Can any of you voting me explain to me why you're scumreading me? The only one who looks to have provided any actual reason was Abnegation.
This is what I see from the first vote:
In post 83, KittyTacky wrote:
My top TR is Erinys. Seems solvy and wanting to defibrillate this game.
My top SR is Kowah. Even ignoring the RVS vote, I don't like their recent comment. Seems overly nitpicky. It's a tenuous SR but it's because this game is very lackluster. Which we should try and change-- active towns win games.
In post 149, KittyTacky wrote:
I'd normally protest putting someone in hammer range on page 6 but this game is anemic and I don't think we will get much more useful this day. Maybe a claim will generate discussion.
Kowah, claim.
I just find it odd that for a tenuous scum read 40 posts earlier, they're cool with a naked vote, and their very next post is simply requesting me to claim my role.
Ab's vote at least provides something like a reason:
In post 134, Abnegation wrote:
it almost seems like kowah is looking for things to frame as scummy. i'd normally be suspicious of that, but part of me wonders if it's our dead gamestate rather than their alignment that's causing them to do that.
Spoiler: quotes
nothing in their iso gives me town vibes though so i'll vote them. they're not a bad wagon for now.
VOTE: kowahbunga
But then we're right back to why am I being voted by this person?
In post 141, HighPrincessErinys wrote:
Would vote Kowah now but this one is a bit sketched out by the possibility of a quickwagon since it'll be E-2 when right now it moreso wants info rather than an elimination.
In post 145, HighPrincessErinys wrote:
In post 144, Abnegation wrote:
In post 141, HighPrincessErinys wrote:
Would vote Kowah now but this one is a bit sketched out by the possibility of a quickwagon since it'll be E-2 when right now it moreso wants info rather than an elimination.
e-2 doesn't really risk a quickhammer imo.
You're probably right. This one will think on a vote or not while it does some other stuff.
This looks scummy to me because they wanted to act like they wanted to get on my wagon, but gave a reason why they weren't, then someone convinces them to put that vote down. So are they scumreading me or not? If they were, would they need to be convinced to vote me? Like I would probably understand a well thought out and good argument being presented to them and they have a moment of clarity and vote. But the literal reason provided is "don't worry about a quickhammer" "oh okay, vote" wtf?
And finally...:
In post 123, Not Known 15 wrote:
In post 31, Kowahbunga wrote:
Well lets talk about it then. Who is scummier? Me for casting a 2nd vote during RVS or Kitty for thinking it is scummy? Lets get some opinions and conversation going.
This is a bit weird...
In post 126, Not Known 15 wrote:
In post 100, Kowahbunga wrote:
In post 96, KawaiiKame wrote:
In post 81, HighPrincessErinys wrote:
In post 80, KittyTacky wrote:
Leaving aside the fact that it's a random number generator and I did it as a joke, I think checking a moderate townread is good.
On that note, this one would like to ask everyone who their current top town and scum reads are.
Town exists among:
HPE
NK15/Skitter
Kitty
Here are three examples of casting a wide net. You seem more like you're wanting to please the playerbase rather than ruffle any feathers.
Even your most recent post literally means nothing because as long as you listed 3 or more people, your statement was always going to be true.
VOTE: kawaii
Doesn't look like real scumhunting here, more like attempts to make scumminess out of air.
Now Not Known at least has a progression here to get to his vote on me. However, one thing that stands out to me is how easily he voted considering that in post
122 he listed Abnegation along with me as a top scum read. I know I'm listed as a scum read in this post, but so is Abnegation who is already on my wagon.
I will claim if more people demand it of me, but in all honesty this wagon looks shady af to me. I think my biggest issue with this wagon is HighPrincessErinys and the way they joined it. I also think Kitty's vote is sus.