Open 891: STDBINSBICACOT (Game Over)

[Black]

So maybe someone neither of us pushed is scum?

Could be Psyche or Alisae just based on this assumption

[Black]

Could also be Dave. What was your read on him D1? I'm not seeing it in 659

[davesaz]

If you're town it's rather important for you that I can TR you.

this was originally directed toward gob, but goes for everyone.

[Dannflor]

I started out scum reading him but later revised him to a town read

okay time to buckle down and actually read this day and see if i can get anything alignment indicative out of it

[Dannflor]

people town leaning gob is weird

i feel like he should be hard town or hard scum lol

[Gamma Emerald]

I have a scum lean there rn because his play isn’t great but after last game I am hesitant to pass a hard judgement either way yet

[Black]

people town leaning gob is weird

i feel like he should be hard town or hard scum lol

Damn I feel called out lol

I still think gob could be scum but I'm willing to give him a pass for now

Gob is operating somewhere between troll and tryhard and he keeps going back and forth between the two. I'm not really sure what to make of that

I still think the cop claim could indicate he's scum with the Informed ability. Or it could just be him not caring about a possible counter claim which is definitely possible

He's hard to read. Why should I hard townread him?

[gob]

I am interested in what Dannflor's read is on me. Seems he hasn't interacted with many of my posts this game.

I am reading you as town

I do not think I am going to get anything out of interacting with you sorry

Shame, anything I can do to make it easier to interact with me?

[Dannflor]

anything that starts with you quoting a VC is not going to be easy for me to engage with

for example your scum read on crescent does nothing for me

[gob]

If you're town it's rather important for you that I can TR you.

this was originally directed toward gob, but goes for everyone.

Yes but im not going to change my play style to accommodate your limited play style.

people town leaning gob is weird

i feel like he should be hard town or hard scum lol

I don't really think so.

I have a scum lean there rn because his play isn’t great but after last game I am hesitant to pass a hard judgement either way yet

Seems like you're fishing for a wagon on me, but don't want to put your foot forward confidently.

[gob]

anything that starts with you quoting a VC is not going to be easy for me to engage with

for example your scum read on crescent does nothing for me

Well just trust my conclusions for VCA if you aren't gonna read them.

How about this, I think Gamma/Crescent has been pretty fence sitty like their last post.

[Dannflor]

@Roden why are you town reading Dave and Something Smart

[Gamma Emerald]

I don’t like to vote before I am reasonably caught up but you can’t have really known that so that interpretation is valid

[Black]

Gob why did you retract your cop claim with the reasoning "no one believed it anyway" when it was pretty clear that at least a few people believed it?

[Dannflor]

i really don't like 841 especially the first line, it feels like davesaz didn't want to actually say anything content wise but felt compelled to say *something* of seeming substance

i don't like 861 because A. I think saying it's not obvious which kill was which feels like feigning ignorance in order to look uninformed whereas I think a townie is just going to make certain assumptions and B. states the obvious

862 comments on gob because I feel like dave feels like he should but doesn't actually SAY anything about Gob

idk gob, you wanna talk about fence sitty?

[gob]

Gob why did you retract your cop claim with the reasoning "no one believed it anyway" when it was pretty clear that at least a few people believed it?

I don't think anyone really believed it. Nobody asked me for my night results or anything.

[Black]

I can't help but read that as you trying to justify why you weren't the NK

[Dannflor]

1111 is weird too and feels out of sync with the game

why am i a top town read despite barely posting today

why is black a top town read and davesaz had basically nothing to say about my spat with black

the read on something_smart is weak sauce and I feel like a townie would have stronger reasons to vote someone at this point in the game then "i don't remember what they posted"

[gob]

I can't help but read that as you trying to justify why you weren't the NK

What? I dont even understand the logic here. Why would I ever have been the NK?

[Black]

I can't help but read that as you trying to justify why you weren't the NK

What? I dont even understand the logic here. Why would I ever have been the NK?

If scum thought you were the cop then it would make sense to take you out no?

[gob]

i really don't like 841 especially the first line, it feels like davesaz didn't want to actually say anything content wise but felt compelled to say *something* of seeming substance

i don't like 861 because A. I think saying it's not obvious which kill was which feels like feigning ignorance in order to look uninformed whereas I think a townie is just going to make certain assumptions and B. states the obvious

862 comments on gob because I feel like dave feels like he should but doesn't actually SAY anything about Gob

idk gob, you wanna talk about fence sitty?

Davesaz has said they think out loud, so it's more passable I guess. I think we can catch davesaz by seeing if he digs himself into a logical hole or starts slanking.

1111 is weird too and feels out of sync with the game

why am i a top town read despite barely posting today

why is black a top town read and davesaz had basically nothing to say about my spat with black

the read on something_smart is weak sauce and I feel like a townie would have stronger reasons to vote someone at this point in the game then "i don't remember what they posted"

I do not like Psyche's slot either, but I think you've posted enough to be read as town. Black has been less towny today but they did lead a lot of discussion day 1.

[gob]

I can't help but read that as you trying to justify why you weren't the NK

What? I dont even understand the logic here. Why would I ever have been the NK?

If scum thought you were the cop then it would make sense to take you out no?

Yes, exactly. Except for doctors and whatnot. But I wasn't attacked.

[Dannflor]

i think gob has far more depth of play in this game than they usually do as scum

it's not impossible they are informed ascetic scum pulling a gambit but i kinda of assume that will become clear with time

[Dannflor]

gob gamma and black are all slots i just wanna town bin and not think about rnow

[Black]

i think gob has far more depth of play in this game than they usually do as scum

it's not impossible they are informed ascetic scum pulling a gambit but i kinda of assume that will become clear with time

This is kinda where I'm at except I don't have much gob meta to go off of. He was scum in the game we played recently but he was caught pretty easily so I could see that causing him to try a little harder this game