In post 3323, jjh927 wrote:
My biggest concern on Fire is that Ali said he was within his scum range on day 1 and to be quite honest I don't really know what scum!fire looks like but I thought he was town then and I still do
Do you agree with my analysis at all about the off-wagon pool (Ydrasse Fire You Andres)
Like if you look at other games youll find the stuff i said rings true. 1-2 wolf on main wagon and then 1-2 off main wagon. its just how mafia end up playing.
I think that pool is really likely to hit scum. Its possible Im wrong on Fire and Andres and its Ydrasse or you but at this point ive made my decision.
I think that what your analysis is based off is a statistical likelihood due to the nature of groups and does not tell you anything about any game in context. It will not provide you with information that will give you above chance reads
If you aren't going to actually engage with the context then you are a lost cause
"As best I can tell, jjh is some kind of wizard with mind control powers." -Jingle
Well here, I've just quoted a bunch of quotes for you. There are more posts worth highlighting than this but I didn't want to basically quote half the posts on page 84
In post 2069, gob wrote:
WOULD LIM
Camel
T3
JJH
Imaginality
Andres
Scum?
Save The Dragons
camelCasedSnivy
Shirou
Titus
camel is the one who is in both of your lists. I also saw Prism scumreading Camel before. I've felt camel was solvey day 1. This past day though I feel like they have just been messing around.
With the way this game is designed I see Titus's push today as trying to get me mislimmed knowing she can skip town tonight so it doesn't matter how bad she looks after I flip town.
In post 2084, Ydrasse wrote:
UNVOTE:
going to reread soon, don’t feel so keen about this vote anymore
titus v imaginality could be s/s but that doesn’t feel right rn
In post 2090, jjh927 wrote:
There's just kinda
a lot of the people I am referring to as sheepie sleepies and each day you don't know which one of them is going to pop up and make a post that says nothing
If we start compromising to form wagons then some of them might start making naked votes, but I think that just takes us back to how we got the Alisae elimination
I'm gonna hold fast on Camel. No compromising from me
In post 3329, jjh927 wrote:
I literally just pointed you to some very juicy voting data that you've told me you don't remember and you're like "nah I don't want to read 2 pages"
I want to reiterate that my preference is Andres->imaginality. I am with jjh on not voting Firebringer. My reasoning is very different from gob's, but if jjh isn't willing to vote imaginality at all, then again maybe we can split the difference and put 3 more on Andres.
i’ve been following along and i don’t actually know, i was okay to vote andres for a while and then was whipped around to t3 or dragons but dragons feels like a bad vote to me too. maybe imaginality
i’m probably going to default to “vote with my townreads” whenever there’s a new vc if they’re not split
In post 3344, Ydrasse wrote:
i don’t feel great about this vote but there are few i think i could feel great about atp
Can you explain why you’re voting for me beyond just I’m going to vote with my TRs? Because it seems to me like this is basically going to define whether we win or lose, and you seem to really not care.