella but don’t understand the reference?

I believe Bellaphant is talking specifically to Joker here.

I am more confident on Elements!scum than Gimli but I think Eira’s town so I’d prefer to vote Gimli > Eira.

Of course I think if Elements isn’t black spotted tomorrow something’s possibly up.

~Harley

I have agreed with you here, and am frankly relieved to read this. I'm very on edge here tbh. I have affirmed, agreed before that I'd also vastly prefer Elements, but Mala and Toffee have stated their intent not to vote there, and from what I see Bellaphant stated they prefer Flea, so also as I stated earlier, my hands are kind of tied at this point.

Gimli has burned out of posts though, and, repeating myself again, I'm not seeing the crew motivation in that with three days remaining so *shrug*

I believe I have 5 posts total left after this, including reserve posts. I've been sleeping spottily lately and am posting this after waking up like 3 am something. now I'm gonna try and go to sleep again. hope everyone has a good time.

[Killing Joke]

VOTE: gimli

[Aisa]

Prodding Killing Joke.

Why are we getting a prod when we only have 10 posts left for this gameday?

Spoiler:

The activity requirement is that you post something game-advancing every 36 hours. The number of posts you have left does not override this.

[Aisa]

4.09

Votecount 4.09 (Final)

Gimli (5):

BlueBloodedToffee, Malakittens, Eiralox, Bellaphant, Killing Joke.

Eiralox (4):

Flea The Magician, Elements, Radical Rat, Gimli.

Not Voting (0):

-

With 9 players alive, it took 5 to eliminate someone.

Day 4 ends in (expired on 2023-02-12 15:30:00).

Co-Mod Notes

• Combined Mod ISO
  
• Flea The Magician is V/LA.
  
• Gimli has reached his post limit for today and has 0/10 posts left in his reserve. He can only post naked votes every 12 hours.

[Aisa]

Flavour

The pirates were more argumentative than ever, on the fourth day since downsizing had been announced. Everyone was talking about how many Mutineers there could be, after one had died the previous day, and what the best course of action was to preserve what semblance of order remained. Eventually, it was agreed that Gimli had fallen out of favour with the group, and he was forcefully grappled onto the ship's plank.

Flips and Nightstart

Gimli has been eliminated! He was

Spoiler:

a

Loyal Sailor

, aligned with the

Crew

.

Spoiler: Role PM

Welcome to HMS Mutiny,

Andresvmb

Gimli! You are a

Loyal Sailor

and are aligned with the

Crew

.

Abilities:

You have no special abilities.

Win condition:

You win if all threats to the Crew are eliminated and at least one member of the Crew is alive.

Confirm by replying with your role and alignment in a PM to me.

BlueBloodedToffee has died! He was

Spoiler:

the

Captain

, aligned with the

Crew

.

Spoiler: Role PM

You could sense it. There was a dangerous tension among the Crew, usually so jovial and unified. Ever since the First Mate died of scurvy. They'd had such a way with the sailors. You could tell that some were planning mutiny. The time for talking was over. You studied your old pistol. You'd known it would come it in handy, and not just for naval battles. Someone was going to get smoked.

Welcome to HMS Mutiny, BlueBloodedToffee! You are the

Captain

and are aligned with the

Crew

.

Abilities:

• Informed [passive]: You are aware that there is at least one roleblocking role in the game.
  
• Recharged 1-Shot Vig: Once per game, at Night, target a player. Assuming no interference with your action, that player will die that Night. If you are roleblocked on the Night you try to use your action, your shot will be refunded (and you will be informed of this).

Win condition:

You win if all threats to the Crew are eliminated and at least one member of the Crew is alive.

Confirm by replying with your role and alignment in a PM to me.

Night 4 begins now and ends in (expired on 2023-02-11 09:45:00). Submit any Night Actions to me (Aisa) or in a PT where this is allowed. You get a few extra hours as I may not be awake at this time again in 48 hours.

[Aisa]

Day 5

No-one died last Night. Day 5 starts now and ends in (expired on 2023-02-18 10:00:00).

[Aisa]

5.00

Votecount 5.00

Not Voting (7):

Killing Joke, Elements, Bellaphant, Radical Rat, Eiralox, Flea The Magician, Malakittens.

With 7 players alive, it takes 4 to eliminate someone.

Day 5 ends in (expired on 2023-02-18 10:00:00).

Mod Notes

• Combined Mod ISO

[Radical Rat]

Elements, results please

[Elements]

I was roleblocked

[Radical Rat]

Not surprising, but worth asking anyway.

[Elements]

I still very much think Eira is scum

[Radical Rat]

So here's the problem. We apparently weren't in ELo yesterday, so we DEFINITELY are now.

There is no more room for error.

No one throws votes around until we have everything on the table.