Mini Normal 2316 | Halloween | Endgame

[BlackStar]

This was the reads list I made when D2 ended, but I need to reread all the stuff from this day to see where I stand now

Town

Thestatusquo
usesPython
Enchant

Town Lean

Black

Null

TheHoldSteady
Roden

Scum Lean

OutworldER
Naerys

Scum

Smiley
AnimatedWiz

My top town read was thestatusquo or theholdsteady

Look who's at the top: thestatusquo. Black was talking about the majority of the game. If you look through the reads lists I've posted, you'll see THS near the top of most of them before that

[usesPython]

Look who's at the top: thestatusquo. Black was talking about the majority of the game. If you look through the reads lists I've posted, you'll see THS near the top of most of them before that

Blacks point is that we're also on the top

[Black]

Why did THS drop to null then if your TR was so strong there

[BlackStar]

Look who's at the top: thestatusquo. Black was talking about the majority of the game. If you look through the reads lists I've posted, you'll see THS near the top of most of them before that

Blacks point is that we're also on the top

She said that I had you at the very top throughout the game and that's not true.

[Black]

THS being null feels like you and the scumteam were preparing to push him today, or at some point. I don't think it's a coincidence that both Naerys and OWER shaded THS today as well

Damn scum really fucked up by leaving me alive. I feel like I'm on fire

*cut to postgame where I was completely wrong about everything*

[BlackStar]

Why did THS drop to null then if your TR was so strong there

He hammered Hu Tao and then both he and Wiz immediately seemed doubtful about if Hu Tao was actually scum, so I was suspicious

[BlackStar]

THS being null feels like you and the scumteam were preparing to push him today, or at some point. I don't think it's a coincidence that both Naerys and OWER shaded THS today as well

Damn scum really fucked up by leaving me alive. I feel like I'm on fire

*cut to postgame where I was completely wrong about everything*

If you're town then I hope you apologize if I get limmed

[Black]

Talk to me about your OWER and Naerys null reads

[Black]

Oh you moved them both to scum leans actually, I didn't see that. Why?

[AnimatedWiz]

Why did THS drop to null then if your TR was so strong there

He hammered Hu Tao and then both he and Wiz immediately seemed doubtful about if Hu Tao was actually scum, so I was suspicious

Doubtful, no. Wanting to get the readslist from Hu Tao I had asked for repeatedly throughout the game? Yes.

[Black]

I guess this would be a little more accurate

Town

TheHoldSteady
Thestatusquo
Roden
Enchant
usesPython

Town Lean

Black

Null

OutworldER, Naerys (same level)

Hu Tao

Scum Lean

AnimatedWiz

Scum

Smiley

I think python being scum is a possibility here but I don't particularly like BlackStar's response to being wagoned

In Mini Normal 2313 BlackStar was much more engaged and inquisitive as he was being run up. It felt like he was considering who was scum pushing him there and I'm not getting any of that here. Instead it feels like he wants to say as little as possible and isn't doing much other than answering softball questions from Annie

@BlackStar can we get a readlist from you

I was engaged because people were asking me nonstop questions. All the conversation right now is about speculation. Nobody is directly interacting with me, so there's not much for me to comment on.

This was the reads list I made when D2 ended, but I need to reread all the stuff from this day to see where I stand now

Town

Thestatusquo
usesPython
Enchant

Town Lean

Black

Null

TheHoldSteady
Roden

Scum Lean

OutworldER
Naerys

Scum

Smiley
AnimatedWiz

[AnimatedWiz]

Also, I would like to posit the theory that we *do* have a Mafia Roleblocker, and that a claimed VT (Roden or OWER, especially) has that role. It would likely be a way to balance out the many protective roles—perhaps partnered with a (gated?) Cop of some sort to get the info about who they should target

[Dannflor]

VC 3.1

Bloody Mary

BlackStar [3]:

OutWorldER, Roden, Naerys

usesPython [2]:

TheHoldSteady, BlackStar

Not Voting [6]:

SmileyDude1, AnimatedWiz, Enchant, Black, Thestatusquo, usesPython

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to eliminate. Day 3 ends in (expired on 2023-11-21 17:35:22).

Mod Notes:

[AnimatedWiz]

Also, I would like to posit the theory that we

do

have a Mafia Roleblocker, and that a claimed VT (Roden or OWER, especially) has that role. It would likely be a way to balance out the many protective roles—perhaps partnered with a (gated?) Cop of some sort to get the info about who they should target?

EBWOP (for proper style).

[Black]

Also, I would like to posit the theory that we *do* have a Mafia Roleblocker, and that a claimed VT (Roden or OWER, especially) has that role. It would likely be a way to balance out the many protective roles—perhaps partnered with a (gated?) Cop of some sort to get the info about who they should target

My only issue with this is that OWER and Roden both claimed VT without knowing who I watched. So if one of them is the RB and they blocked someone (THS?) then it would be pretty risky not to claim something that targets people

I still think OWER being untrackable or something like that makes more sense

[AnimatedWiz]

Also, I would like to posit the theory that we *do* have a Mafia Roleblocker, and that a claimed VT (Roden or OWER, especially) has that role. It would likely be a way to balance out the many protective roles—perhaps partnered with a (gated?) Cop of some sort to get the info about who they should target

My only issue with this is that OWER and Roden both claimed VT without knowing who I watched. So if one of them is the RB and they blocked someone (THS?) then it would be pretty risky not to claim something that targets people

I still think OWER being untrackable or something like that makes more sense

If I recall correctly, the only normal modifier that would have that power is Ascetic, and the only normal role is Commuter—either would be easy claims to make if they were true and town. I feel like Commuter is really, really uncommon, and Ascetic would be kind of useless in a town with two very gated investigative roles—such a low chance of either role doing anything but blocking protection, right?

[Black]

If I recall correctly, the only normal modifier that would have that power is Ascetic, and the only normal role is Commuter—either would be easy claims to make if they were true and town. I feel like Commuter is really, really uncommon, and Ascetic would be kind of useless in a town with two very gated investigative roles—such a low chance of either role doing anything but blocking protection, right?

I am absolutely the wrong person to ask XD

[AnimatedWiz]

Additionally, I feel like there’s little reason to hide either of those options, as neither would be too suspicious on their own—but there is a reason to hide being a Roleblocker, as it’s not generally an Town-aligned role.

[usesPython]

If not a Mafia RB then maybe OWER is some type of scum role that prevents themselves from being investigated/watched

Normal roles that would let you do that:

• Alien (role)
  
• Ascetic
  
• Commuter
  
• Rolestopper

[AnimatedWiz]

Ah, thanks—I was focused on the roles that OWER could have that would prevent himself from being tracked, but a Rolestopper or Alien could be possible.

I just don’t think either of those two is likely to be here due to them

also

being protective roles, y’know? Additionally, since both aren’t more common with Mafia, I don’t think there’s a reason to not claim such role.

[BlackStar]

Oh you moved them both to scum leans actually, I didn't see that. Why?

Naerys was on both mis-lims and it doesn’t feel like she’s really doing anything. Out of the people who were off the D2 wagon, I trust OWER the least so that’s why I dropped him to a scum lean.

[Naerys]

Naerys was on both mis-lims

So was Python,Smiley and Enchant. Content wise i am not exactly excelling i agree.

[Enchant]

Remind me who we killed first

[Black]

im dead why the fuck would i fakeclaim

You missed point.

what fucking point???

Also vanilla cop suck

i can find villagers how is that useless

You mistaked with Neopolitan.

that's ice cream bro what the fuck

This is probably the funniest post in the game

[Black]

Maybe Wartortle was just right about Naerys