In post 369, Dannflor wrote:
i believe some of the best reads can come from RVS and the phase shortly after as a general rule lol
i don't think that stuff that happens that early is *less* worthy of being read into. i do, however, think that on page 5 your sample size of "stuff that has been done and can be read into" is too small to make eliminating anyone a very bad idea
i am surprised you disagree with this based on my knowledge of you as a player. you were town in friends and enemies, obviously, and when i was pushing shadi for something that happened early you were implying i shouldn't still believe a read from so close to the start of the game?
In post 369, Dannflor wrote:
i believe some of the best reads can come from RVS and the phase shortly after as a general rule lol
i don't think that stuff that happens that early is *less* worthy of being read into. i do, however, think that on page 5 your sample size of "stuff that has been done and can be read into" is too small to make eliminating anyone a very bad idea
i am surprised you disagree with this based on my knowledge of you as a player. you were town in friends and enemies, obviously, and when i was pushing shadi for something that happened early you were implying i shouldn't still believe a read from so close to the start of the game?
pedit: T3 i kind of think you said that too lol
i think the longer the game goes the more likely scum are to win
i actually think larger sample size tends to just add more noise to reads
that wasn't because I thought the read was bad, I was surprised you either A. hadn't already killed Shadi if you still believed that read, or B. changed your read because you hadn't already killed Shadi
like I didn't expect you to still have that read and for Shadi to still be alive
ok i mean on the surface it feels stupid to entertain the idea you might be lying about that but how do you expect me to just kill him. i had been beating the lim shadi drum for like the entire game, i can't just like snap my fingers and eliminate people
when you roll scum, on average, how guilty is your conscience
Firstly welcome to the game! I don't think we've met unless you're an alt
I don't have a guilty conscience when I roll scum. I'm elated. Sometimes I feel guilty throughout the course of a game but that's usually based on personal relations and me stressing people out that I really like
yeah I like feel very good about that solve *if* all the major players in the game so far are town
i feel like that dynamic is very very hard for scum to interact with genuinely at all and I think CCS/T3/Aureal all displayed they were able to do that
In post 307, T3 wrote:
I don't think this game will ever progress without a black lim tbf
VOTE: T3
I don't think he is trying to solve the game. He voted for me on page 2 and since then almost every post has been a timely pop-in to keep the pressure on me. This post feels like an excuse to not do anything until I'm faded
Sure? I mean, I have reads on players that are not you but I haven't been particularly expressive of those reads. I understand where this read comes from though.
this feels like a townpost tbh
Why? I'm not seeing it and tbh I'm not sure why anyone is townreading T3 at this point
The lack of omgus towards Dann and myself gives me pause, and I do think T3's stance here is strange at least.
i don't know much of dunnstral's posting feels like he's waiting to see which way the thread is going to go
I feel like town!Dunnstral would have a new target in mind here to put pressure on
I think the reason he's backing off of Black is weird because... Black was already OMGUSing Generic, it's not like she can realistically or believable OMGUS all the people pushing her. it just feels a bit made up as a reason to back off of black. I kinda just think Dunnstral would have a better reason here
