Mini Normal 2317 - Postgame

[biancospino]

3.04

Votecount 3.04

Taly (2): Chell, Sleepy Dragon
Doctor drew (1): gob

Not Voting (5): Taly, Titus, camelCasedSnivy, Naerys, Doctor Drew

With 8 players alive, it takes 5 votes to secure an execution or 4 to secure a no-execution.

The day deadline is in (expired on 2023-12-10 22:05:16).

[camelCasedSnivy]

what is gob doing

[Doctor Drew]

what is gob doing

Finally we agree on something here lol

[Naerys]

Gobity gob, i suppose

[Naerys]

Gob why should we pick that over guilty on taly slot

[Sleepy Dragon]

It honestly seems unbelievable to me, but idk. It's possible SD is bussing but it just doesn't make sense to me why SD would check Taly.

Maybe because Taly was the only claimed VT? Maybe because Bingle, my other option, died? Maybe because Snivy, my other other option, softed PR?

[Sleepy Dragon]

what is gob doing

probably openwolfing but possibly just being terrible town

I think we can all agree that Chell should not watch gob tonight.

[Sleepy Dragon]

I'll show my work like it's school. This is what I'm working with and why I made the decisions I made. However if I went by purely gut I would go Titus here.

I'm waiting.

[Sleepy Dragon]

Doctor Drew, NewPerson/Taly/Khaos, Titus, Sleepy Dragon

This four contains scum, for sure.

I think it's between Titus and Sleepy. The fact Sleepy hasn't been gunning for Titus makes me think its both of them, frankly.

VOTE: Titus

I am actually also okay with limming the Taly slot, just because I also think that slot/Drew also most likely contains a wolf.

That is actually better to lim in, realistically. It's possible all maf were on Bingle's wagon, but I doubt it.

VOTE: Drew

But I seriously feel like Titus is mafia here. She hasn't really been progressing the game forward at all, which I think is more like her wolf game. She's been more in the background this game than any other game I've played with her before. Can't shake the feeling she's mafia basically.

I think Sleepy looks really bad, especially with what Bingle said, but I sorta idk feel like he's town still lol.

Okay I think I misread this. Are you saying you think all three scum are in sleepy/Taly/Titus/Drew?

[Sleepy Dragon]

I kinda get why you scumread Titus, but if you think Taly is likely to flip scum and I have a guilty there, why are you voting Drew then?

[Sleepy Dragon]

= Taly / Drew = 50/50 (both were conveniently on the Element's wag day 1). Has 1-2 mafia.
= Sleepy Dragon, Snivy, Naerys, Chell, Titus = 1-3 mafia.

I am NOT going to say everything you just said is bullshit just because of this, but I hope you do see the math doesn't check out. I assume you mean the second list has 1-2 maf?

[Naerys]

= Taly / Drew = 50/50 (both were conveniently on the Element's wag day 1). Has 1-2 mafia.
= Sleepy Dragon, Snivy, Naerys, Chell, Titus = 1-3 mafia.

I am NOT going to say everything you just said is bullshit just because of this, but I hope you do see the math doesn't check out. I assume you mean the second list has 1-2 maf?

Well pointed out. Do you think gob could be a scum? Or is this town!gob thing

[Titus]

While I am 90% sure Sleepy is town, I feel like no lim is still the best answer. Let a bullet decide who is right. It's melo not elo.

[Sleepy Dragon]

= Taly / Drew = 50/50 (both were conveniently on the Element's wag day 1). Has 1-2 mafia.
= Sleepy Dragon, Snivy, Naerys, Chell, Titus = 1-3 mafia.

I am NOT going to say everything you just said is bullshit just because of this, but I hope you do see the math doesn't check out. I assume you mean the second list has 1-2 maf?

Well pointed out. Do you think gob could be a scum? Or is this town!gob thing

Why is that scum indicative for gob? Serious question

While I am 90% sure Sleepy is town, I feel like no lim is still the best answer. Let a bullet decide who is right. It's melo not elo.

The only thing a no-elimination achieves right now is losing either you or a PR. How does that help anyone?

[Sleepy Dragon]

I think no eliminating TOMORROW might have some merit. Today we should vote Taly, the person you pushed to kill all of yesterday.

[gob]

Gob why should we pick that over guilty on taly slot

Either is fine. I just chose drew since Taly slot isnt around

[gob]

It honestly seems unbelievable to me, but idk. It's possible SD is bussing but it just doesn't make sense to me why SD would check Taly.

Maybe because Taly was the only claimed VT? Maybe because Bingle, my other option, died? Maybe because Snivy, my other other option, softed PR?

Doesnt really make sense to me but whatever.

[Sleepy Dragon]

I kinda hate this game state tbh

I have townread every living slot except Taly at one point in the game. And every time I try to say "yeah this slot ia probably town and that one is probably scum", I immediately go "but why? Hasn't the other slot also done townie things"

And then I don't know what to do

So I really really really need someone to die

Actually maybe Titus is right, I don't think scum just kills me tonight if we no elim because that condemns Taly slot, and the kill should tell us SOMETHING about SOMEONE.

OTOH, blergh. Scum might kill my best townread and then I would be REALLY lost.

[gob]

i love this game state cause its tough

[Sleepy Dragon]

gob can you just vote Taly already? Like worst thing that happens is my scumbuddies quickhammer, but for real bro, that is such a small downside for not having to wait forever.

[Naerys]

VOTE: Taly

[gob]

gob can you just vote Taly already? Like worst thing that happens is my scumbuddies quickhammer, but for real bro, that is such a small downside for not having to wait forever.

Arent you admitting to being scum here? lol

[gob]

We definitely shouldnt hammer early at all. Why would you say that in a game state where town clearly doesnt have control.

[Chell]

UNVOTE:

[Chell]

I don't think we lose anything by waiting for a replacement to potentially spew alignments