In post 1735, BlackStar wrote:
All the talk right now is about roles and what is and isn't possible and I don't know how any of that works. I guess I'll just go through the wikis or something
I feel like if you were town here then you would still be trying to solve outside of the mech talk. You don't really need to engage with the mech at all imo
How? If people were saying that they didn't understand something that I said then I could try to defend myself. But since nobody is saying anything to that effect, I don't have anything to work with. Half the votes on me have been placed without reasons and the other half are just people saying they don't think I'm the bodyguard. That's not enough information for me to try to decipher intentions
In post 1735, BlackStar wrote:
All the talk right now is about roles and what is and isn't possible and I don't know how any of that works. I guess I'll just go through the wikis or something
Don't you have 3.4k posts on this site? How would you not know about common Normal roles like Jailkeeper/JOAT/Bulletproof/Watcher?
I've been gone for like 5 years. Even before the break my eyes would glass over whenever people would start talking about this stuff
My favorite moment of game where Black writes me as investigator, someone tells "but investigator was joke" and Black tells "oh" And still keeps me as investigator.
Wizard-Mercenary
You need replacement/players ASAP? PM me! I almost always accept.
In post 1750, BlackStar wrote:
How? If people were saying that they didn't understand something that I said then I could try to defend myself. But since nobody is saying anything to that effect, I don't have anything to work with. Half the votes on me have been placed without reasons and the other half are just people saying they don't think I'm the bodyguard. That's not enough information for me to try to decipher intentions
You have like 65 pages of non-mech stuff to work with. I don't understand this logic
In post 1751, Enchant wrote:
My favorite moment of game where Black writes me as investigator, someone tells "but investigator was joke" and Black tells "oh" And still keeps me as investigator.
In post 1751, Enchant wrote:
My favorite moment of game where Black writes me as investigator, someone tells "but investigator was joke" and Black tells "oh" And still keeps me as investigator.
Yeah I updated the list to incorporate Shea's VT claim but I forgot to remove your joke claim
Posting a read list from yesterday before all claims and night actions were revealed rather than just putting in the work to try to figure out a new one does feel a bit anti-spewy to me.
In post 1706, AnimatedWiz wrote:
BlackStar, if I could ask, why did your read on Smiley change between 530 and 992? You never mentioned wanting to vote for Smiley during the beginning of D2, even when you responded to Enchant voting for him in 848.
I just looked at the votes at the end of D1 and tried to decide who seemed the most like scum. I looked at the people off the wagon first because I figured at least one of the scum would've been off of it and since there were fewer people off the wagon, it might be easier to narrow down who was suspicious.
I was town reading THS and Roden, so that left you and Hu Tao. Hu Tao seemed pretty much the same to me as the last game we played together where she was town, but she wasn't posting that much so I felt a little bit wary of her. That just left you and I didn't see much from your iso that would make me want to trust you. I didn't want to start tunneling you and being a jerk though, so I kept looking at everyone else.
I feel like your reasoning here for voting me is really off from what you’ve stated previously about your reads on me—in the past, you said it was about how I seemed on the fence, like I was looking for group approval, and that I was acting similarly to my previous scum game. If it’s now just process of elimination out of those not on the Wartortle wagon, I feel like the story isn’t matching up properly.
Moreover, I’m unsure why you’re so concerned about your push on me when that’s not really been addressed at all today—it feels to me like you’re trying to preemptively defend against that line of questioning. It feels… performative?
Hi, I'm Annie! Please have patience with me—I am disabled.
In post 1706, AnimatedWiz wrote:
BlackStar, if I could ask, why did your read on Smiley change between 530 and 992? You never mentioned wanting to vote for Smiley during the beginning of D2, even when you responded to Enchant voting for him in 848.
I just looked at the votes at the end of D1 and tried to decide who seemed the most like scum. I looked at the people off the wagon first because I figured at least one of the scum would've been off of it and since there were fewer people off the wagon, it might be easier to narrow down who was suspicious.
I was town reading THS and Roden, so that left you and Hu Tao. Hu Tao seemed pretty much the same to me as the last game we played together where she was town, but she wasn't posting that much so I felt a little bit wary of her. That just left you and I didn't see much from your iso that would make me want to trust you. I didn't want to start tunneling you and being a jerk though, so I kept looking at everyone else.
I feel like your reasoning here for voting me is really off from what you’ve stated previously about your reads on me—in the past,
you said it was about how I seemed on the fence, like I was looking for group approval, and that I was acting similarly to my previous scum game. If it’s now just process of elimination out of those not on the Wartortle wagon, I feel like the story isn’t matching up properly.
Moreover, I’m unsure why you’re so concerned about your push on me when that’s not really been addressed at all today—it feels to me like you’re trying to preemptively defend against that line of questioning. It feels… performative?
It's both. And I'm not concerned about the push, I was explaining my entire thought process leading up to wanting to vote for Smiley
Can one of the townies on BlackStar's wagon unvote? Just temporarily. If Annie is scum here then he's gearing up to vote there and BlackStar will just hammer and end the day short
In post 1762, Black wrote:
Can one of the townies on BlackStar's wagon unvote? Just temporarily. If Annie is scum here then he's gearing up to vote there and BlackStar will just hammer and end the day short
UNVOTE: BlackStar
Plural | Nameless (They/He) and Alice (She/Her) and C (They/Them) and more
In post 1762, Black wrote:
Can one of the townies on BlackStar's wagon unvote? Just temporarily. If Annie is scum here then he's gearing up to vote there and BlackStar will just hammer and end the day short
Do you think I’m a partner with BlackStar?
Hi, I'm Annie! Please have patience with me—I am disabled.
In post 1762, Black wrote:
Can one of the townies on BlackStar's wagon unvote? Just temporarily. If Annie is scum here then he's gearing up to vote there and BlackStar will just hammer and end the day short
Do you think I’m a partner with BlackStar?
I think you could be yeah. I'm less confident in this than OWER/Naerys but I don't want to risk it
In post 1762, Black wrote:
Can one of the townies on BlackStar's wagon unvote? Just temporarily. If Annie is scum here then he's gearing up to vote there and BlackStar will just hammer and end the day short
Do you think I’m a partner with BlackStar?
I think you could be yeah. I'm less confident in this than OWER/Naerys but I don't want to risk it
Are you planning on voting for BlackStar?
No, honestly. I don’t want D3 to end quickly, and I also feel like other slots have a better reasons behind them—the OWER/Roden partner dynamic is more convincing for me right now.
Hi, I'm Annie! Please have patience with me—I am disabled.
