Eminence in Shadow: Season 1 [Game Over]

[SirCakez]

nobody should be getting overlooked at this point, there's only 5 other slots besides yourself

[tired person]

what did u find towny about sircakes?

[jjh927]

I thought he seemed to be genuinely struggling with the gamestate

I also thought penguin was a better direction to be looking at in the previous day phase than T3 but that turned out to be not true at all

I also noted more work being done to actually place people but looking back it's more like firing off stray shots

[jjh927]

With the first note, I am well aware that is easy to fake but I think I got a bit too big for my boots this game as I very much believed I could identify that kind of thing anyway

[Sakura Hana]

With the knowledge that T3 did indeed receive that neighborhood courtesy of Wheme's redirection i find it harder to justify neighborizing a partner making jjh less likely scum, of course it could also be some sort of mastermind plan by Pooky, so if at all i'd prefer to ignore the neighborhood entirely, but Wheme's and T3's flips make that harder. But overall i'm not sure his play matches what i remember from Anything Upick.
SirCakez is a hard sort for me because if he's scum that means Pooky crossbussed with 2 teammates early on, however i know this is possible for SirCakez to do, and apparently it's something Pooky is capable of doing as well. It's just a matter of in that gamestate if that's really what happened.
jjh i've had gut scum pings throughout majority of the game, i specially disliked the "T3 is solving in the neighborhood so he's town", however my issue here is that may have been T3's goal, coz as it's usually said, it's easier to fool 1 person than... however many townies alive were at the time.
PP i've had the opposite, i've had gut town pings, but the play seems more scummy than towny.
TP is someone i have a hard time placing by play, but by predecesor i find it hard to believe Gamma vs Ceph was SvS and T3 seemed interested in dismantling that notion so im inclined to believe i'm right on this.
Bingle i'm not sure how to read so i'm just placing him as town because of the Kawaii meta that Klick provided us.

So with that in mind
jjh > PP > Cakez > TP > Bingle

Scummiest to Towniest is where i stand right now.

[PenguinPower]

jjh > PP > Cakez > TP > Bingle

[Sakura Hana]

Not. Helping.

[PenguinPower]

[Sakura Hana]

Regardless it's probably just jjh anyway.
VOTE: jjh

[Sakura Hana]

PP outside of my read on you, do you have any thoughts on the other 4 reads i presented?

[PenguinPower]

[SirCakez]

With the knowledge that T3 did indeed receive that neighborhood courtesy of Wheme's redirection i find it harder to justify neighborizing a partner making jjh less likely scum, of course it could also be some sort of mastermind plan by Pooky, so if at all i'd prefer to ignore the neighborhood entirely, but Wheme's and T3's flips make that harder. But overall i'm not sure his play matches what i remember from Anything Upick.
SirCakez is a hard sort for me because if he's scum that means Pooky crossbussed with 2 teammates early on, however i know this is possible for SirCakez to do, and apparently it's something Pooky is capable of doing as well. It's just a matter of in that gamestate if that's really what happened.
jjh i've had gut scum pings throughout majority of the game, i specially disliked the "T3 is solving in the neighborhood so he's town", however my issue here is that may have been T3's goal, coz as it's usually said, it's easier to fool 1 person than... however many townies alive were at the time.
PP i've had the opposite, i've had gut town pings, but the play seems more scummy than towny.
TP is someone i have a hard time placing by play, but by predecesor i find it hard to believe Gamma vs Ceph was SvS and T3 seemed interested in dismantling that notion so im inclined to believe i'm right on this.
Bingle i'm not sure how to read so i'm just placing him as town because of the Kawaii meta that Klick provided us.

So with that in mind
jjh > PP > Cakez > TP > Bingle

Scummiest to Towniest is where i stand right now.

You still think PP is scummy despite EOD yesterday?

[Sakura Hana]

You still think PP is scummy despite EOD yesterday?

i dunno anything anymore, all i know is that TP and Bingle are most likely not scum, any of the other 3 could be, but im more positive on jjh than you or PP, if all of you think PP is very unlikely to be scum then we can just bin him as town together with TP and Bingle and it becomes a you vs jjh with 1 miselim remaining, a.k.a autowin.

[Sakura Hana]

Anyway back to Yakuza for me.

[tired person]

sakura, i agree that gut pings say pp is town but his play is scummy. that's why he's still in my pool. but do you have any reason to town read sircakes? because i don't, and that's what's making me think it's him. he's less scummy than pp and jjh, but he's also not towny at all, and i think that's what makes him scum.

but anyway i agree we're in autowin probably.

[PenguinPower]

Anyway back to Yakuza for me.

[SirCakez]

sakura, i agree that gut pings say pp is town but his play is scummy. that's why he's still in my pool. but do you have any reason to town read sircakes? because i don't, and that's what's making me think it's him. he's less scummy than pp and jjh, but he's also not towny at all, and i think that's what makes him scum.

but anyway i agree we're in autowin probably.

I don't understand this post, you're saying JJH and PP are scummier than me but I'm less towny then JJH and PP? How does that compute

[Firebringer]

Bingle is being prodded.

[Firebringer]

With the terrorist plot foiled. The school burnt down, our hero decided it was time for a vacation to the holy city of Lindwurm to see the goddess festival.

Day 6 - Lindwurm
Vote Count 6.01

jjh927 [2][E-2] Sircakez, Sakura Hana,
Sircakez [1][E-3] tired person,


Lurking in Shadows (Not Voting - 3) : jjh927, Bingle, Penguinpower,

With 6 Alive, It Takes 4 to Eliminate.
Deadline is (expired on 2024-02-10 11:44:00)

Mod Note: No mod notes

[SirCakez]

Bingle why have you been so quiet?

[SirCakez]

ok actually where tf is everyone

[PenguinPower]

Waiting for jjh or bingle to do something.

[PenguinPower]

Also playing yakuza.

Sujimon. Gotta catch em all.

[tired person]

sakura, i agree that gut pings say pp is town but his play is scummy. that's why he's still in my pool. but do you have any reason to town read sircakes? because i don't, and that's what's making me think it's him. he's less scummy than pp and jjh, but he's also not towny at all, and i think that's what makes him scum.

but anyway i agree we're in autowin probably.

I don't understand this post, you're saying JJH and PP are scummier than me but I'm less towny then JJH and PP? How does that compute

what i meant is that penguin has about 500 scum points for playstyle and maybe 400 town points for yesterday.
jjh has about 450 scum points for how he played yesterday, for his bad reads, and for his entrance today, but has maybe 150-200 town points for various reasons.
you have about 350 scum points for also having bad reads and especially the push on alisae, for having an out-of-step reaction to how people were considering if wheme needed to claim or not, and for basically not doing anything while also voting t3's counterwagon.
you also have 50 town points for your push on pooky.

however on rethinking this i am not so sure that jjh has more town points than you so i'll move my vote if he doesn't do anything convincing soon.

[jjh927]

I could give the play by play of the PT but I've been kinda waiting to see what bingle does