mini theme 2315 - love child (game over)

[Meuh]

Gamma vaguely looks town? I can see Broccoli town, at the very least I don't think they're scummy enough for me to be interested in a wagon there

VOTE: Titus
Don't think she has any interest in solving the game tbh

I don't see anything towny from GE prior to this post.

Spoiler:

VOTE: Theta Alpine
found scum already

Aureal gets a D1 pass

I’m down to speedwagon on Broccoli

I no longer am interested in voting Broccoli

The laid back tone here feels both genuine and town indicative

[Meuh]

I can see the scum me angle

but Andante is one of the only people solving here and said solving looks townie to me

I feel like scum usually say this more than town because they think it looks noble

True but I'm still town

[furtiveglance]

Gamma vaguely looks town? I can see Broccoli town, at the very least I don't think they're scummy enough for me to be interested in a wagon there

VOTE: Titus
Don't think she has any interest in solving the game tbh

I don't see anything towny from GE prior to this post.

Spoiler:

VOTE: Theta Alpine
found scum already

Aureal gets a D1 pass

I’m down to speedwagon on Broccoli

I no longer am interested in voting Broccoli

The laid back tone here feels both genuine and town indicative

Yeah maybe

[Skygazer]

votecount 1.14

Ircher (3) - Hu Tao, Gamma Emerald, Afrayed Knott
Afrayed Knott (3): Andante, HighPrincessErinys, furtiveglance
Titus (2) - Ircher, Aureal
furtiveglance (2) - Meuh, Broccoli Quest 2
Meuh (1) - Doctor Drew
Aureal (1) - Titus

not voting

(1) - Theta Alpine

with thirteen alive, it takes seven votes to be the first one to die. how embarassing! day one ends in (expired on 2023-11-01 17:45:00).

[Meuh]

Titus' ISO is also yawn inducing and scummier than yours
Maybe there's merit to a vote on you for the sake of pressure but meh
I'll VOTE: Furtive though

I also don't buy this explanation

I checked your ISO but not Alianna's yesterday for context if that somehow helps

[furtiveglance]

I can see the scum me angle

but Andante is one of the only people solving here and said solving looks townie to me

I feel like scum usually say this more than town because they think it looks noble

True but I'm still town

I've seen Andante post like that as scum before. The game with Firebringer also scum and it was a scum sweep

Also, what in your eyes made you seem like scum to yourself?

[Meuh]

I can see the scum me angle

but Andante is one of the only people solving here and said solving looks townie to me

I feel like scum usually say this more than town because they think it looks noble

True but I'm still town

I've seen Andante post like that as scum before. The game with Firebringer also scum and it was a scum sweep

Also, what in your eyes made you seem like scum to yourself?

HPE calling my posting and stance around wanting to end day weird was fair
There's enough weirdness to my gameplay (that while I think is probably outdone by towniness) that I can see people reasonably come to the conclusion of me being scum based off of.
Andante's posting is town indicative (like mine), but lacks the weirdness that made me stick out around there, so an Andante scumread felt harder to understand

[Broccoli Quest 2]

Why are people voting Furt?

Same reason you voted Alianna, and it hasn't really gotten better since then.

I read 172 and was about to quote it and say this is scummy before I realised I was Alianna's slot.

I... do appreciate the fact it's funny. In fact it made me chuckle out loud.


Fineeee I won't scumread you for that! But I will keep scumreading you for other things!


For instance, Mr. Sailor

Moon

Swift, can you explain how this is not just a blatant attempt to get TR'd?

Broccoli Quest 2 - town.
HighPrincessErinys - town, agreed with a lot of posts here.
Doctor Drew - town by meta and direction of travel (i.e. agrees with my takes)
Hu Tao - town. Liked both streams of posts so far
Theta Alpine - town. A level of depth to posting about reads that I didn't see from scum!Rautherdir in Conception (hope talking about alt metas is ok)


Ircher - unsure. Scum by posts (as ever?) but town by VCA?
Andante - unsure. Not a priority vote at the moment but I am wary of what I saw as a scattergun approach to votes/scumreads.
Gamma Emerald - unsure. Wallflower act is meta typical but harder to read, hopefully GE gets into a more direct discussion at some point soon.
Titus - unsure. Tonally different from scumgame but voting is a little strange.
Aureal - unsure. Tonally seems town and just like past towngames but not packing enough of a punch to be a TR just yet.


Meuh - scum based on posting and voting. I don't get the TRs here at all.
Afrayed Knott - scum. Vote priority urgent.

I feel this has barely any effort put into it (and I feel mean saying that if you did put effort into it, sorry). Like anyone could come up with me/HT/DD being town and the rest of the reads feel surface level-ey if not outright fake:
Which posts of HPE do you agree with? I don't feel it voiced much opinions this game (it mainly said that it was unsure about a bunch of things iirc)
And are you seriously putting Knott as your top scumread based on his whack entrance?
How is Ircher town by VCA and scum by posts?

[Broccoli Quest 2]

Gamma vaguely looks town? I can see Broccoli town, at the very least I don't think they're scummy enough for me to be interested in a wagon there

VOTE: Titus
Don't think she has any interest in solving the game tbh

I don't see anything towny from GE prior to this post.

Spoiler:

VOTE: Theta Alpine
found scum already

Aureal gets a D1 pass

I’m down to speedwagon on Broccoli

I no longer am interested in voting Broccoli

The laid back tone here feels both genuine and town indicative

I can see the scum me angle

but Andante is one of the only people solving here and said solving looks townie to me

I feel like scum usually say this more than town because they think it looks noble

True but I'm still town

I can see the scum me angle

but Andante is one of the only people solving here and said solving looks townie to me

I feel like scum usually say this more than town because they think it looks noble

True but I'm still town

I've seen Andante post like that as scum before. The game with Firebringer also scum and it was a scum sweep

Also, what in your eyes made you seem like scum to yourself?

HPE calling my posting and stance around wanting to end day weird was fair
There's enough weirdness to my gameplay (that while I think is probably outdone by towniness) that I can see people reasonably come to the conclusion of me being scum based off of.
Andante's posting is town indicative (like mine), but lacks the weirdness that made me stick out around there, so an Andante scumread felt harder to understand

Okay I'm gonna be a cauliflower for a second and say:

ya meuh is town

[Theta Alpine]

hmm

not sure i can voice my meuh town read beyond vibe

as to rautherdirs meta uh
i am not entirely sure my meta can be comparable to rauths but i am not gonna get mad about if you do

[HighPrincessErinys]

Okay yeah this one does kinda see now what Drew meant with the Andante/Meuh stuff but either way this one thinks Afrayed is the way to go here.

What do you think of Furtive's takes on this page?

Honestly fairly good? Not super sure about how he's confident on scum!Meuh but Ali was an eh-meh null for me and furtive this one is fine raising to a townread.

[HighPrincessErinys]

Also note to self: ISO Theta and actually acknowledge her posts

[Ircher]

I'll say that I'm not interested in an Aureal lim today

Titus' posting has gone up a notch and while she's not the towniest town to ever town, I can believe a world where she's town

Incorrect.

[furtiveglance]

Spoiler: Green quote

Why are people voting Furt?

Same reason you voted Alianna, and it hasn't really gotten better since then.

I read 172 and was about to quote it and say this is scummy before I realised I was Alianna's slot.

I... do appreciate the fact it's funny. In fact it made me chuckle out loud.


Fineeee I won't scumread you for that! But I will keep scumreading you for other things!


For instance, Mr. Sailor

Moon

Swift, can you explain how this is not just a blatant attempt to get TR'd?

Broccoli Quest 2 - town.
HighPrincessErinys - town, agreed with a lot of posts here.
Doctor Drew - town by meta and direction of travel (i.e. agrees with my takes)
Hu Tao - town. Liked both streams of posts so far
Theta Alpine - town. A level of depth to posting about reads that I didn't see from scum!Rautherdir in Conception (hope talking about alt metas is ok)


Ircher - unsure. Scum by posts (as ever?) but town by VCA?
Andante - unsure. Not a priority vote at the moment but I am wary of what I saw as a scattergun approach to votes/scumreads.
Gamma Emerald - unsure. Wallflower act is meta typical but harder to read, hopefully GE gets into a more direct discussion at some point soon.
Titus - unsure. Tonally different from scumgame but voting is a little strange.
Aureal - unsure. Tonally seems town and just like past towngames but not packing enough of a punch to be a TR just yet.


Meuh - scum based on posting and voting. I don't get the TRs here at all.
Afrayed Knott - scum. Vote priority urgent.

I feel this has barely any effort put into it (and I feel mean saying that if you did put effort into it, sorry). Like anyone could come up with me/HT/DD being town and the rest of the reads feel surface level-ey if not outright fake:
Which posts of HPE do you agree with? I don't feel it voiced much opinions this game (it mainly said that it was unsure about a bunch of things iirc)
And are you seriously putting Knott as your top scumread based on his whack entrance?
How is Ircher town by VCA and scum by posts?

You need to pick a line of attack here. Is it busy work to get townread or is it low effort lazy scumplay? It's neither, because the point of it is to show what my reads are in the hope I'll be judged on them and on subsequent flips. I didn't feel the need to quote every post to justify a read, nor was the idea to put in really deep thoughts to display my own alignment.

I don't think my reads were completely consensus either.

Main thing I like from HPE is the Afrayed scumread.

Ircher is town by VCA because he was E-1 early on D1, and scum by posts because his posts are scummy. Also scummy for lack of posts after E-1.

Putting Afrayed Knott last because I feel confident in this read and I want to underline it to get more votes on him.
179 isn't just wack, it's really scummy. The 'random' vote is ostentatiously explained, comments about pages and colour are robotically dry, mention of being mislimmed D1 in a previous game is subtle ATE, ends with a plea for a D1 pass just unashamed survivalism.

Subsequent posts are nearly all jokes of some kind, the voting and unvoting of Ircher with no explanation is also best explained by a Scum/Town dynamic there.

[HighPrincessErinys]

I'll say that I'm not interested in an Aureal lim today

Titus' posting has gone up a notch and while she's not the towniest town to ever town, I can believe a world where she's town

Incorrect.

Aaaaaaand do you wanna elaborate why?

[Ircher]

I still feel Titus is scum. She had not done anything by the point I voted her other than go over things that had already been hashed out. She has since OMGUSed me, which I get but it doesn't do her any favors in my read, and then offered one small read, so I'm fine leaving my vote there.

I moved away from Broccoli because I thought Broccoli's more recent posts were better. I didn't really like their mason stuff at the beginning of the game; it felt like the kind of thing scum does to joke around and look town which is why I voted there in the first place, but Broccoli has shown earnest attempt to solve the game since.

I agree that broccoli is town. I'm not sure I buy the Titus read, though. Is the 'omgus' the only reason?

The OMGUS was and is not the primary reason for the read.

[furtiveglance]

hmm

not sure i can voice my meuh town read beyond vibe

as to rautherdirs meta uh
i am not entirely sure my meta can be comparable to rauths but i am not gonna get mad about if you do

[Ircher]

I'll say that I'm not interested in an Aureal lim today

Titus' posting has gone up a notch and while she's not the towniest town to ever town, I can believe a world where she's town

Incorrect.

Aaaaaaand do you wanna elaborate why?

Titus's posting hasn't improved.

[HighPrincessErinys]

ircher can you pretty please give me like, a read list or something

[Ircher]

Town

Broccoli
Andante

Null

Everyone not listed.

Scum

Titus

[furtiveglance]

VOTE: Titus

I still feel Titus is scum. She had not done anything by the point I voted her other than go over things that had already been hashed out. She has since OMGUSed me, which I get but it doesn't do her any favors in my read, and then offered one small read, so I'm fine leaving my vote there.

I moved away from Broccoli because I thought Broccoli's more recent posts were better. I didn't really like their mason stuff at the beginning of the game; it felt like the kind of thing scum does to joke around and look town which is why I voted there in the first place, but Broccoli has shown earnest attempt to solve the game since.

I feel like this kind of comes out of nowhere from Ircher. Yes there was a preceding vote, but it wasn't explained, so I assume the logic was just deferring to the post quoted below (which came directly before):

Gamma vaguely looks town? I can see Broccoli town, at the very least I don't think they're scummy enough for me to be interested in a wagon there

VOTE: Titus
Don't think she has any interest in solving the game tbh

I'm wondering whether Ircher was just told by

someone

while at E-1 "hey can you start hard pushing Titus?". Just a theory, but I'd like to maybe get some comment from Ircher on this - was your initial vote's logic the same as given by Meuh (not solving)? Was there more at the time?

[Ircher]

It was similar in spirit.

[furtiveglance]

VOTE: Ircher

Going to OMGUS a vote for some VCA too.

Was this the offending post?

[Gamma Emerald]

lolwut

I think you forgot I'm a broccoli for a second there.

No
I just think it’s odd you want someone else to start a fresh wagon rather than doing it yourself.

[Gamma Emerald]

Town

Broccoli
Andante

Null

Everyone not listed.

Scum

Titus

vrej

Btw I feel decent about furrtive rn