Mafia 29: Mafia - Game over!

[HairyMezican]

3 kills? It doesn't really make sense for there to be more than 1 town faction. Do we have 2 serial killers, or does someone want to claim ownership of the melchizedek kill?

[Coron]

Maybe one of the vigs did it.

[DarkLight140]

Well, we got as many as four killing groups out of that, if we use the "two bullet holes=two people targeted" theory. If Locus Cosecant killed someone (potentially melchizedek) last night, then we're down to three, of which probably at least two are anti-mafia, though it seems like the mafia would probably have a high number of vig roles. In any case, it would probably be a bad idea for anyone to claim a kill at this point. They would eat up protects, maybe attract a townie role block, and in general be more trouble than the knowledge is worth.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I don't think we need to lynch Mezican today, JDTAY...We should have more info now, and he came close enough to being lynched that I doubt he is town, at least enough that wasting a lynch on another claimed goon is pointless...it is possible he planned to give himself up, but since there was no night, there was no way for him to plan this with his town buddies if he was lying...you are way too eager to waste another of our lynches, so I think you are town trying to push us towards that goal...

VOTE:JDTAY

[lazarusmoth]

going back to an earlier hunch.

vote: HM

[Yggdrasil]

Vote Count

:

2 HairyMezican (JDTAY, lazarusmoth)
1 JDTAY (Mastermind of Sin)

9 to lynch.

[PeaceBringer]

vote JD

something needs to happen

[Desperate Heart]

God damn family vacations are annoying

Anyway, the guys that voted for our confirmed goons are.

bigbenwd
Scalebane
Uraj45
olliep13
Hairy Mezican
lazarusmoth
Darklight140
Quagmire (Goon)
Mastermind of Sin

And the people who voted with the confirmed townie are

ZONEACE (Goon)
bloojay
Locus Cosecant (Goon)
commify

In case we want to consider a townie bandwagon yesterday.

Also, this game looks like it has a whole lot of killing roles.

[PeaceBringer]

gee GH I guess I didn't vote, hmm-

LOL

[olliep13]

I get the feeling that Hairymezican is a serial killer... however for now, i will go for one of the people who voted with Melchizedek.

Vote Bloojay

[joe]

i still feel that hm is a serial killer

vote hairy mezican

[joe]

i still feel that hm is a serial killer

vote hairy mezican

[joe]

i still feel that hm is a serial killer

vote hairy mezican

[Scalebane]

I had a pretty long post. Php dropped it. That's frustrating. Anyways, I don't really like the hairy mezican bandwagon. I just don't think, on day 2, that it's our best decision.

[Mastermind of Sin]

GH, you might want to point out which ppl on ur list were voting for who, to narrow things down...

[Desperate Heart]

Everyone but you on the first list voted for zoneace, and you voted for locus.

The second list, by virtue of being people who voted with melch, only contains people that voted for Coron.


I'd guess that if the town

did

vote together most were going for zoneace and we got the odd man out when we vigged (Or SKed) melch. Of the For Zoneace list I'm not entirely sure who's most suspicious though. Whoever's lurking the most, I guess. Or maybe Mezican.

Alternatively, the town tried an unsuccessfull Coron bandwagon and both bloojay and commify are townspeople.

And, of course, it's entirely possible that the town didn't vote as a group. This is probably true for one or two members, but it'd be annoying if it was true for the rest as well (Who didn't vote yesterday?)

Option two is the easiest to test, and gives us two townies if correct, but I think it's also the least likely.

I'll wait on voting for now, though I will get around to this day. We've had a night now so no lynch isn't an option anymore.

[PeaceBringer]

again the above list is in-correct cause I ended up on the zoneace lynch I believe.

vote JDTAy--

why go back to that vote?

[Desperate Heart]

Ah, missed the 1/2 majority bit. So I will

unvote.

This means you didn't vote for zoneace.

But don't worry, I sort of suspect you of being town anyway.

[Coron]

wouldn't it make sense to keep track of who voted them at any point?

Currently I really don't have any information that makes me not think that HM is a good lynch, or that anyone else really is a better lynch, but I'd prefer not to vote for now.

[commify]

Alternatively, the town tried an unsuccessfull Coron bandwagon and both bloojay and commify are townspeople.

I voted for Coron because I thought it was better to vote for a possible townie than for ZONEACE or HM, who were goons. I saw the case against ZONEACE as rather weak, and I never really thought that HM had done anything scummy.

[Desperate Heart]

Here's the list of people who voted for a confirmed goon at any point during the game.

Zoneace

bigbenwd
Scalebane
Coron
Uraj45
DarkLight40
HairyMezican
JDTAY
olliep13
PeaceBringer
lazarusmoth
Quagmire

Locus Cosecant

Mastermind of Sin
JDTAY (Early)
Hairy Mezican
Coron
PeaceBringer
lazarusmoth

(No votes were placed on Quagmire)

HairyMezican, Coron, PeaceBringer, JDTAY, and lazarusmoth all appear on both lists (This is most likely because they started on Locus and then moved to Zoneace as the, uh.. "evidence" developed.)

Right now I'm slightly suspicious of everyone who lynched Zoneace, and after rereading the thread a little bit more suspicious of Coron and PeaceBringer, though it may just be because PB's style annoys me.

commify and bloojay have a very good chance of being goons, but I'm gonna be just a teeny tiny bit suspicious of them too. On principle.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Alternatively, the town tried an unsuccessfull Coron bandwagon and both bloojay and commify are townspeople.

I voted for Coron because I thought it was better to vote for a possible townie than for ZONEACE or HM, who were goons. I saw the case against ZONEACE as rather weak, and I never really thought that HM had done anything scummy.

wait...how did you

know

they were goons??? Anybody could claim to be a goon...actually, I've seen several instances where scum claimed a role day 1 without any real provocation, just so that people wouldn't really think about them as possible scum...I'm not saying that I think HM is scum(townie), but I only came to that opinion after seeing the end of the day and what happened...I don't see any way you could've known at that point unless you had information on them in advance...

[bloojay]

Hey guys, just popping in to say that i'll have very limited access fomr here on till the 7th of February. I posted this in the limited access thread too, but nobody seems to read it...

At any rate, i need to go back and look at what happened today. But from what i've read so far...

I get the feeling that Hairymezican is a serial killer... however for now, i will go for one of the people who voted with Melchizedek.

Vote Bloojay

I'm confused by the with. Do you mean that i voted for similar people as melchizedek or that i voted FOR him?

[olliep13]

I'm confused by the with. Do you mean that i voted for similar people as melchizedek or that i voted FOR him?

I meant you voted for the same person that melchizedek did.

[Coron]

JDtay and Laz are both on the same person right now. Strong connection there.

FOS: JD and lazarusmoth