In post 173, Black wrote:
I will take your personality into consideration. That seems like it could be a viable explanation
I also considered your tinfoil theory too. I don't think it's that crazy of an idea that Cook noticed she wasn't hammered and played it up for the town cred. I'm actually worried about that myself
Can you tell me what you don't like about Claptastik's posts?
I just, don't think scum!gob plays a fake hammer this way. It's a bad reason to call someone conf, but I just can't help but feel that gob, as scum, would see your E-1 and either think you were deliberately reaction testing there or simply just, play it in a different way? I don't know quite what I expect gob's "scum fake-hammer" to look like, I just don't think that was it.
Claptastik's push on Elements feels really lazy and 100 pings me as really weird for how early in the game it was made.
In post 38, gob wrote:
Honestly limming me here might be the most optimal play
Because I am town, and if the mafia knew my capabilities they would know I win here if left alive for more than 1 day as town. So mafia should kill me tonight.
Therefore the most optimal thing for me to do is die and give info on my way out, since I can give more info being the mislim than I can being NK'd.
What do you all think?
I think it's an open setup and you're full of shit.
Full of shit how?
I initially read this as referring to a role power. Now I get that you're just claiming s tier scum hunting skills.
In post 100, Claptastik wrote:
If they're a bad player it's cool. Fact is that d1 lims don't hit scum any better than random chance. So, taking out a person who's junking up the thread and will be difficult to read later is logical if no one is particularly scummy.
In post 140, Mizuki wrote:
I mean, I think you have a point in the PR's being easier to find, but also, the hypoclaims happen D2. The perfect scum game here is a 3-day game, and I think max is like 5? So I don't think the PR's being easier to find on D2 is really that much of a disaster. They ended up full-claiming on D2 last game anyways.
Feels worth considering maybe.
VT lim>VT NK leaves 5:2 T:S, and 3:2 vanilla:PR within town on D2, if PRs are found on D2 they'll really only ever be NKed and not eliminated (as long as they aren't speedwagoned).
So D3 you would in worst case be at 3:2 ELO with a flipped PRs result that is not a clear, maybe sometimes it's a clear like if a Rolecop finds a doctor, but keep in mind that last game we killed the Goon D1 so when the Roleblocker and Rolecop claimed their actions we had 4 clears. If we hadn't killed a Goon on D1 both of those results would be meaningless.
I don't think hypoclaiming D2 is right unless we are very careful to claim something that makes sense with our reads (which I was not, and to be fair that was my mistake). Even then I'm not sure, I don't think it works out if we haven't hit scum on D1.
Eh, fair enough. When I suggested it last game it was mostly as an off-the-cuff idea rather than something I had brainstormed zealously. I'm not a mechanical powerhouse by any means.
I get bad vibes about Claptastik's posting so far
VOTE: Claptastik
What about Clap's posting stands out? I feel like very little is standing out this game, except gob. All I can remember about Clap and Cook is them briefly talking about policy
She/Her - limited access on nights and weekends
"No ssbm is not grudging me. She's one of my favorites on the website, and i wanna say vice versa." - Transcend
The day senpai noticed me^
Dont think it makes sense for scum!gob to test cook like that unless the scumteam is exactly {gob,cook}, but if that's the case I don't think this play can ever work in the long haul
Cook I believe she could have thought she was dead because Mizuki's vote change was in a wall.
She/Her - limited access on nights and weekends
"No ssbm is not grudging me. She's one of my favorites on the website, and i wanna say vice versa." - Transcend
The day senpai noticed me^
