In post 574, Deltabreedy wrote:
I think it's quirky that Fire jumped in to defend Datisi super-hard, it looked more like someone looking to curry favour on what was being universally called a bad read for credit, and didnt read as genuine.
Why would Town!Fire jump in to defend Datisi? Meh I dont think they're town
I think it is fairly common for townies to jump in and defend people against what they think are bad arguments
In post 574, Deltabreedy wrote:
I think it's quirky that Fire jumped in to defend Datisi super-hard, it looked more like someone looking to curry favour on what was being universally called a bad read for credit, and didnt read as genuine.
Why would Town!Fire jump in to defend Datisi? Meh I dont think they're town
In post 560, fireisredsir wrote:
idk how to find sk but i think they could easily be in the top half of my reads since they are uninformed so it's not very hard for them to fake looking towny i would think?
i think don's theory of appearance being sk is kinda dumb bc part of the issue w him (at least my issue) is lack of genuine looking scum hunting which shouldn't be difficult for sk to fake since it wouldn't even be fake
and i don't really like don's overconfidence in it, it feels kinda like he just decided a narrative to push bc then he doesn't have to fake any nuance or solving thought
that said appearance is kinda scummy regardless
Interesting. It's a very shallow disertation of what i've said so far. As for your point of contestion, Sk would not want to be overtly doing scumhunting because they wouldn't want to be targeted by scum.
Can you expand on your shea and merlyn reads?
shea idk i think he's been kinda scummy but i also think he might try harder to not look scummy if he's actually scum lol
like ignoring me just kinda makes me think that he doesn't want to talk to me but doesn't think the point is important which he's probably more likely to feel as town bc he knows he's town. if he knows he's scum he may feel more obligated to defend himself. im aware this is an awful reason to lessen a scumread on someone but shrug
merlyn i don't have anything to elaborate on beyond what i already said which isn't very much. i don't have a strong read on her and im not really sure how to
In post 574, Deltabreedy wrote:
I think it's quirky that Fire jumped in to defend Datisi super-hard, it looked more like someone looking to curry favour on what was being universally called a bad read for credit, and didnt read as genuine.
Why would Town!Fire jump in to defend Datisi? Meh I dont think they're town
i mean the point wasn't about datisi really
your arguments just seemed really bad and scummy to me and i was attacking them bc i think you're scum, and trying to show why i didn't think they were believable thoughts for town to have
call it a chainsaw if you want lol, that would at least be more accurate
In post 574, Deltabreedy wrote:
looked more like someone looking to curry favour on what was being universally called a bad read for credit
this is also just made up
i was the first one besides datisi to call it out as a bad read. nobody else had criticized it at all. it was nowhere close to "what was universally called a bad read"
even if you're talking about afterwards (which makes no sense -- how would i know in advance it would be universally called a bad read?) it def was not universal, don and appearance liked your points
I don't think i'll be able to get a fire case ready in time. Apologies, life's been pretty hectic. Guess i'm fine with an appearance hammer if you must.
Age of Empires Elo: 1500 something in DE, 1800 in HD
Formerly Dongempire
The night has passed, and the town has reassembled, however an odd killing has occurred, you find Thestatusquo with an odd number of cuts, obviously this has been done by the odd night killer.
However another thing comes to pass as you look over the body once more, you find one of the weapons that have been tied to the even night killer killings, and thus can tell that this must be one of them.
Thestatusquo the Even-Night Mafia Goon has been killed Night 1
Returning win rate: 4/1, 80%
In the process of creating a game to mod, we will see what it holds.
I don't think SK was Cop hunting, this was very likely a fear kill. Shea was basically set up to take center stage today, and I don't think it makes any sense for the SK to disrupt that unless they were afraid that a town!Shea could thrive and turn the attention back onto them.
VOTE: Sheep
Merlyn is hard cleared from being Shea's scum buddy IMO. And the Shea kills makes no sense from her position if she were SK since he was defending her all game.
It is definitely still good for town to hit SK today but it is especially good for scum to hit SK today because then they direct all the nightkills.
So I think its worth looking into who was a little bit too enthusiastic about refuting the "we shouldn't try to hit sk today" point.
I feel like this was genuine spew and that his partner doesn't fit the criteria he's describing here. I doubt that anyone who was pushing to hit the SK yesterday is the second mafia, and that his buddy either had no comment or tried to blend in by doubting our attempts to hit the SK.
