Mini Normal 2316 | Halloween | Endgame

[Black]

I was looking for any indication that 26, 28, and 30 were real thoughts but I don't think I'm going to get that

Do you think we'd make "non-real" thoughts as scum there?

-A

I think you could, yeah. It's a little bit different but one of your first posts in F&I was asking mala who her scum partner was because you were suspicious of her. You are more than capable of faking a thought as scum here imo

[Black]

I vibe with Black's entrance here.

What does your readslist look like?

[SmileyDude1]

I vibe with Black's entrance here.

What does your readslist look like?

UsesPython, TheHoldSteady- Townreads
Black, OutWorldER, TheStatusQuo- Town Leans
Roden, AnimatedWiz, Wartortle, Hu Tao, Blackstar, Enchant- Null tier
Naerys -Scum Lean

Have to leave for work in a second, but i'd say this is about where i'm at right now. This is somewhat ordered (though some placements are near interchangeable for me).

[BlackStar]

I like the posts that Black has made so far. The logic seems consistent and she’s putting in effort to figure people out.

Thestatusquo’s push on Wartortle because they think he’s lying about playing forum mafia feels weird.

And I wish that Enchant would dial down the trolling by like 20% lol

That is not the only thing I said about Wartortle. Nor was it the most important.

You said that he has a lot of takes that seem to go nowhere but you’ve spent more time talking about his his experience level, so I thought you cared more about that

[Wartortle]

Ok I have read the remaining pages

AnimatedWizard [4] : OutWorldER, Hu Tao, BlackStar, Roden

I think Annie feels pretty townie this game and I hate this wagon composition. OWER has been fine I think but I haven't liked much from the other 3 slots here. Hu Tao isn't doing anything, BlackStar seems to just be pushing things along in a really agenda driven way and I think his vote is the worst on the wagon, and then DE70 has pinged me quite a bit this game. With DE70 though I think I'm willing to hold off there for now. I have a history of not really liking his posts ever so I need to check my bias there

I would be ok voting for Hu/BS, but I think I want to sheep Shea right now. I agree that something feels off about about Wartortle. I don't like how he has interacted with the game so far and his townread on Wiz feels a little too on-the-fence for me with the constant repeating of how baffling his posts feel and how he could be newbscum. 333 doesn't feel good either

VOTE: Wartortle

yeah my read on ani is fence-sitty cuz i can’t read him but i was also p strongly townreading him earlier

Doesn't really seem like it to me

81 you said his post was "absolutely transparent scum buddying"
You ride the fence in 82
In 184 you said "Wiz could be scum" was the "least spicy take I have seen in my life"
186 you give a definitive "Wiz is town" for some reason
In 333 you say you don't know Annie well so you're down to vote for him, despite townreading him?
You ride the fence more in 364

To me your read here seems really flip-floppy and not in a natural townie way trying to figure him out. It feels like you have an agenda

what’s the difference between being flip floppy and being town trying to figure ani out when i don’t have a good read on him

[Naerys]

I am not scum lol, stop pushing me smiley

[Wartortle]

Spoiler:

I think I'm leaning scum for you here

Hmmm. A quick skim over Steady's scum game here and I'm not seeing many similarities. I'm not going to rule out the possibility of Steady!scum based on a meta read but his play here seems less involved and thoughtful, like maybe he's more of a tryhard as scum? Would like to read a town game of his next

Steady's town game here feels more in line with his behavior this game. Slightly defensive, frustrated, annoyed. In his scum game it felt like he was more level-headed and played a type of mediator role. Obviously this doesn't mean much since I think good players can mimic their town game as scum, but I felt like pointing it out

Hmmm. A quick skim over Steady's scum game here and I'm not seeing many similarities. I'm not going to rule out the possibility of Steady!scum based on a meta read but his play here seems less involved and thoughtful, like maybe he's more of a tryhard as scum? Would like to read a town game of his next

I probably shouldn't be like this, but I'm pissy about being misread because in 1092 I had generally accurate reads but couldn't get enough grip on the game state because people wouldn't stop calling me scum

I understand this feeling and I get this way as town sometimes. This feels genuine enough

I think I'm comfortable leaning slightly town on you with this new information in my head

I like this progression

i do too and THS and probably Black are town for it - it doesn’t look like a pocket attempt either

[Wartortle]

I am not scum lol, stop pushing me smiley

smiley’s scum lean on you was hardly a push. he voted you on page 11 and barely mentioned you for 8 more pages until he put you as a scum lean in his readlist.

this is scum.

VOTE: naerys

[Naerys]

No u

[usesPython]

I am not scum lol, stop pushing me smiley

Welcome back

VOTE: Naerys

[Black]

No u

Wanna join us on the Wartortle wagon?

[Black]

Python what was the point of 441? Do you have a read on Wartortle?

[usesPython]

Python what was the point of 441? Do you have a read on Wartortle?

The big fights've been kinda hard to follow for us so we're just pointing out stuff that stuck out to us until people are done

[Black]

What big fights?

You don't have any read on Wartortle this game?

[usesPython]

What big fights?

You don't have any read on Wartortle this game?

We vibed with his early posting and then kinda mentally checked out from the game once the Wiz/DE walls started happening

[Thestatusquo]

I like the posts that Black has made so far. The logic seems consistent and she’s putting in effort to figure people out.

Thestatusquo’s push on Wartortle because they think he’s lying about playing forum mafia feels weird.

And I wish that Enchant would dial down the trolling by like 20% lol

That is not the only thing I said about Wartortle. Nor was it the most important.

You said that he has a lot of takes that seem to go nowhere but you’ve spent more time talking about his his experience level, so I thought you cared more about that

This doesn't seem like the post of someone who is actually interested in evaluating my thoughts. Like ok maybe you missed it or maybe you thought that the only thing that matters is 'what someone talks about the most.' Which is kind of Bizarre way to play Mafia to begin with, but you still don't engage with that thought in any way in this post.

Like if you were interested in evaluating my positions why would you post this sort of weird defense of yourself rather than actually talk about the argument I made?

This post just seems extremely self conscious.

[usesPython]

What big fights?

You don't have any read on Wartortle this game?

We vibed with his early posting and then kinda mentally checked out from the game once the Wiz/DE walls started happening

Just realised that even if people start posting about new stuff it's still gonna be in relation to the reactions to those walls and we'll still have to read the original walls

pain

-A

[BlackStar]

I like the posts that Black has made so far. The logic seems consistent and she’s putting in effort to figure people out.

Thestatusquo’s push on Wartortle because they think he’s lying about playing forum mafia feels weird.

And I wish that Enchant would dial down the trolling by like 20% lol

That is not the only thing I said about Wartortle. Nor was it the most important.

You said that he has a lot of takes that seem to go nowhere but you’ve spent more time talking about his his experience level, so I thought you cared more about that

This doesn't seem like the post of someone who is actually interested in evaluating my thoughts. Like ok maybe you missed it or maybe you thought that the only thing that matters is 'what someone talks about the most.' Which is kind of Bizarre way to play Mafia to begin with, but you still don't engage with that thought in any way in this post.

Like if you were interested in evaluating my positions why would you post this sort of weird defense of yourself rather than actually talk about the argument I made?

This post just seems extremely self conscious.

"This feels weird" was the evaluation. You're saying stuff like "cut the crap" to him and accusing him of lying, so why would I not think that you thought his experience level was an important point? You haven't spent any time grilling him on his "endless takes" to try and find out what he believes. I don't see how anything that I said was self-conscious.

[BlackStar]

@Roden

Have you had a chance to get caught up yet?

[AnimatedWiz]

We vibed with his early posting and then kinda mentally checked out from the game once the Wiz/DE walls started happening

Just realised that even if people start posting about new stuff it's still gonna be in relation to the reactions to those walls and we'll still have to read the original walls

pain

-A

This makes sense to me, personally—at a certain point when I was deep in the walling, I realized I needed to pull away a bit or I was going to just fully sap everyone of our mental energy, me included. I totally see a townie saying this.

[Thestatusquo]

I like the posts that Black has made so far. The logic seems consistent and she’s putting in effort to figure people out.

Thestatusquo’s push on Wartortle because they think he’s lying about playing forum mafia feels weird.

And I wish that Enchant would dial down the trolling by like 20% lol

That is not the only thing I said about Wartortle. Nor was it the most important.

You said that he has a lot of takes that seem to go nowhere but you’ve spent more time talking about his his experience level, so I thought you cared more about that

This doesn't seem like the post of someone who is actually interested in evaluating my thoughts. Like ok maybe you missed it or maybe you thought that the only thing that matters is 'what someone talks about the most.' Which is kind of Bizarre way to play Mafia to begin with, but you still don't engage with that thought in any way in this post.

Like if you were interested in evaluating my positions why would you post this sort of weird defense of yourself rather than actually talk about the argument I made?

This post just seems extremely self conscious.

"This feels weird" was the evaluation. You're saying stuff like "cut the crap" to him and accusing him of lying, so why would I not think that you thought his experience level was an important point? You haven't spent any time grilling him on his "endless takes" to try and find out what he believes. I don't see how anything that I said was self-conscious.

Even this post fails to actually engage with my argument about how he seems to lack follow through so I'm gonna just continue to ask what you think about it until you actually answer?

[BlackStar]

I like the posts that Black has made so far. The logic seems consistent and she’s putting in effort to figure people out.

Thestatusquo’s push on Wartortle because they think he’s lying about playing forum mafia feels weird.

And I wish that Enchant would dial down the trolling by like 20% lol

That is not the only thing I said about Wartortle. Nor was it the most important.

You said that he has a lot of takes that seem to go nowhere but you’ve spent more time talking about his his experience level, so I thought you cared more about that

This doesn't seem like the post of someone who is actually interested in evaluating my thoughts. Like ok maybe you missed it or maybe you thought that the only thing that matters is 'what someone talks about the most.' Which is kind of Bizarre way to play Mafia to begin with, but you still don't engage with that thought in any way in this post.

Like if you were interested in evaluating my positions why would you post this sort of weird defense of yourself rather than actually talk about the argument I made?

This post just seems extremely self conscious.

"This feels weird" was the evaluation. You're saying stuff like "cut the crap" to him and accusing him of lying, so why would I not think that you thought his experience level was an important point? You haven't spent any time grilling him on his "endless takes" to try and find out what he believes. I don't see how anything that I said was self-conscious.

Even this post fails to actually engage with my argument about how he seems to lack follow through so I'm gonna just continue to ask what you think about it until you actually answer?

He’s bringing up points about people and then voting for them. It seems like he’s following through to me.

[Thestatusquo]

Does it seem to you like he's actually trying to make the lims he wants happen?

[Dannflor]

please don't steal

[Dannflor]

my pagetop