Open 891: STDBINSBICACOT (Game Over)

[gob]

I'm one of the best wolfers alive. Just assume I'm town cause if i'm wolf you have no shot of catching me.

Yeah but are you 5-0 like me?

Also gob why do you have no interest in reading Roden? I feel like you should since at least two of your townreads are leaning scum on him

I have read Roden's slot and a good portion of his posts. Just not gonna iso cause i can tell he isn't wolf based on how easily he's been faded by everyone with no defense. He could be traitor I guess, but i would rather hit a real wolf anyways.

The Roden wagon has never gotten more than like 3 votes so I'm not sure what you mean here. Do you expect scum to just openly defend him when there's no real pressure there?

Eh, that is true.
I was not really factoring in the traitor when i was thinking though. With just 2 wolves informed, he isn't really spewed at all.

I still won't scumread Roden though since what I've seen I think has been good. I think Roden is a loner-type player.

[Black]

I still won't scumread Roden though since what I've seen I think has been good. I think Roden is a loner-type player.

What specifically have you seen from Roden that you like

[gob]

Unless gob is GF or ascetic informed, why would he bait the cop?

Actually mafia have reason to try to draw out the cop if they didn't choose ascetic informed.
If they did choose it and town didn't roll it, then they can fakeclaim it with impunity because they know there won't be a counter claim.

I still have gob as pretty much a null enigma. I'm unwilling to just ignore the fake(?) claim like so many have appeared to.

You should've paid more attention to it when it was in play. As a dead piece it's just a waste of time.

[gob]

I still won't scumread Roden though since what I've seen I think has been good. I think Roden is a loner-type player.

What specifically have you seen from Roden that you like

Fr? you want me to go back and look and shit?

[Black]

I still won't scumread Roden though since what I've seen I think has been good. I think Roden is a loner-type player.

What specifically have you seen from Roden that you like

Fr? you want me to go back and look and shit?

I mean yes, but should you really have to go back and look if this is an opinion you have?

Earlier you said you don't townread him but you don't think he's scum based on people pushing him and him not getting much defense. Now you are suddenly saying what you have seen from him looks good?

[gob]

I still won't scumread Roden though since what I've seen I think has been good. I think Roden is a loner-type player.

What specifically have you seen from Roden that you like

Fr? you want me to go back and look and shit?

I mean yes, but should you really have to go back and look if this is an opinion you have?

Earlier you said you don't townread him but you don't think he's scum based on people pushing him and him not getting much defense. Now you are suddenly saying what you have seen from him looks good?

I have said before from what I saw from Roden looked good. But the majority of my read is from the gamestate against him. I originally scumread him, but then I felt I only scumread him because of his avatar. Then I started townreading him based on how the game was progressing (he's gotten the most shade of any player i think). However, what you said does make me rethink it.

I thought you were asking me to go back and ISO Roden and quote his posts.

[Dannflor]

VOTE: something_smart

im fine with this

[Dannflor]

ill just vote whoever in [something_smart, roden, davesaz]

[gob]

VOTE: something_smart

I can get behind this.

[gob]

Always almost accidentally calling Roden Rodent or Roman

[Taly]

dann, dave, and black

compose a tier of townreads for me

not a fan of

gamma

entrance but then again, i havent read it all, or much of the last 4 pages

as for

crescent

,

black

, i didnt really skim them critically when i did it last night, but i found them to be hyper aggressive and very critical of everything my predecessor did so all i think about

crescent

was

"detriment"

, i need to reread to think its NAI but i think

gamma

is an easier read.

[gob]

TALY thank goodness you returned. Now we can really get started.

[Taly]

Lmao I can't tell if you're being sarcastic or earnest or if that's a dig

[Taly]

SS

is not in the top 3 places I'd vote rn but I'm curious to hear why the wagon exists

[Dannflor]

why is dave a town read for you taly

[Gamma Emerald]

Dave you have been pretty quiet wrt Roden. What are your thoughts on his slot?

As far as I can tell, I haven't had thoughts about him specifically. I disliked it when someone pushed him because that push felt fake.

Davesaz is town here. I can tell.

I agree w this

[Roden]

VOTE: Black

[Taly]

Tone. Not a convincing read. I don't get the impression they have an agenda or are dwyaing people intentionally in any certain direction.

Why do you scumread

dave

?

[Roden]

Also after looking back, I find it funny that Black is riding Dunn's last minute read on me so hard even though she hard scum read him and kept arguing with him for the entire Day phase.

Like this is so far from the truth and it implies that Roden isn't paying attention to my slot at all. Normally I feel like this type of misrep would more likely come from town but this post comes right after Alisae starts mulling over whether or not I could be scum and it just feels like shade to push that thought forward

Are you seriously trying to argue that my post has suspicious timing when I've been consistently arguing that your takes have been bad for most of the game

Also I have no idea how you have the gall to claim "misrep" when you DID scum read Dunn and you DID argue with and discredit him throughout Day 1

[Dannflor]

Tone. Not a convincing read. I don't get the impression they have an agenda or are dwyaing people intentionally in any certain direction.

Why do you scumread

dave

?

1189 1192

[Taly]

Roden

you noted

Titus/Black

were TvT early in the game and several posts henceafter show you think otherwise. Can you explain thay progression?

[Dannflor]

roden

i feel like you are arguing that black's arguments are bad rather than arguing that black is scum

[Roden]

the roden slot I just don't like how they treated titus and the "omg titus has been obv scum since 24 hours since the game started" still rings as so fake in my mind

Ok and for what gain, exactly? The other slots that were taking heat flipped town.

[Roden]

roden

i feel like you are arguing that black's arguments are bad rather than arguing that black is scum

Scum can make bad arguments my dude

[Taly]

Idk I don't really take issue with any of the posts you mentioned of

Dave

but i can do a second look