Veiled Committee Mafia: List Mods Edition [game over]

[AniX]

someone asked me about this

because anix is obvious scum lol

Anix has felt off since the beginning of the game, trying to blame their weirdness on being from a different era and not voting me but sussing me early is kind of weird. Since then, their actions have only gotten weirder.

I want to be clear, my weirdness is independent from me being from a different era.

[Theta Alpine]

in response to random nurses comments on my posts
at least the ones i could figure out
i meant my role would not be part of a game breaking strategy
i would still claim it if we did a mass claim

having said that
i am not sure that the listmods would submit roles that lend themselves to a game breaking setup
this is not a reviewed game but it also is not a upick or fully randomized setup either

[Bingle]

Anix has felt off since the beginning of the game, trying to blame their weirdness on being from a different era and not voting me but sussing me early is kind of weird. Since then, their actions have only gotten weirder.

:thorface:

I don’t think AniX has made any excuses for their play, actually. I think AniX has given a reason for mech focus, but afaicr all of the explanations for why the {performative/stilted} thus {scum} being bullshit have been me.

And correct me if I’m wrong, but the only AniX is town assertions have been me and people saying “Bingle sounds right.” Regardless, that some people, regardless of the number, think AniX is town doesn’t make the push of AniX is scum for being weird any less of an easy push, and it is provably false that that is not a stance many people are taking. I would be shocked if there wasn’t scum in that mess of names, and your takes look the worst of them to me.

[AniX]

in response to random nurses comments on my posts
at least the ones i could figure out
i meant my role would not be part of a game breaking strategy
i would still claim it if we did a mass claim

having said that
i am not sure that the listmods would submit roles that lend themselves to a game breaking setup
this is not a reviewed game but it also is not a upick or fully randomized setup either

Yeah, but if they didn't consult with one another, they could have easily produced roles that individually couldn't break a game but together with a wacky role they couldn't have anticipated might.

[Save The Dragons]

Ranger: Possibly forced to claim Miller either legitimately or illegitimately to active some power
Skygazer: Some sort of ability (possibly their legitimate assertion of vote trading) related to a questionnaire perhaps.
Aureal: Something related to their MLM posting shtick. Possibly recruitment for neighborhood or cult (although there was no cult at base, I guess this could activate a cult under certain conditions)
DragonEater: Hurt Tag usage as power activator
Koba: Artifice of posting towards DragonEater and DragonEater alone

Maybe I'm WAY out of the modern meta, but if having a pretty decent to solid leads on at least 5 roles of other players in a complex game with brand new roles is "barely", I'd love to see your 6+.

i don't think any of these are accurate

"AniX's reads are not accurate" and "AniX has no reads" are exclusive positions from one another.

No they aren't

If I take a math test and my answers are "banana" and "orange" I haven't done any math and my answers are invalid

What is this

[Save The Dragons]

Anix has felt off since the beginning of the game, trying to blame their weirdness on being from a different era and not voting me but sussing me early is kind of weird. Since then, their actions have only gotten weirder.

:thorface:

I don’t think AniX has made any excuses for their play, actually. I think AniX has given a reason for mech focus, but afaicr all of the explanations for why the {performative/stilted} thus {scum} being bullshit have been me.

And correct me if I’m wrong, but the only AniX is town assertions have been me and people saying “Bingle sounds right.” Regardless, that some people, regardless of the number, think AniX is town doesn’t make the push of AniX is scum for being weird any less of an easy push, and it is provably false that that is not a stance many people are taking. I would be shocked if there wasn’t scum in that mess of names, and your takes look the worst of them to me.

You are wrong some people tr anix without mentioni ng you

[Skygazer]

can't we just stop arguing and get back to what's important (murdering drew)

[Cook]

good morning mafiascum!!

[Cook]

drew wagon is… a choice? little concerned on how fast it came together. scum lubricated the wheels no doubt

oh well, i will participate
VOTE: Doctor Drew

[AniX]

Ranger: Possibly forced to claim Miller either legitimately or illegitimately to active some power
Skygazer: Some sort of ability (possibly their legitimate assertion of vote trading) related to a questionnaire perhaps.
Aureal: Something related to their MLM posting shtick. Possibly recruitment for neighborhood or cult (although there was no cult at base, I guess this could activate a cult under certain conditions)
DragonEater: Hurt Tag usage as power activator
Koba: Artifice of posting towards DragonEater and DragonEater alone

Maybe I'm WAY out of the modern meta, but if having a pretty decent to solid leads on at least 5 roles of other players in a complex game with brand new roles is "barely", I'd love to see your 6+.

i don't think any of these are accurate

"AniX's reads are not accurate" and "AniX has no reads" are exclusive positions from one another.

No they aren't

If I take a math test and my answers are "banana" and "orange" I haven't done any math and my answers are invalid

What is this

Honestly, what the fuck are you even talking about here? If my reads don't exist, they can't be accurate or inaccurate because nonexistent reads don't have accuracy values. If my reads DO exist, I must by necessity have them since they...exist. That is not the case with whatever madlibs you are playing here, where getting banana has no causal relationship to orange.

This really seems like less "I don't believe you", which would be fine, and more "I am going to twist anything you say into something I can criticize". I'm not sure it's scummy, but it's definitely goofy.

[Save The Dragons]

You're being pedantic again

[Save The Dragons]

You've decided I've said two different things and are trying to justify it rather than read what I'm saying critically

[Save The Dragons]

I'll paraphrase

Me: anix doesn't have reads
Anix: here are my reads
Me: no those don't count because they are nonsense. You dont have reads.
Anix: you didn't say it in the specific way I require you to say it

W/e I'm disengaging we can continue this stupid argument when I go back to voting you

[DkKoba]

I kinda think anix has strong potential to be town but std is right on the perspective that the reads are kinda derived from objectively poor reasoning

When solving with mech, it's never about "this role sounds scummy" and as I mentioned earlier, open role usage/claiming in role madness is objectively more likely to be town.

[AniX]

I'll paraphrase

Me: anix doesn't have reads
Anix: here are my reads
Me: no those don't count because they are nonsense. You dont have reads.
Anix: you didn't say it in the specific way I require you to say it

W/e I'm disengaging we can continue this stupid argument when I go back to voting you

STD: "You don't have reads"
AniX: "Actually I do, here they are"
STD: "No that doesn't count because I have secretly determined they are nonsense, no I will not elaborate"
AniX: "That isn't an argument"
STD: "YOU ARE BEING PEDANTIC AGAIN!"

Yeah, ok.

[Save The Dragons]

Disengaging

[AniX]

I kinda think anix has strong potential to be town but std is right on the perspective that the reads are kinda derived from objectively poor reasoning

When solving with mech, it's never about

"this role sounds scummy"

and as I mentioned earlier, open role usage/claiming in role madness is objectively more likely to be town.

That is not even my argument. It has never been my argument. You will not find that argument from me about any role at any point in this game.

The two people I have attempted to explore if they were mafia through roles are someone who's ability I suspect REQUIRES open role usage to work (and thus it being openly used would not be town-aligned) and someone whose role I am arguing is different from the role they are suggesting they are.

[AniX]

Me when I start an argument and realize I am actually wrong and continuing it makes me look bad:

Disengaging

[AniX]

Anyway, I probably won't post again until Saturday EST, it's my brother's wedding tomorrow and I'm leaving now.

[Doctor Drew]

im actually okay with going drew, seems kind of muted

VOTE: drew

can someone explain pretty please

i dunno i feel like drew should be more present

I kinda tend to be in a game type like this on D1, especially when anytime to come to the thread I have to deal with Anix/Koba pointing at each other and screaming 'no you!' ad nauseam.

So ya, gonna just hang out for a bit in the whiskey pocket and then do my usual drunk posting in the evening.

[KatyKimFanClub]

Me when I start an argument and realize I am actually wrong and continuing it makes me look bad:

Disengaging

This comment isn't very fair lol.

[DkKoba]

I kinda think anix has strong potential to be town but std is right on the perspective that the reads are kinda derived from objectively poor reasoning

When solving with mech, it's never about

"this role sounds scummy"

and as I mentioned earlier, open role usage/claiming in role madness is objectively more likely to be town.

That is not even my argument. It has never been my argument. You will not find that argument from me about any role at any point in this game.

The two people I have attempted to explore if they were mafia through roles are someone who's ability I suspect REQUIRES open role usage to work (and thus it being openly used would not be town-aligned) and someone whose role I am arguing is different from the role they are suggesting they are.

That is how I perceive it. Elaborate better as you've been asked to multiple times and we won't won't misunderstand ?

[Save The Dragons]

Me when I start an argument and realize I am actually wrong and continuing it makes me look bad:

Disengaging

Sure believe what you want. You are wrong.

[camelCasedSnivy]

i wanna believe std and anix is TvT

[Cook]

that's about where i'm at too?