Open 879: Fire and More Fire [game over]

[Datisi]

vote count 1.17

with 15 votes in play, it takes 8 to make a decision. day 1 ends in (expired on 2023-06-28 17:00:00).

yeet

Bingle [4]:

Firebringer, The Bulge, osuka, Meuh

sheepsaysmeep [2]:

Radical Rat, Umlaut

Firebringer [2]:

Donempire, Black

Skygazer [2]:

Ausuka, sheepsaysmeep

Merlyn [1]:

Invisibility

Meuh [1]:

Bingle

Ausuka [1]:

Doctor Drew

Donempire [1]:

Merlyn

not voting [1]:

Skygazer

mod notes

this is a mod note.

flavour

[Ausuka]

Mooh why do you even scumread merlyn

You seem to have gone from "meh i guess im not townreading merlyn" to "If you wagon anyone except merlyn or black I hate you and you suck"

[Merlyn]

I omitted the reads wall, mostly because the spoiler stopped the cntrl f but also because the explanation there made sense to me.

but that's not fair, dammit, you can't omit the one I actually put thought into!

The rest-
You are right about the push, I recognize it was a small thing. It was also pretty early in the game though so I'm kind of good with noting small things early.

Let it be known that I do not actually town or scumread anyone on their pokemon preference, I just like glaceon. I judge them for it, but not townread or scumread them.

The holes thing is going to be longer to write about but I will tomorrow.

this is an oddly apologetic and borderline deflective post

I'm never sorry for anything ever

[Meuh]

Merlyn just has very blegh posting and the reasons people have for townreading her are all bad, it's more of a broad feeling than specific moments
and a "I guess I'm not townreading Merlyn" sentiment feels worse the more content is provided because I'd expect Merlyn to do some townie stuff by now

[Meuh]

Mooh why do you even scumread merlyn

You seem to have gone from "meh i guess im not townreading merlyn" to "If you wagon anyone except merlyn or black I hate you and you suck"

Donempire would also be good
Drew would be better than either FB or Skygazer
osuka too but a bit less
Bingle and Sheep aren't ideal but they're both better than those wagons
Idt this is an accurate characterization when I literally mentioned 5 people I was happy with wagoning in that post earlier and that I didn't despise the Sheep/Bingle wagons

[Ausuka]

Well I think it's an exaggeration to say it's an exaggeration

[Ausuka]

that emoji is really cursed on sepia

[Meuh]

Calling this an exaggeration feels like an exaggeration

Copying my homework smh my head...

[Ausuka]

Tbh after reading drew's iso again i could maybe compromise there

He has towny vibes but his actual reads kind of suck and feel pretty stagnant. I guess I'm biased on me but his osuka read is also bad and static

pedit: I always copy people's homework

[Meuh]

Actually yeah why is Drew voting for you right now that vote sucks

[Meuh]

8 wagon split with 13 hours left is crazyyyyyyyyy actually what even

[Ausuka]

Merlyn just has very blegh posting and the reasons people have for townreading her are all bad, it's more of a broad feeling than specific moments
and a "I guess I'm not townreading Merlyn" sentiment feels worse the more content is provided because I'd expect Merlyn to do some townie stuff by now

Tbh the main reason I townread merlyn is because it felt like everyone was townreading umlaut and her read on him was like basically exactly what I was thinking at the time. I like a lot of the reads she gave tbh - like Sky and bella, and the reads on drew and RR also felt like believable to me? I mean to be fair, it does occur to me that Merlyn as scum doesn't know the alignment of any of these people, so maybe it's bad to assume genuine reads = town, but shrug I think even if it's weaker stuff like this is prob still more likely to be towny? I also think the reasons people have for scumreading her kind of suck ass for the most part.

I think in general people have been like 'scum can write readslists too' like yeah no shit but I think the reads are towny

[Ausuka]

Wait no one is even voting for drew lmao

[Ausuka]

ok im just going to sleep and vote whoever in the morning

[Meuh]

I did like her Bella read actually that's fair, most of the rest I didn't find super compelling

[Meuh]

Gngn
Will also be around before/at deadline so we can figure something out last minute as functional towns always do

[Doctor Drew]

Tbh after reading drew's iso again i could maybe compromise there

He has towny vibes but his actual reads kind of suck and feel pretty stagnant. I guess I'm biased on me but his osuka read is also bad and static

pedit: I always copy people's homework

Why is my Osuka read bad, you never explained that.

And it is fair to say I have bad reads, but why would you compromise on someone who has towny vibes?

And is it just stagnant because I have consistently wanted to lim you over Bingle, or Sheep, or most others?

[Ausuka]

Osuka made towel replace out and has spent the whole game calling people stupid but you have said he is scum for being insufficiently aggressive. If that was part of your case that's one thing but I'm pretty sure that's the main reason you want to kill osuka which is pretty difficult to believe for me.

Your read on me is stagnant - you voted me because you townread bingle and then said i was scum for thinking black was town because she wasn't self conscious or something? And like, since then i don't think you've really responded to anything i've said, including my clarification of that, vs just insisting I am scum repeatedly

[Radical Rat]

Hey remember when everyone got on my ass because I mentioned compromise and consolidation at three days instead of one?

This shit is why.

[Meuh]

RR come consolidate on Bingle with me

[Meuh]

Also wasn't that like one person who called you out on that, I liked it

[Ausuka]

I don't remember getting on your ass for that :c

[Radical Rat]

I'm exaggerating when I say everyone, but I'm sure there were at least two people.

[Radical Rat]

RR come consolidate on Bingle with me

I will if it must be done, but I still think Bingle's Town.

[Radical Rat]

I'll do Black, or you could sheep me on sheep?