In post 3833, Klick wrote:
I think your takeaway from this should be that I'm town and have a number of accurate townreads btw
You only know if your townreads are accurate if you're scum
???
Where do I imply that anyone should 'know' their townreads are accurate
How is this relevant
It's your wording. "I think your takeaway from this should be that I'm town and have a number of accurate townreads btw." You both could be wrong about some of your reads, but you are supposing that since you two agree on certain reads, that makes them accurate.
Links: User Page | GTKAS
Do you have questions, ideas, or feedback for the Scummies? Please pm me!
In post 3055, Klick wrote:
Anyway, going to sleep on this. Thanks for engaging with me on it, I feel like this was productive.
The whole Klick / Dunnstral interaction over the past page reads as SvS.
How do I come out of that interaction looking like mafia?
The whole exchange came across as not authentic. Klick is pressing you to explain why you are town (which is rather pointless because most people are going to profess their innocence and manipulate their play in a way that this isn't going to help much.) You then at first refuse but ultimately relent, and the way you executed that comes out as pretty staged. I do think you come out looking better than Klick through the whole interaction, but it still really feels staged and unnatural like two scum buddings distancing from each other but then finding a way to magically town read each other. (Okay, Klick is the one who gets the magical town read on you; I don't think you said whether you town read Klick or not after the exchange, but that's beside the point.)
What do you expect me to do differently as town there? I did what was asked of me.
"I used to think you had this elegant-trolly, minimalist playstyle. Then I realized the playstyle is ~Lazy~
The true enlightenment was realizing that they are the same thing."
~fferyllt
"who the fuck fakeclaims Tracker like that
WHO THE FUCK DOES THAT"
~Alisae
In post 3055, Klick wrote:
Anyway, going to sleep on this. Thanks for engaging with me on it, I feel like this was productive.
The whole Klick / Dunnstral interaction over the past page reads as SvS.
How do I come out of that interaction looking like mafia?
The whole exchange came across as not authentic. Klick is pressing you to explain why you are town (which is rather pointless because most people are going to profess their innocence and manipulate their play in a way that this isn't going to help much.) You then at first refuse but ultimately relent, and the way you executed that comes out as pretty staged. I do think you come out looking better than Klick through the whole interaction, but it still really feels staged and unnatural like two scum buddings distancing from each other but then finding a way to magically town read each other. (Okay, Klick is the one who gets the magical town read on you; I don't think you said whether you town read Klick or not after the exchange, but that's beside the point.)
What do you expect me to do differently as town there? I did what was asked of me.
Not engage after your initial post or two explaining why you didn't think it was useful.
Links: User Page | GTKAS
Do you have questions, ideas, or feedback for the Scummies? Please pm me!
In post 3055, Klick wrote:
Anyway, going to sleep on this. Thanks for engaging with me on it, I feel like this was productive.
The whole Klick / Dunnstral interaction over the past page reads as SvS.
How do I come out of that interaction looking like mafia?
The whole exchange came across as not authentic. Klick is pressing you to explain why you are town (which is rather pointless because most people are going to profess their innocence and manipulate their play in a way that this isn't going to help much.) You then at first refuse but ultimately relent, and the way you executed that comes out as pretty staged. I do think you come out looking better than Klick through the whole interaction, but it still really feels staged and unnatural like two scum buddings distancing from each other but then finding a way to magically town read each other. (Okay, Klick is the one who gets the magical town read on you; I don't think you said whether you town read Klick or not after the exchange, but that's beside the point.)
If your issue is with the self-meta thing itself, I can point you to several recent examples of games where I've done basically the exact same exercise
It is one of my favorite things to do to solve people who are willing to engage with it
In post 3833, Klick wrote:
I think your takeaway from this should be that I'm town and have a number of accurate townreads btw
You only know if your townreads are accurate if you're scum
???
Where do I imply that anyone should 'know' their townreads are accurate
How is this relevant
It's your wording. "I think your takeaway from this should be that I'm town and have a number of accurate townreads btw." You both could be wrong about some of your reads, but you are supposing that since you two agree on certain reads, that makes them accurate.
I *do* think that if two players come to the same read on the game independently, they are both more likely to be town having the accurate read on the situation
Or more specifically in this case, I think Pink Ball forming a set of reads and then seeing mine and going 'those reads are very similar to mine!' is pretty indicative of us both coming to our conclusions because they are the correct ones
@GiF I've read the back and forth between Klick and Titus. I want to know exactly what Titus means when she says my posting is hollow. I don't think I agree but Klick doesn't seem to disagree and is instead saying town can make hollow posts.
In post 4312, Dunnstral wrote:
@GiF I've read the back and forth between Klick and Titus. I want to know exactly what Titus means when she says my posting is hollow. I don't think I agree but Klick doesn't seem to disagree and is instead saying town can make hollow posts.
Yeah I meant your reads in general lol
I’m not sure about hollow but I do think your posts are kinda monotonous in vibe in general
That’s why I said way back in D1 that I’m gonna ignore you vs FB because generally monotonous expressing emotion will kinda look awkward and that’s what it looked like it sparked the whole you vs FB.
"I used to think you had this elegant-trolly, minimalist playstyle. Then I realized the playstyle is ~Lazy~
The true enlightenment was realizing that they are the same thing."
~fferyllt
"who the fuck fakeclaims Tracker like that
WHO THE FUCK DOES THAT"
~Alisae
"I used to think you had this elegant-trolly, minimalist playstyle. Then I realized the playstyle is ~Lazy~
The true enlightenment was realizing that they are the same thing."
~fferyllt
"who the fuck fakeclaims Tracker like that
WHO THE FUCK DOES THAT"
~Alisae
In post 4312, Dunnstral wrote:
@GiF I've read the back and forth between Klick and Titus. I want to know exactly what Titus means when she says my posting is hollow. I don't think I agree but Klick doesn't seem to disagree and is instead saying town can make hollow posts.
Yeah I meant your reads in general lol
I’m not sure about hollow but I do think your posts are kinda monotonous in vibe in general
That’s why I said way back in D1 that I’m gonna ignore you vs FB because generally monotonous expressing emotion will kinda look awkward and that’s what it looked like it sparked the whole you vs FB.
I thought FA had good responses on page 169. I like Pink Ball's energy to put forth a plan in 4206. I noticed you voted Titus but I'm not sure how you reevaluated to that. I did see 3269. I think TSQ looks townier over the last few pages. I didn't actually like Firebringer's responses as I feel they chose to focus on something that was not the main issue and ignored a few posts they would have gotten notifications for.
In post 4312, Dunnstral wrote:
@GiF I've read the back and forth between Klick and Titus. I want to know exactly what Titus means when she says my posting is hollow. I don't think I agree but Klick doesn't seem to disagree and is instead saying town can make hollow posts.
Yeah I meant your reads in general lol
I’m not sure about hollow but I do think your posts are kinda monotonous in vibe in general
That’s why I said way back in D1 that I’m gonna ignore you vs FB because generally monotonous expressing emotion will kinda look awkward and that’s what it looked like it sparked the whole you vs FB.
I thought FA had good responses on page 169. I like Pink Ball's energy to put forth a plan in 4206. I noticed you voted Titus but I'm not sure how you reevaluated to that. I did see 3269. I think TSQ looks townier over the last few pages. I didn't actually like Firebringer's responses as I feel they chose to focus on something that was not the main issue and ignored a few posts they would have gotten notifications for.
I stared at the DE wagon real hard that day and that was a hunch I got.
"I used to think you had this elegant-trolly, minimalist playstyle. Then I realized the playstyle is ~Lazy~
The true enlightenment was realizing that they are the same thing."
~fferyllt
"who the fuck fakeclaims Tracker like that
WHO THE FUCK DOES THAT"
~Alisae
