In post 884, Pink Ball wrote: Votes that I accept as good reasoning, in no particular order:
Whemestar
Sheep
Dr Drew
Blue*
Invisibility
Boring votes with less than good reasoning:
patchwork
Sir Cakez
Magical Girl
Jjh
Titus
*if you think that Blue is scum you’re wrong but it’s valid
In post 1043, Pink Ball wrote: Jjh town
?
this feels genuine. to be fair i feel like 1079 was hard to solve with how weird everything wasIn post 1371, Flavor Leaf wrote: But my reads have been off lately, so my confidence isn’t as surging as it could be
You guys really think that was serious? Lmao. Any mason claim from Ranger or FA is a joke until d3 or so.
I missed this...In post 923, Magical Girl wrote: Oh by the way, if no one offers to sign my contract, it's going out randomly.
So you agree it looks bad on the surface?In post 1375, Blue. wrote: It's not actually something scum do very often at all. It is something scum use to push townies because they take a thing that looks surface-level bad and apply a cookie cutter tell to it
Your defense of Cakez felt off. I'm trying to understand your thought process behind it. Idk what you mean by a leading questionIn post 1375, Blue. wrote: Even asking me "How do you think scum would fish?" feels like a leading question.
I don't hate you, I did feel like we mindmelded a bit when you were posting before, I just don't fully trust you, although I'm willing to work with you anyway to see what happens.In post 1366, Flavor Leaf wrote: I like blue even though they hate me
I have no idea what to believe at this point...In post 1379, Titus wrote:You guys really think that was serious? Lmao. Any mason claim from Ranger or FA is a joke until d3 or so.
Not correct. I can only be targeted by certain actions. Investigations is not one.In post 1005, SirCakez wrote: logging all my random thoughts here while i read pgs 1-10
Titus claims Invest Ascetic? That could be a fakeclaim, Ill call it null for now
(Pink Ball excerpt post here)
soooo much shitposting thank fuck for Spotify beer and skimming
dont really think sheep is scummy and think this wagon is just people making up bs to end rvs
142 is funny and thus townie lmaoo
all of these early pushes are kinda garbage tbh, my only vibe thus far is Pink Ball does actually feel scummy and its not just our pre-declared war. he feels too much like he's worried what people think about him so he's just doing what the thread is doing.
I know who Chandra is and we are probably gonna clash heads at some point and 177 is indicative of that cuz I would probably SR that post from a lot of players. the whemestar vote/push is pretty weak.
197 mind meld with Norwe who saw the same thing I did. +++town points.
Squirtle is definitely making shit up as evidenced by the terrible Doctor Drew vote in 202
my main takeaway from those ten pages is that Chandra's push on Wheme is terrible and clearly made up. Why isn't she attacking me, who has been doing jackshit and even less then Wheme? its such a terrible push and Chandra is wayy better than this.
Yeah, but thinking on the surface level doesn't tend to catch scum, and it's where scum tend to operate, because it's all black and white (no pun intended), simplistic terms, not assessing deeper motivation.In post 1381, Black wrote:So you agree it looks bad on the surface?In post 1375, Blue. wrote: It's not actually something scum do very often at all. It is something scum use to push townies because they take a thing that looks surface-level bad and apply a cookie cutter tell to it
Your defense of Cakez felt off. I'm trying to understand your thought process behind it. Idk what you mean by a leading questionIn post 1375, Blue. wrote: Even asking me "How do you think scum would fish?" feels like a leading question.
In post 719, Blue. wrote:I think he fell behind regardless of alignment, that doesn't strike me as a tell either way.In post 707, Black wrote:He drops in and says he might contribute later. Then he drops a seemingly harmless question asking if people are enjoying fighting the training dummyIn post 705, Blue. wrote:How so?In post 702, Black wrote: VOTE: Cakez
I was thinking scum might enter the thread a certain way and so far this fits
I think scum want to get as much info out of town as they possibly can. Talking about our training dummy fights is a great way to do that
What on earth do you think talking about training dummy fights accomplishes for scum? It was the most vague, inoffensive question imaginable, do you actually believe scum are going to try to fish out details of people's roles that way? Like his master plan is to get people to go "yeah I've got +2 ATK so it was easy for me even with -1 DEF"?
As far as "not assessing deeper motivation" ...what? That's literally what I'm doing by reading Cakez comment as an innocent fishing attemptIn post 726, Blue. wrote: I don't believe you really believe the words you're writing, I think you're looking for an easy target and went after the first thing that wandered in front of you. Your case is the most contrived thing in the 29 pages so far, so I'm voting you.
If forced on their life, they made a choice.In post 1132, Black wrote: What is a gth wolf
Who?In post 1140, Firebringer wrote: Willing to sell my day 1 vote. To any of my elite 6
Fire is NAI. That's RL dependant.In post 1185, Doctor Drew wrote:Hmm, last time I saw scumTitus she actually showed some fire.In post 1184, SquirtleSquad wrote:I agree.In post 1177, Ranger wrote:Believable, just one problem.
This feels like Titus-scum.
You lack passion.
snip
While I don't like either wagon, this is useful for VCA. Particularly the disintegrated patchwork wagon.In post 1203, $elene wrote:
Deadline: (expired on 2023-06-12 10:16:25)
Flavor Leaf is V/LA until Sunday
SameIn post 1248, KittyTacky wrote: FL is def town, like I'll be extremely shocked if he's scum.
Yuck.
I will with flips and claims. Don't worry. You'll be the first to know.In post 1321, SquirtleSquad wrote: titus when are you going to mech solve this game.
its kinda bullshit you havent done so already.
Random lurker (at the time) popping in to vote an increasing wagon.In post 1349, Invisibility wrote:how's it feel like a bus?In post 1346, Titus wrote:My reads as of here are Patchwork with Magic Girl, Blue with Drew.
That feels too easy though.
At this point, I just want you dead.In post 1356, Blue. wrote:You should probably wait to see where I actually go with my posts before jumping to conclusions, because that one definitely had a purpose.In post 1344, Titus wrote:Blue is asking a lot of questions while contributing nothing.In post 705, Blue. wrote:How so?In post 702, Black wrote: VOTE: Cakez
I was thinking scum might enter the thread a certain way and so far this fits
Before this latest push I would have said scum but I'm not sure now. I tend to associate solving WIM with town!titus and I haven't seen any of that from you up until now. I will say a lot of this stuff seems to be very surface level and not solvy but its enough for me to want to give you a pass to let you cook.In post 1345, Titus wrote:Gtyh what's your read on me?In post 711, SquirtleSquad wrote: I read all people who I think have really wide scum ranges this way.
No i think it's the opposite, at least for me. Smaller games are easier. Big games are noisy and have a lot of stuff happening which makes it hard to focus on what's important.In post 1301, KittyTacky wrote: Wouldn't it being a huge game make it easier to get a SR? I find it harder to read people in micros tbh.
I agree with this post. I feel similarly about "slips" and "tmi" to a large degree.In post 1375, Blue. wrote:I think accusations of rolefishing outnumber actual instances of rolefishing by something like 100 to 1. It's not actually something scum do very often at all. It is something scum use to push townies because they take a thing that looks surface-level bad and apply a cookie cutter tell to it. Even asking me "How do you think scum would fish?" feels like a leading question.In post 1362, Black wrote:Let's go back to that. You still never explained why you think that scum wouldn't fish like Cakez did. How do you think scum would fish?In post 1356, Blue. wrote:You should probably wait to see where I actually go with my posts before jumping to conclusions, because that one definitely had a purpose.In post 1344, Titus wrote:Blue is asking a lot of questions while contributing nothing.In post 705, Blue. wrote:How so?In post 702, Black wrote: VOTE: Cakez
I was thinking scum might enter the thread a certain way and so far this fits
If he made that post as scum (and I'm not ruling out the possibility), it almost certainly wasn't done with that level of intentionality. He doesn't strike me as the type of player to put that much thought into what he's posting.
Where is Klick, by the by.In post 1351, Pink Ball wrote:It was more like, answeringIn post 1339, Titus wrote:Why answer for Klick?In post 634, Pink Ball wrote: Squirtle is both times in that list so FL accusing someone out of political positioning while not being consistent with his own list is bad.
Or that’s what I think that Klick meanttoKlick rather thanfor